Auto-translated
A few thoughts on the proposals:
1. Remove the "Off-Topic" section entirely. Once and for all.
* Pros: Reduced traffic, a cleaner community (fewer people means more "oxygen"), only those who are truly passionate about the games will remain.
* Cons: Those who are passionate about the games will eventually become more than just casual acquaintances; they'll become good friends or even family. Where else will they be able to chat about various topics (besides the games), especially if they can't meet in person due to time zone differences? Furthermore, even the most dedicated fans will eventually get tired of not being able to discuss other topics. (On the other hand, this isn't such a big drawback – don't forget about real life!)
2. Divide the forum into two sections: one for the games and one for off-topic discussions.
* Pros: A reasonable solution to the problem. But this already exists in practice. There are special threads for off-topic discussions; if you want to post there, create a thread, etc.
* Cons: Since this already exists, and the amount of off-topic content isn't decreasing, it's not very effective.
3. Do nothing: See option 2.
I like the first option, and I can live with its drawbacks.
Of course, I'm exaggerating, and I may not have mentioned all the pros and cons.
Sincerely, Draco