Posts from Appeals Committee. Disputed situations in tournaments.

it's clear that the respawn isn't red's, the question is whether red had passed through there before or not? moreover, the latter option is unlikely to occur not only to a novice but also to an experienced player who has only practiced on xl maps, for example — where people tend to ignore (un)blocked passage guards... and even on an SM map, where the general guard zone is shared by two players)) i.e. you need specific Jebus experience, where you have to fight the guard zone for neutral respawns, and buggy Jebus experience at that))) Vok, for instance, has extensive experience in template building, knows all sorts of road network bugs, so the situation is obvious to him, but can he put himself in the shoes of an average player? personally, in the heat of a game and due to ignorance, it simply wouldn't have occurred to me that they might not have run through here before :confused: i.e. I wouldn't have guessed or suspected myself of a possible violation, but would have simply thought exactly what Dirty said! :) but now I've been warned, and I'll try not to do this in the future, regardless of the referee's authoritative opinion)))

jump to your game object, place harpies in an isolated cell, and kill a lot of gray bears that way, then teleport home.

Couldn't resist mapmaking for Heroes 5, unfortunately.

In some cases, exceptions can be made when the situation makes it difficult to suspect something is amiss. But here, the grounds for suspicion were quite substantial.

If we reason like this, then the rule prohibiting passing by a moved guard will have to be completely abolished.

In my opinion, the screenshot clearly shows that this is not a red respawn point. A pile of logs on the road, pushing aside mountains of ore (there are no herbal obstacles along the passage) – all signs indicate a bugged passage to a corner respawn point.

I might still allow for some leniency towards a newbie if they play the innocent act well, but if there's even a minimally experienced player, then it’s a complete fail.

In my opinion, the screenshot clearly shows that this is not a red spawn point. A pile of logs on the road, with mountains of mines (there are no grassy obstacles along the passage) – all signs of a bugged passage to a corner spawn point.

I can still allow for the possibility of leniency towards a newbie if they play the innocent, but if there is even a minimally experienced player, then this is a complete failure.

+1, by the rules of the bugged passage this is unambiguously a Town Portal for blue.

Actually, it's an easy game: you ask your opponent; if you're not sure, you save immediately and ask the judges. Let them scratch their heads :D

This is possible in 1 out of 100 cases, IMHO. Perhaps I don't have much experience with Jebus Cross, let the experts tell me how often respawns are dealt without GO?

I request that the AC consider lifting the ban on my participation in tournaments.

The restart is initiated at the player's discretion, who owns the block, if it is impossible to bypass the block that cuts off the castle from the main part of the starting zone, leaving no possibility of development up to the block.