Connection ErrorBad RequestSession ExpiredSign in requiredForbiddenNot FoundToo Many RequestsServer ErrorBad GatewayService UnavailableGateway TimeoutHTTP Version Not Supported
Session Expired
Your session has expired. Please log in to continue.
Sign in required
You need an account to do that. Sign in or create one — it only takes a minute.
Request Failed
We encountered an issue while processing your request.
Please check your internet connection and try again.
There are no 4 roles in the newspaper; something from the first 4 is assigned to the lizard: 1. Healing for Usagi, then he is not Mafia. and Mafia are losers 3. Guarding Kino Makoto. 4. Guarding Aino Minako. 5. Killing Mafia Doesn't look like guarding, either block or healing. More likely a block. Then, there are 2 peaceful roles or a Mafia role assigned to the lizard, considering that Aino Minako blocked the guard. UPD: Mafia are stuck on either block or natural defense.
It's all a bit confusing. Stop mixing everyone up.
SnowmanV2
11 years ago
Auto-translated
Reread the newspaper (oh, these Japanese names are so confusing), the city block was mentioned. But there was no mention of a mafia blockade. So, the lizard could have been blocked by them.
Siverfale
11 years ago
Auto-translated
You're a pro, so you don't even need to read it.
Guys, let's kill the "Heroes" player last; I like him.
SnowmanV2
11 years ago
Auto-translated
It's all a bit confusing. Stop mixing everything up.
I just listed the roles that weren't mentioned in the newspaper but should have been.)
Added 1 minute ago I'll write it concisely, what was missing: 1. Usagi. 2. Makoto 3. Minako. 4. Mafia kills. 5. Mafia blocks. Something from this list, except for the mafia kills, was used on Yashur.
Драккошка
11 years ago
Auto-translated
Why even bother reading the story? Just execute everyone according to the rules, and that's it.
KindShaman
11 years ago
Auto-translated
No, the GM put a lot of effort into it and wrote it... It would be a shame not to read it. You should respect other people's work.
I just listed the roles that weren't mentioned in the newspaper but should have been)
Added 1 minute ago I'll write it concisely, what was missing: 1. Usagi. 2. Makoto 3. Minako. 4. Mafia kills. 5. Mafia blocks. Something from this, except for the mafia kill, was used on Yashur.
1. Healing Usagi, then he's not mafia.
let's assume the healing happened. Where did you get that conclusion from?
Why even read the storyline? Just execute everyone according to the lore, and that's it.
I always play like that, I recommend it; the games end in two nights, and the investigators are very scared.
SnowmanV2
11 years ago
Auto-translated
Let's say Yashura was blocked by the Mafia. Then he's either player 1, 2, or 3, or the Mafia messed up and blocked their own killer. This explains the absence of a Night Detective (ND) in the newspaper. The fact that there's no ND for Minako is explained by her greed. The Mafia is focused on defense. What's up with Makoto is unclear.
Added after 47 seconds
it seems they've already decided that Revan was blocked
I've already rewritten this. There's so much flood that I can't keep up with reading everything.
Added after 1 minute
The dust still doesn't look like healing. If the victim had been healed, the fight would have been described accurately.
The Mafia could have aimed for a natural defense. The second Mafia night action could have been a check, and the third, logically, would have been a block, but it seems to always be displayed. Maybe they decided not to narrow down the circle of suspects and used a misdirection, for example, or didn't take a third night action at all.
Regarding Yashur, I agree it was either a heal or a defense. Most likely the latter. Our options are either a neutral night action or an ontology check, which is risky.
KindShaman
11 years ago
Auto-translated
Snow, please express your thoughts more specifically, otherwise even I get confused by your abstractions.
Added 2 minutes later
I think we should wait for everyone to express their opinions first, and then we'll decide who to punish and for what reasons.
Okay, let's assume that. Where is the hint about this? The Mafia seems to have a blocker who is an ice mage. What does magic dust have to do with it? (Correct me if I'm missing something about the theme of this game)
