Posts from Appeals Committee. Disputed situations in tournaments.

This isn't a straightforward situation. On Diamond, for example, the portal could easily be broken on turn 112. And even on X3DM1, it's not uncommon for it to be broken on the first turn, although this isn't a very likely occurrence.

Regarding the main point: I believe that the current logic of the Overlord's Hour (OH) required a replay of the Blue player's last turn, but Zee should have demanded this immediately (it seems from the stream that he immediately understood what happened and could have not waited for the results of all the previous battles). However, after Red had already moved and won 3 battles against Blue, the opportunity was lost. You formally agreed with what was happening as soon as you started moving in the first combat encounter.

If the current logic requires loading and replaying a turn, it's bad logic. Either we play until a draw is reached, or we rely on the turn-breaking algorithm built into the HD mod. Otherwise, for the sake of saving 1 hour (this is a very optimistic estimate of the time saved from the end of restarts per match and the end of the turn limit), we risk creating a situation in the match where a turn is replayed, taking into account the huge additional amount of information obtained during the replayed turn.

P.S. and no, 4 turns per hour are usually not played on x3dm1.

What if, when playing with turn-based mode, you follow the turn order according to the gameplay? For example, if red goes first, then after their turn 122, they wait for the opponent to finish their turn 122. Or vice versa, if blue finishes their turn 122, they don't start turn 123 until red finishes their turn 123?

This isn't a simple scenario. On Diamond, for example, the portal can easily be broken on turn 112. And even on X3DM1, it's often broken on the first turn, although this encounter isn't particularly likely.

This isn't a straightforward situation. On Diamond, for example, the portal can easily be broken on turn 112. And even on X3DM1, it's often broken on the first turn, although this encounter isn't particularly likely.

Regarding the main topic: I believe that the current logic of the game required a replay of the blue player's last turn, but Zee should have requested this immediately (it seems from the stream that he immediately understood what happened and could have not waited for the outcomes of all the previous battles). But by then, after the red player had already moved and won 3 battles against the blue player, it was too late. You formally agreed with what was happening as soon as you started moving in the first combat encounter.

The following users participated in the discussion and voted on this decision: Redwhait, Nitro, =Stinger=, Mizrael, злой_романтик, Dirty_Player

Where is the promised topic about the meeting minutes of the Arbitration Committee?

just like everything promised, it requires a three-year wait.

I'll say it again: I realized that the original game mechanics were disrupted precisely in the last battle. Accusing me of cheating or deception is possible, of course, but I've never given any reason for it, and it's at least inappropriate of you to do so. The same applies to Cobra.