Connection ErrorBad RequestThis page went staleSession ExpiredSign in requiredForbiddenNot FoundToo Many RequestsServer ErrorBad GatewayService UnavailableGateway TimeoutHTTP Version Not Supported
Session Expired
Your session has expired. Please log in to continue.
Sign in required
You need an account to do that. Sign in or create one — it only takes a minute.
This page went stale
Your security token was rejected, usually because the page sat open too long or you signed in elsewhere. Nothing was saved. Reload the page and try again.
Request Failed
We encountered an issue while processing your request.
Please check your internet connection and try again.
Error Details:
Share Link
Posts from What types of combat do fans of Heroes enjoy?
Another very fun and useful activity is jiu-jitsu (there might be spelling errors). I didn't really learn jiu-jitsu properly, but the coach showed some very good grappling techniques. It seems to consist of strikes and grappling, and there's also a very sadistic stance called kibodachi. The legs are bent at a 90-degree angle and spread apart. People with average fitness can stand like that for 2-3 minutes :smile25:
Умирает не тот, кто устал, а тот, кто остановился.
And for some reason, I used to think that karate was the coolest type of martial art... it turns out that's not the case)). Although, again, a person needs to use their head; the question is only about the level of skill.
A karate practitioner has less chance of defeating a judoka of equal strength. After hundreds of thousands of falls during training, a judoka doesn't feel punches very much and can calmly take down an opponent and finish them on the ground (I've tried it myself). In such a case, a karate practitioner might be helped by strikes to various pressure points (e.g., a heel strike to the groin).
Умирает не тот, кто устал, а тот, кто остановился.
voted for karate! because I've been practicing it for 2 years. Kyokushin style (Kyokushinkai, Kio-kushinkai... there are many variations in spelling).
Agilist
A karate practitioner has less chance of defeating (in the sense of winning) a judoka of equal strength.
I don't quite agree with you. It all depends on the karate style. I can say that since Kyokushin is a contact style, all contact styles are also not very receptive to blows. For example, in our training, we have sparring sessions where we only hit each other (within reasonable limits, of course). And then there are sparring matches... so we are generally crazy :smile04: :smile10:
I voted for karate! because I've been practicing it for 2 years. Kyokushin style (Kyokushinkai, Kio-kushinkai... there are many variations in spelling)
I don't quite agree with you. It all depends on the karate style. I can say that since Kyokushin is a contact style, all contact styles are not very receptive to blows. For example, in our training, we have drills where we only hit each other (within reasonable limits, of course). And then there are sparring sessions... so we are generally crazy :smile04: :smile10: :smile26: :D So, even hand-to-hand combat specialists won't always be able to defeat a karate practitioner.
And in our training, we are thrown onto the tatami many times (it's not that soft), and the only unpadded area is the shins (which hurt quite a bit after sparring with karate practitioners). By the way, padding won't help against a judoka, because a judoka doesn't hit (we are a rather peaceful people), but throws, twists, and chokes. Wouldn't padding help against that?
Умирает не тот, кто устал, а тот, кто остановился.
I don't know about "breaking" or "choking," but a karate practitioner can withstand several falls. And a karate practitioner won't just stand there; their legs move like a butterfly. If you miss one strike, it becomes quite difficult to recover. And if the strike lands on the head, that's the end of the sparring match.
In principle, this is what sets us apart. You are peaceful, while we work in full contact.
I completely agree with Agilist, as I myself practice judo. Hard throws (especially the single leg takedown:D) are performed on a hard mat, so you can consider the whole body to be bruised... A karate practitioner has an advantage – their legs. BUT! in a street fight, there will inevitably be contact sooner or later. It won't be a problem for a wrestler to put the opponent on their back. (Hip throw, back arch, leg sweep – there's a whole range of options:D)
Added after 1 minute A judoka has reactions to both hands and legs (this is developed through grappling). So, you can catch a leg or an arm and do something with it:D
To end the fight, you need to close the distance, but a skilled fighter (boxer, karateka, etc.) will try to maintain that distance, and if their technique, speed, and striking power are at a high level (and they have a good head on their shoulders)... one clear hit will do the trick (no matter how many times a day you fall on your butt on the tatami and toughen up). In general, who has a better chance is a debatable question. The kibodachi stance exists in karate as well (although it's not very useful... it's purely for kata and aesthetics, and for showing off - IMHO, it's only good for getting beaten up...).
Let's not talk about boxers. I saw how sambo wrestlers, in one friendly tournament, simply took down one boxer after another, and none of the boxers could do anything except look surprised. We, in turn, kept taking them down until they fell. Boxing is, of course, a tough sport, but not very effective in a fight. It's just too specialized.
I don't know about "breaking" or "suffocating," but a karateka will withstand several falls. Besides, a karateka won't just stand there; their feet "fly" like butterflies... if you miss one strike, it'll be quite difficult to recover. And if the strike was to the head, that's the end of the sparring session. Basically, that's how we differ. You are peaceful, and we work in full contact
1. A karateka might not withstand a skillful throw, after which you can only breathe slowly, your lungs hurt, and questions arise in your head: "Where? Who am I?" 2. The strike must be specifically to the head (and a clean one) or to the groin. I've checked myself; other strikes (even to the solar plexus) are merely irritating. 3. Agreed, a successful strike to the head can end the fight. Just one question: "What would stop a judoka from simply reaching out and grabbing the head with their arms (assuming they are stupid)"
Умирает не тот, кто устал, а тот, кто остановился.
We had two schools in our city: Boxing and Judo... No matter how many fights and skirmishes there were, Judo always won only a few times... Boxers were always the first, even when they were outnumbered... as Snowball rightly said - it's all about distance, and I completely agree with him. In general, Judo is a sport... and Boxing is a fight...
OptiMAL
