Posts from Mafia: general discussions. Auto-translated

Quote:
"Andrey already felt the cold tentacles of death1 behind him; he looked one last time with tears in his eyes2 at the setting sun3 and vanished into oblivion."
There are three clues here, but two are incorrect. This encourages dialogue. Or one clue, but which points to several people. Also, to facilitate dialogue.

What exactly is a key role?

So, you weren't convincing enough or you didn't manage to convey your idea correctly.

Here, the question needs to be phrased differently: in which game did the town win thanks to good daytime play? Without any distribution of night actions or other giveaways, but simply thanks to constructive dialogue and accurate conclusions.

then the mafia will constantly win

In which game did the town pull through thanks to good daytime play? Without any night action distribution or other incriminating clues, but simply due to constructive dialogue and correct conclusions.

By the way, that's an interesting idea. If you explain it in more detail, I'll implement it in my next game .

Arandor's body lay in a pit shrouded in thick smoke. The fractured skull indicated a powerful blow from a hammer.

Arandor's body was found only at noon - the fog carefully concealed the crime for a long time.

In this case, I meant blockers. A very important in-game role that provides information for daytime discussion.

But how should I convey it then?

Do you think that removing notes and blocking will improve the quality of the game? I'm afraid the daytime discussion will be even more sluggish, and there will be nothing to have a constructive dialogue about. You yourself wrote that...

But how will the town then figure out which of the clues is the real one? I like this option more than the current one because then the clues will fit into the setting and won't stand out from the newspaper (although there are such clues even now). But will this really help the town?

It's important, but often it also unfairly targets players. There shouldn't be easy wins:)

Be more persistent and convincing. No one is saying it will work on the first try.

If it's not removed, there definitely won't be any progress. I don't think it can get any worse.

Maybe instead of notes, we could implement "wills," as Ple-Sen suggested? And the will could only be written before the in-game death, so the information from the last night is automatically excluded. Also, the block could be made invisible. We can reinforce the check with links to blockers or city archers.

Seriously, using blurry avatars as clues?

Decrees are again a very big advantage for the town.
The town doesn't need to be strengthened; it's fine as it is. If you constantly help the town, you won't make any progress. You need to give the town challenges that are solvable but require effort. Let it fail to win on the first, maybe even the second or third attempt, but it's impossible to progress by setting easy, rather than difficult, conditions for yourself.