Posts from Мафия 85. Lux in tenebris

BuglerV, I have almost no doubt that you are either a Townie or a Mafia member. Townies don't play like that. I'm trying to act in the most correct and safe way for the town right now; it's mathematically calculated, not based on some "psychology" that you use to make absurd accusations against me. If you've decided to play the psychologist, think about it: does it really make sense for a Townie to get into an argument on the very first day and make enemies? And then try to help the town make the only correct decision right now, instead of disappearing into the night like always.

Meaning 1: The Mafia stirs up trouble and makes enemies for themselves, only to later claim that there was no point in the Mafia's actions.
Meaning 2: Mr. X is actually an informant, and the Mafia learned something about Vistyr, which makes her specifically dangerous to the Mafia.
Meaning 3: A simple attempt to seize the initiative.
Meaning 4: To make the town discuss this topic while someone else nearby is exposed, possibly in a newspaper. A distraction.
Meaning 5: Creating a possible NON-pairing with Vistyr, so that later, if Vistyr turns out to be Mafia, they can say, "See, I voted him out on the first day."
Meaning 6: Throwing out information to the town, suggesting that they vote out someone, so that if the town agrees, it will reduce the number of people in the town.
Meaning 7: Throwing out information to the town, suggesting that they vote out someone, so that later, if someone agrees, they can say, "Look, he agreed, he doesn't care who he votes out, he's with the Mafia." In other words, a setup.
Meaning 8: Searching for and eliminating a role that is dangerous to the Mafia. For example, the Orc. Let's say the Orc blocked a Mafia member that night, which means he will finish them off the next night. It would be beneficial for the Mafia to find him and neutralize him so that an unsuccessful attempt doesn't appear in the newspaper.

I think we can go on for a long time....

I'm heading home, Ursula and Bugler, could you write a post summarizing today's blah-blah? And write it in one post, showing who voted against whom?

Everything you wrote applies to you as well, including you, oh psychologist.

Well, then... Maybe you'd like to support me just for a change? ))

But he simply responded to your statement about not having any motives to behave in that way, if you were a Mafia member, and nothing more.

If everything is unclear and we are heading towards a no-win scenario, then you can execute me, for example. I wouldn't mind being known as a complete pacifist – on the condition that the chaplain agrees to resurrect me.

This is all reinventing the wheel and pulling ideas out of thin air. Such behavior is a big and not entirely justified risk for a Mafia, especially when there is no support. Theoretically, I could actually do this, but do I need to?

It doesn't matter. The point is that such a possibility exists in principle (he could have chosen the appropriate option based on the described scenarios, or he might not have, and no one can know for sure except for you). To claim that it is absolutely impossible is at least strange.