Skip to content

Posts from Appeals Committee. Disputed situations in tournaments.

No ratings yet — be the first to rate!
User Avatar
#610
Auto-translated
Well, why don't you start by holding a vote to decide whether Katherine should participate in the season? I'm even curious to see what the players decide...
If there's a unanimous NO, then we can move forward with banning her for cheating.
In reply to RiMpel2
User Avatar
#611
Auto-translated
RiMpel2
There's no point in this "Cheater Mark of Shame"...
You say there's no point in the "Cheater Mark of Shame," yet you've written an entire page of complaints. The original idea behind the "Cheater Mark of Shame" was to inform all players that the player with the mark may be cheating. In other words, the "Cheater Mark of Shame" doesn't prohibit anything. If someone wants to play with Catherine, that's their right. Regarding tournaments, naturally, no organizer would include such a player in a tournament. However, the "Cheater Mark of Shame" can be removed for good behavior, and this has already happened with vitalic. There was even a poll in which the option "remove the Cheater Mark of Shame" won by a large margin, but that was six months after it was awarded.

Regarding the season. A season is not a tournament. In tournaments, opponents are determined by a draw, but when people play whoever they want and as much as they want, that's no longer a tournament, but a circus, even if a reward is given. Therefore, I have nothing against players with the "Cheater Mark of Shame" participating in a season, especially if there are reports and saves.
In reply to Dirty_Player
User Avatar
#612
Auto-translated
I can't understand why there's so much aggression. Since its creation, Heroes of Might and Magic Online has only restricted access to tournaments for obvious reasons. Has anyone's gameplay been negatively affected? It would be better if everyone played stronger; then cheaters wouldn't be such a hindrance.
Земля нуля.
Все в ней нулево и кукольно.
In reply to RiMpel2
User Avatar
#613
Auto-translated
RiMpel2

I think this is a sign of weakness from the local moderators when they see a "sweet, defenseless girl" who, not only behaves like a

Moderated: OFFENSIVE LANGUAGE in the message

b!tch
in personal communication, but also brazenly comes to the forum with the attitude of "oh, I accidentally did it, I didn't mean to, I swear, I won't do it again."
Publicly insulting a girl is much lower than cheating. :smile18: According to the forum rules, this user should be given penalty points for this.
В дикім полі
In reply to Dirty_Player
User Avatar
#614
Auto-translated
Dirty_Player
... a ban can be lifted for good behavior; there was already a case with vitalic. There was even a poll, in which the option "lift the ban" won by a large margin, but that was six months after the ban was issued...
Here is a great solution to the problem. Even in prison, a person can be released early for good behavior. :smile36: But for this, a person needs to be given a chance to rehabilitate themselves, and not be driven into a corner. And if this is a repeat offender who does not want a different life for himself, then there is no point in being lenient with such a person. :smile51:
By the way, I chatted with Katerina in a private message - I have the opposite opinion about her. No arrogance, or anything else - she is a perfectly normal person. Apparently, the approach was different.
Техника в руках индейца мертва.
Справочник по НоММ-4 http://handbookhmm.ru/pamyatka-dlya-heroes-iv.html
Памятка по НоММ-3 http://handbookhmm.ru/pamyatka-dlya-homm-iii.html
и HotA http://handbookhmm.ru/vyishla-obnovlennaya-pamyatka-dlya-homm-iii-hota.html
In reply to злой_романтик
User Avatar
#615
Auto-translated
evil_romantic
During my conversation with Rbv, he expressed some thoughts about playing for money and that he was already doing it, and he mentioned names like Preds and Alexzegreat. I wonder if this is true or just another lie.

Once, I played with him, either for a bottle of beer or for 2, and I lost.
I haven't analyzed the saves, but if needed, I can ask Aztec to retrieve them if they were saved (I was in Odessa with him at that time).
The worst thing is that, I think, last winter, I met Rbv in a club in Moscow, he was playing funk live in a club with DirectX, and as far as I remember, he even won. In terms of gameplay, he was a very careful player, without taking many risks.
I would never have thought that he would start cheating. Why?
In reply to dnaop-wr
#616
Auto-translated
dnaop-wr

By the way, I chatted with Katerina in a private message – I have the opposite opinion about her. No arrogance or anything else – she’s a perfectly normal person. Apparently, the approach was different.

I agree. Rimple has a strange reaction to some people. I remember him wanting to take away the medal from the winner of the previous Novice tournament because he played a dozen weak, uninspired games on HotA. If he dislikes someone, he really dislikes them.
In reply to theShevanesian
User Avatar
#617
Auto-translated
theShevanesian
I agree. Rimple has a strange reaction to some people. I remember him wanting to take away the medal from the winner of the previous Novice tournament because he played a dozen weak, uninspired games on Haven. He really doesn't like someone, he really doesn't like them.

I communicated with her when I was asking about Sylvan... Believe me, Rimple didn't exaggerate at all... it was wrong of him to say it so publicly, but the fact remains. Maybe she has changed now (although I highly doubt it)...
Удача любит подготовленных!!!





Стримы и обучение тут:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCWlnXU5R5RLCMuWzIpBc65Q
User Avatar
#618
Auto-translated
I agree. Rimpel has a strange reaction to some people. I remember him wanting to take away the medal from the winner of the previous Novice tournament because he played a dozen weak, uninspired games on Haven. If he dislikes someone, he really dislikes them.
I'll dislike you now, see :smile10:
In reply to RiMpel2
#619
Auto-translated
RiMpel2
I won't even like you now, yeah :smile10:
You scared me!
In reply to Gomunguls
User Avatar
#620
Auto-translated
Gomunguls
I communicated with her when I was asking about Sylvan... Believe me, Rimpel didn't exaggerate at all... although he shouldn't have said it so publicly, but the fact remains. Maybe she has changed now (although I highly doubt it)...
I haven't seen your correspondence or Rimpel's, but I want to point out one thing: if you write to a person:
"Hello. I'm so-and-so, and I wanted to clarify a couple of things with you regarding this and that" or "Ah, you lying b\*\*\*h, what are you doing, what's in your saves..." - then, obviously, you will get a corresponding answer.

I'll immediately clarify that I'm exaggerating a bit, but I think the point is clear.
In reply to theShevanesian
User Avatar
#621
Auto-translated
theShevanesian
Katya actually withdrew from the tournament herself after winning a match due to her cheating. In my opinion, she doesn't deserve to be banned from tournaments, and they could have given her a second chance, but the organizers decided otherwise.
I understand that you're playing the role of a defender and all that :) Winning means defeating your opponent. In our game, Katerina lost at 111. Please call things by their proper names; otherwise, it just seems incorrect.
In reply to Volodymyr
#622
Auto-translated
Volodymyr
I understand that you're a hero and a defender, and all that :) Winning means defeating your opponent. In our game, Kateryna lost on turn 111. Please call things by their proper names, otherwise it just seems a bit incorrect :)

Why a hero? Just a defender. Well, yes, since you advanced further, you won.

By the way, I heard about your battle at three o'clock, where you moved each unit for 10 minutes; I decided for myself that if we ever play against each other and you repeat those tricks, I'll just go to sleep.
In reply to theShevanesian
User Avatar
#623
Auto-translated
I don't really want to clutter the thread; these are more like posts for show, but it's okay, they'll move them later.
theShevanesian
Well, yeah, since you got further, you won.
Please don't distort things anymore, if it's not too much trouble.
theShevanesian
By the way, I heard about your battle at three o'clock, where you moved each unit for 10 minutes;
There was a battle, it was difficult for me, is it written somewhere that you can't think for too long?
theShevanesian
I decided for myself that if we happen to play against each other somewhere
God willing, we won't.
theShevanesian
and you start doing these tricks again, then I'll just go to sleep.
So what? Go to sleep, is that a big problem?
#624
Auto-translated
Well, we’ve reached an agreement.