HeroesWorld

Posts from philosophy

Philosophy
3.7 (3 ratings)
In reply to AlexeyPank
User Avatar
Offline <garkin>
Registered:
Posts: 329
#1180
Auto-translated
AlexeyPank;62542
That's right. And that's absolutely true. And the day before Bloody Sunday, he was in the Winter Palace and reported on the upcoming action and its purpose – to submit a petition. And it was Nicholas who chose the specific course of events that unfolded.
Hmm... well, I won't argue, as I don't know... I did read that he was hired by someone very influential to identify a double agent in the Tsarist security service, who later turned out to be Evno Azev, who was also a leader (though Savinkov was more of a leader) of the SR Combat Organization... but that's all just speculation:cool:
Плоды размышлений были съедены червями сомнения...
0
⚖️
0
User Avatar
Offline AlexeyPank
Registered:
Posts: 2,416
#1181
Auto-translated
Yes, history is a complex subject. I personally believe that history should not involve subjective evaluations. It should only contain facts and explanations of patterns. Otherwise, it becomes completely incomprehensible.
Мы спасемся? Я не знаю. Верьте...
Геройский Интернационал
Клан Homo homini - основатель клана
Член РКСМ с 07.07.07.
ФЛУДОВСКИЕ ССЫЛКИ!- сообщить о бесполезной теме/сообщении.
0
⚖️
0
In reply to AlexeyPank
User Avatar
Offline <garkin>
Registered:
Posts: 329
#1182
Auto-translated
AlexeyPank;62546
Yes, history is a tricky subject. I personally believe that history shouldn't involve evaluations. It should only contain facts and explanations of patterns. Otherwise, it becomes completely incomprehensible.
No matter how you look at it, it ends up being confusing... history is a subjective science... we will never know exactly how things were in the past, because different people perceive the same fact differently, and historians are no exception... and history wasn't written by just one person...
Плоды размышлений были съедены червями сомнения...
0
⚖️
0
User Avatar
Offline AlexeyPank
Registered:
Posts: 2,416
#1183
Auto-translated
We should treat history not as a humanitarian science, but as a natural science. Where everything is subject to strict laws. I like a quote by L.N. Gumilev: "What can a chemist teach if he says he loves alkalis and hates acids?" The same applies to history – we shouldn't love anything; we should simply present it as it is.
Мы спасемся? Я не знаю. Верьте...
Геройский Интернационал
Клан Homo homini - основатель клана
Член РКСМ с 07.07.07.
ФЛУДОВСКИЕ ССЫЛКИ!- сообщить о бесполезной теме/сообщении.
0
⚖️
0
In reply to AlexeyPank
User Avatar
Offline <garkin>
Registered:
Posts: 329
#1184
Auto-translated
AlexeyPank;62548
The same applies to history – there’s no need to love something; you just need to present it as it is.
In my opinion, this is a utopia... So, it reminded me of something: I like it when football commentators don't show their preference for any particular team, but lately, it's become so obvious that it's outrageous... If a couple of years ago, a commentator "supported" (what a silly word) a team from their hometown, or, like 30 years ago, all commentators voted for the weaker team, today every Moscow commentator has a team (there are plenty of them in Moscow) for which they say encouraging words or express paternal disapproval...
Плоды размышлений были съедены червями сомнения...
0
⚖️
0
User Avatar
Offline AlexeyPank
Registered:
Posts: 2,416
#1185
Auto-translated
That's right. And it's unclear why all this is necessary. Expressing personal preferences makes sense only when it doesn't harm the cause.
Мы спасемся? Я не знаю. Верьте...
Геройский Интернационал
Клан Homo homini - основатель клана
Член РКСМ с 07.07.07.
ФЛУДОВСКИЕ ССЫЛКИ!- сообщить о бесполезной теме/сообщении.
0
⚖️
0
In reply to AlexeyPank
User Avatar
Offline СКИФ
Registered:
Posts: 118
#1186
Auto-translated
AlexeyPank;62536
I love it when people start praising Nicholas II. Do you think the Tsar couldn't have known why people were coming to him? Considering that a provocateur from the secret police was leading the crowd? And that a minister could have started a war without the Tsar's knowledge? What kind of Tsar is he, if he's not involved in anything?
I thought we had already dissected and analyzed everything about Nicholas and Stalin. But it turns out there are still people who are convinced of Stalin's worthlessness and Nicholas II's complete innocence.
But I think we won't give up and will continue to open people's eyes to the truth.:smile14:
Пуля производит удивительные изменения в голове, даже если она попадает в за***цу.
0
⚖️
0
User Avatar
Offline AlexeyPank
Registered:
Posts: 2,416
#1187
Auto-translated
This is a favorite pastime – gossiping about others. This is a characteristic of humanity.
Мы спасемся? Я не знаю. Верьте...
Геройский Интернационал
Клан Homo homini - основатель клана
Член РКСМ с 07.07.07.
ФЛУДОВСКИЕ ССЫЛКИ!- сообщить о бесполезной теме/сообщении.
0
⚖️
0
In reply to СКИФ
User Avatar
Offline <garkin>
Registered:
Posts: 329
#1188
Auto-translated
SKIF;62562
I thought we had already discussed every aspect of Cole and Stalin. But it turns out there are still people who are convinced of Stalin's worthlessness and Cole 2nd's complete innocence.
But I think we won't give up and will continue to open people's eyes to the truth.:smile14:
Read the posts more carefully, or get some glasses:smile19: and then post yourself {think first - then do}. No one here is bashing Stalin, and no one considers N2 a saint...:smile22:
Плоды размышлений были съедены червями сомнения...
0
⚖️
0
User Avatar
Offline СКИФ
Registered:
Posts: 118
#1189
Auto-translated
That’s exactly what I was thinking. First, read the posts by Dracolich and Saruman. What a champion of good and justice, just like Sailor Moon:smile06:! You won’t get away with this next time!:smile22:
Пуля производит удивительные изменения в голове, даже если она попадает в за***цу.
0
⚖️
0
User Avatar
Offline AlexeyPank
Registered:
Posts: 2,416
#1190
Auto-translated
It's strange how much time has passed, how many events have occurred, yet Stalin and Nicholas II remain the most discussed figures. And the most discussed topics are the revolution and the repressions. Few delve deeply into the past, and even fewer are satisfied with the present. Here's another paradox: the 20th century is the closest to us, yet we know less truth about it than we do about primitive people. And in general, textbooks should be written with space for adjustments, so that with each change in the "general line," one could simply pencil in the necessary names and epithets. Something like this: "Thanks to the heroic/significant/unnecessary efforts of Lenin/Stalin/Putin, the most just/dishonest/cruel society in the world was built (underline the appropriate one)."
Мы спасемся? Я не знаю. Верьте...
Геройский Интернационал
Клан Homo homini - основатель клана
Член РКСМ с 07.07.07.
ФЛУДОВСКИЕ ССЫЛКИ!- сообщить о бесполезной теме/сообщении.
0
⚖️
0
In reply to СКИФ
User Avatar
Offline <garkin>
Registered:
Posts: 329
#1191
Auto-translated
SKIF;62562

But I think we won't give up and will continue to open people's eyes to the truth.
and what is this, does it mean you know how it all really was???
:smile26:
no one will know the truth, your truth is subjective just like any other... your truth for other people is someone else's...
Плоды размышлений были съедены червями сомнения...
0
⚖️
0
In reply to <garkin>
User Avatar
Offline СКИФ
Registered:
Posts: 118
#1192
Auto-translated
;62631
No one will ever know the truth; your truth is as subjective as any other... your truth is alien to other people.
Well, I wouldn't say that; as far as I know, Alex agrees with me on these issues.
Пуля производит удивительные изменения в голове, даже если она попадает в за***цу.
0
⚖️
0
In reply to СКИФ
User Avatar
Offline <garkin>
Registered:
Posts: 329
#1193
Auto-translated
SKIF;62641
I wouldn't say so, as far as I know, Alex agrees with me on these issues.
regarding which these??? if it's about history, then there are as many opinions as there are people!!! (fact)
Плоды размышлений были съедены червями сомнения...
0
⚖️
0