Posts from Mafia 90. The Tale of Oldforest.

1. What exactly did the GM mess up? So far, I've only seen a glitch with the display of the witch's tea, which gave Alex away. But judging by your words, there are tons of bugs and lags in the GM's game...
2. What caused the "balance to go to hell"? Was it because the Leshy successfully blocked your mage on the first night? Or because the Berehynia fed your teammate to the wolves instead of Alex? Well, the GM isn't to blame for that.:smile32:

Don't worry, I think the game won't last long, and you won't have to suffer much. You don't even need to wait in your network; I won't even watch it.

Just like with Mentu.

There was a mention of a voice change, so there was a basis to accuse the Shaman of voice-chatting. But there was also a basis not to accuse him, since it wasn't quite done correctly.

Added 1 minute ago
In my opinion, there are more grounds for complaints against the Moderator who violated rule 6.

Added 35 seconds ago
As well as against Ment.

Well, there wasn't an autopsy as such, especially for the mental.

Um, what? )

Regarding Drakkosha, I made a hint long ago. It's strange that no one paid attention to it knowing my role.

And how did I give away her role, essentially repeating once again what I had said earlier about not listing her as 100% town, because there's a possibility of this or that?

I thought that the rule didn't apply to situations where the role was already known anyway

That's not how it should be done, I think.

The game knowledge check revealed itself to me, and I was the one doing the check. But you still don't know what role he used his ultimate on.

Also, post the questions and answers.

1) You don't need to be Seneca to figure out that the Witch's Brew action can target not the player (Alex), but the role (the apprentice).
2) Having a turn order is a good thing (I remember the times when the GM took into account the order in which players sent messages in private, whoever sent it first got their turn). But it should still be divided into some groups: a group of actions, a group of blocks, a group of translations, a group of kills, etc. Otherwise, for example, a Lunar Bard cannot stop the witch's apprentice, the witch, the herbalist, or the Beregynya, and among the female characters, he can only charm a mermaid, who is already on his side.
3) It was very amusing to receive a message that we had "successfully" blocked the apprentice, who continued to run around and ask questions, even though she was supposed to be listening to concerts until dawn.
4) When the GM's lack of interest in the game and blatant disregard for the rules finally become noticeable (c) Shaman. It would be more honest to write: there are no rules, everything will be as the GM says!

The GM is an idiot.

The bug existed for 2 weeks, and no one noticed it = everyone is to blame.

I was just really afraid that because of this poll, the Mafia would expose me as a Priest (well, there was another role option, yes, but it wasn't entirely clear whether he had a kill or not).

That's exactly why I didn't kill Revan on the second night: I would definitely have used the redirect as the Mafia ;)

So, you answered in a way that any Mafia role would suit you? Well, you couldn't hide the Priest/Warlord option from the Mafia anyway (they know their own), but this creates confusion for the Town.

Well, it was clear to the Sorceress that she would be eliminated the next day, so she wasn't focused on redirecting, it was better to use her Ultimate ability and eliminate Alex, and then put the Ultimate ability of fire on herself. That's what the Mafia did...

in any case, I did the right thing by not going to war with Revan.

Honestly, I didn't really care.

Heh, I would have tried to do a double kill at the end, it's a more interesting option. Anyway, I did the right thing by not going to war with Revan.

There was no reveal, there was a leak of state secrets info that others shouldn't know.

That you can't do, IYAM.

Added after 33 seconds
Well, what do you mean no one? I contributed.:D Back when you were wandering around in the next world in the forest, I already started suspecting her based on the Leshy block. It's just that back then I was thinking about a swap, and once you said she could be mafia, then...

This - is a guess about Dracoshka's possible role. And this - is a disclosure of info that others aren't supposed to know.

So in answer to this question from Nefela I could have calmly answered that Hekasan is Darin, and nothing would have happened to me for it? And here I was a chump and didn't know...:( Though, Shaman and Oven wouldn't have believed it anyway — after all, it was a troll saying it...

Well, if this is a reason to award the Shaman a medal, then in my opinion, the one who starts changing the rules and balance after the game has already begun deserves it.
1) The set was in place for 2 weeks, and no one paid attention = everyone is to blame.
2) There was complete chaos in the order of actions initially. The points I raised were taken into account. No one else paid attention. See point 1). ;) By the way, the bard could have stopped all the characters you mentioned. But not with all the non-player characters.
3) Here, the question is about the effect of the block on doubled damage. One was blocked, the other was not. In the previous game, there was a similar situation with a troll and redirection. Here, the GM decides how the block/redirection works: on both damage types at once or only on the first. The only downside is that this should be written in the rules. But again, we didn't ask, and the GM overlooked it...
4) There are rules, and the GM didn't want to change them during the game. And that's exactly right!