HeroesWorld
  • Log in
  • Create account
  • Mode
    Interface scale

Posts from Controversial issues and their resolutions.

General
No ratings yet — be the first to rate!
In reply to Captain
Offline asm
Registered:
Posts: 251
#476
Auto-translated
Well, since you decided to delve into it, then...

1. Sil was the organizer and judge of the tournament.
2. The organizer has the right to make any changes to the rules of their tournament.
3. Mike, at the judge's instruction, began playing according to the new rules.

Therefore, there was no cheating, no violation of the rules, and not even an attempt to trick or circumvent the rules. Everything was fair.
And the judge's decision can be discussed, but there will always be those who are dissatisfied with any decision.
0
⚖️
0
In reply to Dirty_Player
User Avatar
Offline Vigo
Registered:
Posts: 2,259
#477
Auto-translated
Dirty_Player

P.S.: Does anyone remember which clan Djedi was accepted into when the scandal broke out?

Of course, they remember. She was accepted into the "Order of the Phoenix" clan based on my recommendation. If you want to know the details, feel free to send me a private message. Or do you want to just chat about it here? I don't think it's worth sharing opinions and thoughts on that in this thread. If you want to discuss that situation, no problem, let's discuss it privately if you're so hung up on it and it bothers you.

Although, I completely don't understand what a young, inexperienced cheater (possibly) has to do with the comparison to experienced players (not all of them!) and with Sil (an experienced and skilled player) who says or does something that was mentioned in the post and in conversations...

P.S. There are no perfectly pure people! It's a shame, but it's a fact :(
Всё будет хорошо!!! Только неизвестно когда... НО ОБЯЗАТЕЛЬНО БУДЕТ!!!
Но!...
Слушай всех, прислушивайся к немногим, решай сам...

1
⚖️
0
In reply to Vigo
User Avatar
Offline Wlk777
Registered:
Posts: 2,544
#478
Auto-translated
Vigo
Of course, they remember. She was accepted into the "Order of the Phoenix" clan based on my recommendation. If you want to know the details, feel free to message me privately. Or do you want to just chat here? I don't think it's worth sharing opinions and thoughts on that topic in this thread. If you want to discuss that situation, no problem, let's discuss it privately if you're so hung up on it and it bothers you.
And what, didn't anyone immediately notice that she (Djede) doesn't know how to play at all and doesn't know the most basic things (bless on angels is everything :D). I suspected this strongly in the first game, and after the second, I wouldn't even play with her. Although I won both times. Nevertheless.
0
⚖️
1
In reply to Wlk777
User Avatar
Offline Kash
Registered:
Posts: 4,408
#479
Auto-translated
There are no perfectly honest people!
Unfortunately for them, they do exist.
Have you met any? I won't lie, I'm not like that, I can lie too (and here I'm not lying :D)
In life, yes, if I need to and it won't really hurt anyone, I'll lie without batting an eye. But in a game, I don't see the point.
1
⚖️
0
In reply to Kash
User Avatar
Offline Wlk777
Registered:
Posts: 2,544
#480
Auto-translated
Kash
Unfortunately for them, they do exist.
Victor, do you really think so? Have you met anyone like that? I won't lie, I'm not like that, I can lie too (and here I'm not lying :D).
0
⚖️
1
In reply to Wlk777
User Avatar
Offline SEM_56
Registered:
Posts: 1,916
#481
Auto-translated
Wlk777
Victor, do you really think so? Have you met anyone like that? I won't lie, I'm not like that, I can lie too (and here I'm not lying :D)

He knows, believe me, I do too, and there are many around....
We won't shout, we're preparing the facts :D
Ушел с героев, пока пряники)
0
⚖️
0
In reply to SEM_56
User Avatar
Offline Dirty_Player
Registered:
Posts: 11,032
#482
Auto-translated
I'd like to share a screenshot for discussion. One of the guards protecting the herb resource point, which was positioned on the road, has already been defeated. The screenshot shows that Iona can reach this secondary resource point by bypassing the nomads. The question is: is it allowed to pass this way?
Attachments 1
1 file attached • Total size: 180.3 KB
0
⚖️
0
In reply to Dirty_Player
User Avatar
Offline Wlk777
Registered:
Posts: 2,544
#483
Auto-translated
Dirty_Player
I'd like to offer a screenshot for discussion. One guard of the herb resource point, which was standing on the road, has already been defeated. The screenshot shows that Iona can pass to this secondary resource point, bypassing the nomads. Question: is it allowed to pass this way?
By the way, I also wanted to ask the same question ;)

Added 8 minutes later
Here's another question, today I was playing with Oelm, and during the game, he started arguing that it's possible to use scrolls without having a Guild Hall of the same level built, if you have a spellbook (not of that element). I immediately said that it's not allowed, but he was so confident that I started to doubt, maybe I'm wrong? Please, those who know, give your opinion.
1
⚖️
1
User Avatar
Offline Hermit
Registered:
Posts: 3,465
#484
Auto-translated
According to the rules, yes. There is nothing mentioned about the possibility of multiple paths. However, I wouldn't like it if there was a strong Guardian on the way to my Castle. And somewhere in an invisible corner of the main spawn points, there was a weak Guardian, and my opponent would break through it (and I might not even know about it) and pass by the strong Guardian on the way to me.

Added 3 minutes later
Wlk777

Here's another question, by the way. Today I was playing with Oelm, and during the game, he started arguing that you can use scrolls without building a Guild Hall of the same level if you have a spellbook (not of that element). I immediately said that it's not possible, but he insisted so confidently that I started to doubt, maybe I'm wrong? Please, someone who knows, give your opinion.
I don't think so; it would make the spellbook too powerful. And by the way, I would like to clarify whether it is possible to use scrolls with third-level spells without building a Guild Hall 3
Всё не так плохо как Вы думаете. Всё намного хуже!
0
⚖️
0
In reply to Wlk777
User Avatar
Offline Dirty_Player
Registered:
Posts: 11,032
#485
Auto-translated
Wlk777
I definitely said it wasn't possible right away, but he was so confidently asserting the opposite that I started to doubt myself. Maybe I'm wrong? Please, someone who knows, give your opinion.
Of course, it's not possible. What nonsense is this? Did he find a scroll of flight, a water book, and then just flew away? No way, that doesn't happen :D
1
⚖️
0
User Avatar
Offline Pit for LM
Registered:
Posts: 2,468
#486
Auto-translated
Dirty_Player
I suggest we discuss this screenshot. One guard of the herb resource node, which was standing on the road, has already been defeated. The screenshot shows that Iona can pass to this secondary location by bypassing the nomads. Question: is it allowed to do so?
Here are the rules /topic/3515/
5.12. It is forbidden to enter adjacent territories without defeating the guards stationed at the passage (i.e., if they have moved). If two or three guards are scattered along the road, any one of them can be defeated.
In the screenshot, you need to defeat the guards of this passage – the nomads.
Wlk777
[/U]By the way, here's another question. Today I played with Oelm, and during the game, he started arguing that it’s possible to use scrolls without building a Mage Guild of the same level if there is a spellbook (not of that element). Of course, I immediately said that it wasn’t allowed, but he insisted so confidently that I began to doubt myself; maybe I am wrong? Please advise those who know.
Also:
5.8. It is forbidden to use spells from scrolls of levels 4 and 5 without building a corresponding-level Mage Guild in any of your castles.
There is no mention of the book. Scrolls cannot be used without a built Mage Guild.
0
⚖️
0
User Avatar
Offline Деконтаминатор
Registered:
Posts: 281
#487
Auto-translated
Here's another interesting case. Teleport to another respawn. On one side, I defeated the guard, and on the other, I engaged the resource guard and moved on, while the teleport guard was not defeated. In my opinion, this case falls under the rule about doubled and shifted guards.
С уважением, Деконтаминатор.
Hello from ancient novice!
ЗЫ: Когда я свободен для игры, в Асе у меня стоит состояние "Игры"-"Погоняем!", и я ищу Аськи с аналогичным состоянием.
0
⚖️
0
User Avatar
Offline Lider1
Registered:
Posts: 3,371
#488
Auto-translated
Ehhh, just a moment!

Judging by
Dirty_Player
One guard protecting the herb spawn point, which was standing on the road, has already been defeated.
I understand that besides the nomads, there was someone else there, which means -

According to rule 5.12: If two or three guards are scattered along the road, any one can be defeated. - you can proceed!
Сейчас балуюсь этим https://vcmi.eu/download/
За то что нейтралы не бегают за единичкой, для меня это уже стоит того
2
⚖️
0
In reply to Lider1
User Avatar
Offline Kash
Registered:
Posts: 4,408
#489
Auto-translated
to Lider1
This isn't a case where "two or three guards are scattered along the road" (path). There are two paths here: along the road (cleared) and off-road (nomads). According to the rules, they should be defeated.
I confess: in the last game with Sam, I didn't defeat the second guard when I entered the treasure from another path – I thought it wasn't necessary. Luckily, I lost.
1
⚖️
0
User Avatar
Offline bRitvo4kA
Registered:
Posts: 1,107
#490
Auto-translated
Pit for LM is right, formally you need to defeat the nomads. Unless it was reliably known that there was another guard protecting the passage near the nomads, and that guard had already been defeated. Then it's not necessary.
В дикім полі
0
⚖️
0