Posts from Mafia: general discussions. Auto-translated

And what exactly are you planning here? Want to start a revolution? They don't like their ХВ mafia... the nights are too long for them... the clues are too easy/hard... or maybe you'll even go out to the maidan square? That's how it all starts. First they don't like the mafia, then the site, then the moderators, the God-Creator... and then what, you'll force everyone to be gay? Huh? Completely out of control! If I were the coordinator, I'd shoot you all on the spot. Look at what they've come up with! Go work play! Sitting here, philosophizing, instead of guessing the clues.

They sit here and speculate instead of looking for clues.

But it's night. At night, they don't look for clues; at night, they sleep. And those who can't sleep sit and speculate.:p

Added 6 minutes later

What are you planning here? Do you want to start a revolution?

No, sir, this is not called a revolution; this is called a reform.:D

This is called reform.

It all starts here...

The admin will come and restore order! Whoever isn't sleeping is a Muscovite

I don't understand what the problem is. Those who don't like writing in the thread at night don't write, and those who do like it, do. What's with these strict limitations? The "89 Mafia" game went well. The players are reasonable and know what they should and shouldn't write. If something is inappropriate, the GM will warn them.

The problem is that those who enjoy writing at night have an advantage over those who don't. As a result, those who don't enjoy it are forced to constantly monitor the thread.

The players are reasonable and know what they should and shouldn't write.

You don't know the players. Even the most reasonable ones (like me) sometimes break the rules.

If something happens, the GM will warn them.

Well, the GM will have to monitor the thread. But, in my opinion, there's no problem. Whether to allow off-topic chatter at night or not is up to the GM.

like me

As a compromise, we can allow everyone to write a post summarizing the execution and then go to sleep.

Allow me to add my two cents. I am FOR discussing things at night, as long as the GM doesn't mind.
It seems to be a matter of habit. Like Mika, Owen, GK, Kostyakk, whom I actually invited here when we were short on players, we came from a resource where it's okay to write in the thread at night.
The only thing, in my opinion, that they missed as an argument is that we have different "newspapers." We don't write them the same way as here. Here, nicknames of people who visited someone are revealed. That is, the fact of a bodyguard's visit is not described: Player X guarded Player Y all night. We write the result. If the Night Duty worked. For example, if the Night Duty of the Bodyguard is to kill the attacker targeting their protected target, it would be described something like this: Today, he was wrong in thinking that killing the target would be easy. And this mistake cost him his life. ***Mika was killed***
Then come the hints. Not about the profile, but about the quest. Thus, nicknames are not revealed in the "newspaper," only the result is revealed. And people can discuss it without revealing their identities, both during the day and at night.
I want to thank the Master. We really did have normal discussions at night in his game, and there were no incidents.

We don't log the usernames of those who visited someone else. That is, the fact of a bodyguard's visit is not described: Player X guarded Player Y all night. We write the result. If the bodyguard's skill was successful. For example, if the bodyguard's skill is to kill the attacker of his target, it will be described like this: Today, he was wrong, thinking that killing the target would be easy. And this mistake cost him his life. ***Mika was killed***

I wonder, what if they were protecting the wrong person, the one who was being targeted? Is there no display at all? No blocks, no protection, no healing? What is displayed then? Just corpses?:smile04:

Come on, it's a pretty classic Mafia game. "Good morning, you're dead. Nothing else happened, I won't say which role was killed, figure out who the Mafia are." But ours is modified, yes.

Therefore, I'm not sure it's a good idea to randomly mix the classic and our current Mafia content. As I mentioned, there's an entire section dedicated to the classic version, and it's completely inactive.

"Good morning, you're dead. Nothing else happened, I won't say which role was killed, look for the Mafia."

Well, I participated in such a game once. The first newspaper there was like this: "Nobody died. The 2nd turn begins.":D:D:D I don't really feel like participating in something like that anymore. I prefer normal games.:smile08:

Here's an analysis of newspapers – that's the most interesting part. You can't create newspapers with just one line.