Posts from Mafia: general discussions. Auto-translated

This is all not serious. If desired, a draw (or a tie) can be achieved on any day by voting for the players, because two players cannot be eliminated simultaneously.

Of course, but for that, some effort must be made to understand the situation.

This does not require the votes of inactive players. It can be balanced with the votes that are available.

The blue votes don't necessarily have to be introduced.

Three people suddenly decided to execute someone, and the rest didn't care.

Besides, the voting process is another extremely important argument when it comes to future executions.

There, every vote really counts.

This rule doesn't necessarily have to be introduced. But without blue votes, this rule will be even less meaningful, as it reduces the possibilities for balancing.

Why such torture? Are we playing Mafia or a game of "balancing votes"?

If someone doesn't care about the game, they shouldn't participate.

Well, that's what I'm talking about.

Every vote should always matter, regardless of the game. If someone's vote doesn't matter, why should they be in the game during the day?

I'm just suggesting trying it again; I've played enough games with both voting systems to compare.

What's the point?

A large group doesn't need to keep track of what three investigators are doing. Moreover, it shouldn't monitor to ensure that a Mafia team doesn't show up a minute before the end of the day and eliminate someone, adding a couple of votes.

Psychology is psychology; there's a lack of information there. Here, there's already enough information; why add more? Some can't even grasp the existing amount and fall asleep in the middle of the game.

Doesn't the term "team game" mean anything? If the team works cohesively, they win; if they don't, they lose. It seems reasonable to me that this is the case, meaning that a larger number of votes is more important, not the other way around.

I'm just pointing out that in psychological Mafia, such tactics are more reasonable than not, but here, it's different.

And in reality, in the psychology that you love...

I don't mind, but I'm afraid that in this case, the mafia will be able to hang someone themselves.

So, what is the point of the game then? Does everyone come for 5 minutes, write 1-2 posts, leave a vote, and leave?

Cities can unite, or rather, they should, but votes don't matter here.

But is such a game interesting?

In such a game, everyone needs to think and analyze.

look at the psychomafia section and its popularity, and then look at the regular section – the difference is obvious.

If a person can calculate everything and leave a vote in five minutes, and then leave and go about their business, then they have every right to do so.

Damn mafia. They killed a Russian player. Imbalanced mafia teams. The rules have been amended. Double vote. New newspaper. All NNs are displayed. The night lasted three days. Fake notes. Execution based on behavior. Researching the wiki. Light clues. The rake is tied to an axe. Dissatisfaction with complex chains. Rate my setting. The defender is always on the last number. The doctor isn't playing. The city blocked a townsperson. Execution of the city sharpshooter. I won't execute anyone on the first night. Townsperson revealed. Berber. Killed on the first night. Arandor asks for protection. Modkill. Triple swap. The maniac is useful to the town. An uber-maniac loses on the second day. Obvious. Playing as a team. Hints about roles. You are the mafia, and I am a townsperson. Sincerely, Gur. Victory due to luck. Early day closure. Planted clues. Pressure in the database. Paranoia. New ability. Role obtained. Searching for images for the setting. Fantasy mafia. Newspaper at three in the morning. Vegtam the gamemaster. A wall of revelations. Didn't read ten pages while NNV. NNV on the sixth day. Execute NNV. The mafia always gets caught. Calculating probabilities on paper cards. Minus for a misspelled nickname. Recruiting meat shields. Links to profiles. Three open tabs. Low activity. I figured out the roles from the beginning. Killing strong players. Setting with two mafia members. Negative status. All NNs in private messages. The kill failed. The killer dropped a book. Error in counting votes. The player closes the day.