Posts from Darkness or Light? Philosophy in Knights of the Old Republic. Auto-translated

As I said, they just needed to trust the wisdom of the Jedi :D.
And in general, look at how Palpatine treated his former apprentice:
He told Anakin to simply kill him, and Anakin obeyed like a puppet.
And regarding Tatooine, I disagree with you, because the Council refused to train him as a Jedi, not to take him from Tatooine.

Anakin initially had some predispositions towards the Dark Side, perhaps after losing his mother, or perhaps he had some psychological issues (?)... But the fact remains: if Anakin had been unconscious, and Obi-Wan was fighting Dooku, I am 100% sure that Obi-Wan would have spared him... And if he had spared him, he would have likely told the truth about Palpatine.

But the fact remains: if Anakin had been unconscious and Obi-Wan was fighting Dooku, I'm 100% sure Obi-Wan would have spared him... And if he had spared him, it's quite possible he would have revealed the truth about Palpatine.

See, I told you that all light-side Jedi who turn to the dark side lose their power... Well, or Obi-Wan was just stronger than his apprentice (which is quite likely). Maybe Anakin is physically stronger than Obi-Wan, but in terms of wisdom and using the Force, he still has a long way to go...

Well, you might as well say that in terms of a duel, Yoda is weaker than Palpatine:D.
But it's interesting to think about what would happen if Yoda went to take out Anakin, and Obi-Wan took on Palpatine...
I think it's clear that Palpatine would have defeated Obi-Wan... But the situation with Yoda and Anakin is unclear (although it's clear that he would lose to the green friend in battle)).

P.S.: Why are you so sure that Obi-Wan had no chance of winning?
P.P.S.: And at the end of SW III, it was quite sad for the Jedi Masters, who can be said to have been "stabbed in the back" - only Yoda and Obi-Wan managed to survive...
Obi-Wan was just lucky, and Yoda... well, Yoda is very smart :D, in general, this moment also proves his wisdom.

Regarding the lightsaber battle, it might not be the best, but I would say that Mace Windu is better than both Yoda and Palpatine in terms of lightsaber combat, but he's completely lacking in the Force.
Yes - in the end, Luke Skywalker would never have learned about his Jedi abilities, and Palpatine wouldn't have been thrown into the shaft on the Death Star))) Although, considering the intrigues that weren't shown in the film, it's quite possible that without Vader, Palpatine would have been overthrown... by Moff Tarkin or Admiral Motti... or eventually Grand Admiral Thrawn))) There were many contenders for Palpatine's position, but besides Vader, Palpatine also had many other powerful allies, whose stories were only revealed in the expanded universe... This includes the famous Grand Admiral Thrawn, Lumiya, viziers, and the personal guard... and much more, thanks to which Palpatine ruled the galaxy as Emperor for a good 25 years...

Interesting discussion, I'll add my two cents
The Sith are evil because they forbid feelings like love ("What could be worse than love? Only ONE thing - mercy" (Uthar Wynn)), mercy, compassion, the Sith condemn helping others, the Sith are ambitious, which means they are dangerous, the Sith are aimed at an endless cycle of violence and death (the student must kill the teacher... And here's the question - WHY have a student in the first place?! This, in my opinion, is the height of absurdity) and they use the Force for personal purposes, which, given all of the above, are not very good)
The Jedi are bad because any monastic order is bad - due to its isolation, but they at least help people...

An interesting debate, I'll add my two cents:)
The Sith are evil because they forbid feelings like love ("What could be worse than love? Only ONE thing – mercy" – Utar Wynn), mercy, compassion; the Sith condemn helping others. The Sith are ambitious, which makes them dangerous. The Sith are focused on an endless cycle of violence and death, and they use their power for personal purposes, which, considering everything mentioned above, are not very good).
The Jedi are bad because any monastic order is bad due to its isolation, but at least they help people...

the student must kill the teacher... And here's the question – WHY have a student in the first place?! This is, in my opinion, the height of absurdity.

Have you watched anything besides movies?))) The Sith allow it, while the Jedi condemn love... The ancient Sith allowed anything that could increase their power and knowledge of the Force... it's just that acts of mercy were so disadvantageous in this regard that they soon began to be rejected and perceived as weakness...

This curious rule became a rule most likely precisely because it was so often violated... And in reality, it was never a rule... In Knights of the Old Republic, they didn't even think about it... So it's just something that many people took for granted...

Well, isolation is definitely unnecessary...

The Sith allow it, while the Jedi condemn love...

A loved one gives us strength.
The fear of losing a loved one is fear.
Fear leads to the dark side.

In my opinion, being closed off is correct – if you don't want there to be a POSSIBILITY of falling to the dark side. The Jedi are overly cautious, and this is further proof of that, but it is also the only way to protect the Force from bad influence.

I didn't quite understand, do you mean that an apprentice shouldn't kill an apprentice? But then why is it perceived by everyone as something completely self-evident? And also, in the tomb, the old teacher from the Sith academy said that if you possess valuable knowledge, you should never share it with anyone, how should this be understood in conjunction with the permission to have apprentices?

In my opinion, isolation is correct – if you don't want there to be a POSSIBILITY of falling to the dark side. The Jedi are overly cautious, and this is further proof of that, but it is also the only way to protect the Force from bad influence.

there is always a choice... and even in a monastery, there will be someone who envies a more senior person's higher position and the fact that they have more authority...