Skip to content

Posts from Best artist contest. Voting.

HeroesWorld Contests Closed Topic
4.5 (2 ratings)
18 years ago
Auto-translated
Voting statistics:

Drawing No. 1: 9
Drawing No. 2: 6
Drawing No. 3: 14
Drawing No. 4: 1
Drawing No. 5: 1
Drawing No. 6: 4

Votes up to post 42 have been counted.

35 people have already voted :).

Attention!


This thread is only for voting and commenting on the drawings! All questions, comments, etc., can be left here.
In reply to Нэйко
User Avatar
18 years ago
Auto-translated
Thank you for organizing and participating :) I will take the mistakes and the public's interest into account next time. And now, some harsh criticism, don't be offended, I will also comment on my own work :)

#1.The idea is not bad, but it looks rushed. In principle, I'm not very good at this genre, so I'll say that I would fix the griffin (as I understand, this is the wonderful bird on which my sister from the faction is sitting, it's actually a griffin). Griffins seem to have bird-like front paws. Wings: I only see one wing, and it barely seems to be holding on in the picture; the author reduced the base of the wing too much. Furthermore, I didn't understand what or where the mage with the pacifier in his mouth is lying on, and where is his hand? The vampire's leg looks like it's broken or bent backwards? You need to work on the perspective. The demon's wings are confusing: it looks like they took 4 sticks, glued them in pairs, and glued a torn piece of paper between these pairs. The author needs to look at bat wings and their anatomy.
And lastly, regarding this drawing, purely from the perspective of a faction representative - why did they make the Fury completely naked, only wearing boots, bracers, and makeup? O_o.

#2.Oh, I know how difficult it can be to draw a person in a certain pose ;) but I will still point out the mistakes (don't be offended, author, you have many of them, and they are obvious!). First, the head: it's large in itself, if you look at it in relation to the body, and it's asymmetrical (the area of the lower jaw, cheekbones). Secondly, the face itself: I would emphasize the nose (wings of the nose, nostrils), because it looks like a small appendage, the lips are, of course, in a classic style - plump, but they look unrealistic, separate from the face, I would say, as if they were just glued on, and for some reason they are brown, although the hair color is darker (dark brown or black) - it would be better to darken them. Thirdly, the hairstyle is unclear; more light and shadow, highlights, and it would be okay. Fourthly, the neck: it's very thin and long, it wouldn't be able to hold such a large head in reality. Fifthly, the shoulders and arms, maybe she's that muscular, but the contour of the muscles should have been drawn better, because they don't look very good, they are too thick, and then, the right shoulder is longer than the left. Furthermore, the torso is strange, too short, and I don't see any hips at all; the legs are located as if they are growing not from the pelvis, but from the stomach. I don't like the butt, it's too square; female butts are usually depicted more rounded. I won't say anything about the short legs and unclear feet... Accessories. Metal. Yes, the buckle on the belt is drawn well, the chains hang unrealistically; in general, I would say that all the metal in the picture needs good highlights, light and shadow. Otherwise, the weapon looks like rubber or plastic with a glossy coating O_o... Shadows. I don't see any decent shadows at all! It's not clear where the light is coming from. The author made a large shadow, supposedly from the sword (saber, I don't know what it's called) between the heroine's legs. It's unsuccessful! Such a shadow cannot exist! And then, there is a shadow from the sword, but there are no shadows from the heroine and the dagger... Either the author forgot to draw the rest of the shadows, or he simply couldn't draw the area between the legs.
Conclusion: the drawing is flat.

#3.Well, it's not bad. Only the dragon's neck and the lack of the same bright light and shadow on it and on the lower jaw bother me. It's not clear where the neck begins. Again, light and shadow. It's not clear where the light is coming from.

#4.Phew, I won't write about humans, because it will be not a comment, but a lecture on the structure of the human body ;) The tiger is okay, only there are no knees and elbows. The fingers on the paws are very small. Author! Have mercy on such a large tiger! He won't be able to run on such paws :( ;). Plus, the background is good.

#5.I won't talk about the body, it's clear why. The idea is not bad, I like the titan's pose. Plus, again, the background is good, although I would paint the sky blue ;) You need to work on the anatomy and the technique of shading with colored pencils. ;). Light and shadow.

#6.Head, chest, shoulders, everything seems to be in place :) Only, indeed, the rotation of the hand didn't work out. More highlights on the gold. More light and shadow on the precious stones and hair. ;)

It's hard to choose. Because I know how difficult it is to draw a person... and I can imagine how difficult it is to draw a person and an animal (!)... and even in a snowy forest (!)... I GIVE MY VOTE TO WORK #4!!!
P.S. It's a pity that it's not in color. ;)
User Avatar
18 years ago
Auto-translated
Figure #3 was very appealing.
User Avatar
18 years ago
Auto-translated
I'll vote too!!!!!! :smile20: :smile49: The Dragon is SUPER!!!!! :smile49: :smile20: So I'm voting for 3!!!!!!!!!!
User Avatar
18 years ago
Auto-translated
I really liked the idea behind the first drawing and the dragon (No. 3). The dragon looks so real! It's almost like a screenshot, even better! The artwork is superb! I'M VOTING FOR NUMBER THREE
User Avatar
18 years ago
Auto-translated
Unfortunately, I couldn't participate (I hope I won't mess up in the Miss Heroes contest... I'll fight for the last available spot :)), but I'm always happy to take a look at the entries. 1. The drawing is quite flawed, but I really like it. The naive and kind humor, the cute characters, the atmosphere of friendship (I don't see them wanting to tear each other's heads off) - all of this is definitely a plus. 2. There are some minor flaws with the proportions; I would like to see the girl portrayed more gracefully. But the texture is worked out wonderfully, and I really like the expression on her face. 3. Dragon... ^_^ The white outlines on the armor and the complete lack of a background are a bit distracting. But the dragon is cute ^_^. 4. The lack of a color scheme and the shadow from the photograph detract from the overall impression. There are some flaws in the proportions (for example, I would make the shaman's head smaller and her legs longer). But the picture is still pleasant and atmospheric. The little tiger is just adorable ^_^. 5. The drawing is clearly not professional, but the composition is very good. The ropes on the titan's body slightly spoil the impression (I would either erase these areas, dab them with a correction pen, or use a pearlescent pen). A big plus is the overall thoughtfulness of the drawing; if a great professional had drawn it, I would like to see it on the disc of a new expansion. 6. The combination of yellow-orange, green, and red-purple is a bit jarring (at least for me), although the author skillfully found a place for each color, and in the end, this riot of colors still leaves a good impression. And again, there is no background (although the blurred bottom of the elf somewhat mitigates this drawback). The work is good, there are no major flaws, and the snake adds extra charm ^_^. But still, the charm of work #1 makes me vote for it, even though all the works are very, very good
User Avatar
18 years ago
Auto-translated
I vote for the dragon or #3! It's the best-drawn one, and the rest look like they were drawn by (sorry) little kids.
In reply to Green_DooDLeZ
User Avatar
18 years ago
Auto-translated
Green_DooDLeZ;181524
I'm voting for the dragon or #3! It's the best-drawn one, and the others look like (sorry) they were drawn by little kids.
Please excuse me, but why don't I see you among the professional artists on our forum? Why don't I see your name here? Why haven't I seen any of your works in the fan art or art fantasy sections? Why? Are you ashamed to post your "professional" doodles? Try drawing at least one of the least-quality works. I'm not sure you could do it. And if you're such a great artist, why don't I see any proper criticism of all 6 drawings? Can't you give any? I'll tell you that the dragon isn't actually that perfect; I've already listed its flaws. So, don't talk like that about the efforts of our other ARTIST-CHILDREN. Here's my request: without looking at drawing #6, please draw the same elf, but with a different hairstyle, different accessories, and a different color scheme. Then I'll see how "mature" you are, so you can judge the work of others. If I don't see the elf by the end of June, apologize to all the artists who submitted their work, and I won't be afraid to say it. Know that my work is also presented here, and I'll say that it's not a quick job and not copied.
P.S. Vortex, I'm sorry for this scandal, but you'll need to create EXACTLY 2 nominations: "best copy" and "best original work."
18 years ago
Auto-translated
Green_DooDLeZ

Shaddar's signature comes to mind: "Watching a battle from the sidelines, everyone thinks they're a strategist." I could have participated myself and shown how "real grown men draw!"

A message to all participants:

Please, don't pay attention to this person's post and don't take it to heart; his message contains no hint of constructive criticism, just empty words. I hope he realizes his mistake and offers a public apology. Also, please refrain from flaming, swearing, and making statements like "how wrong Green_DooDLeZ acted" and so on.

<from moderator> If such statements occur, you will be punished by the sword of moderation... So it's best to avoid them :)
In reply to Майор Вихрь
User Avatar
18 years ago
Auto-translated
Whirlwind, please forgive me, but the words "you drew it like children" with my many years of experience are like a knife in the heart for me and for other artists. I will not tolerate this. It deeply offended me. Even the guys from the game development team didn't say such things to me, although they are professional developers and game designers. :(
P.S. You can give me ten comments, but I can't just stay silent, especially since I express myself quite politely and intelligently. IMHO.
User Avatar
18 years ago
Auto-translated
Is the voting still ongoing? I'm voting for the second drawing – I like it!
User Avatar
18 years ago
Auto-translated
I liked 3 and 5, but I'll vote for 3 because dragons are like family to me... :)
User Avatar
18 years ago
Auto-translated
I would like to ask the author of drawing #3, what did you use to create it: Photoshop or paper? I'm voting for number 6.
User Avatar
18 years ago
Auto-translated
I vote for number 6 – the drawing is really good. I also liked the drawing with the dragon.
User Avatar
18 years ago
Auto-translated
I vote for drawing #2.
In reply to Antoxic
User Avatar
18 years ago
Auto-translated
I vote for #3. The dragon:smile20:. It looks very similar. And it's beautiful!

P.S. But I have nothing against the other drawings! They are all very beautiful. But I had to choose one.

Statistics

Welcome our newest member: recijeb