[POLL] AK and other weapon customization — Tournament History

No ratings yet — be the first to rate!

Multiple choice Public votes Closed 2015-08-12

This poll is closed.

Allow combining moderation duties with membership in the Arbitration Committee

69.4% 34 votes

Prohibit combining moderation duties with membership in the Arbitration Committee

22.4% 11 votes

1 person is making changes to the ХВ rules

8.2% 4 votes

AK makes changes to the rules for Hv

46.9% 23 votes

Changes to the rules of Heroes & Might & Magic will be made after a general vote

38.8% 19 votes

The rules for official Tournaments are determined by their organizer

36.7% 18 votes

The rules for official Tournaments are part of the ХВ rules

57.1% 28 votes

Leave restart on block

63.3% 31 votes

Remove restart on block

32.7% 16 votes

You can start digging for the Grail from week 6

32.7% 16 votes

You can start digging for the Grail on week 1

63.3% 31 votes

First
Previous
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Next
Last

In reply to Juristis

Heroin_HP

7/31/2015 3:13 PM UTC

Auto-translated

Juristis

How are these two better than other members of the AC or the forum in general?

If the question concerns judging, then definitely, they are not better, but more authoritative than others. As long as I've been playing on Hv, I've remembered them resolving many controversial situations, and always fairly. Lately, everyone seems to need to redo something, reinterpret something, and argue with each other.

P.S. Heroeportal ceased to exist after many "daddies" had a falling out back in the day.

Juristis

7/31/2015 3:16 PM UTC

Auto-translated

Yeah, I’d gladly leave Heroes of Might and Magic Online if there was somewhere else to go.

heroes3.tv/juristis
ICQ - 488-784-621, skype - juristis18

Весна 2014.

злой_романтик

7/31/2015 3:17 PM UTC

Auto-translated

Well, in terms of rights and authority, the coordinator has power on HeroesWorld, doesn't it?

296524052
Весна 2012.

In reply to злой_романтик

Dima Surmay

7/31/2015 3:19 PM UTC

Auto-translated

злой_романтик

Well, in terms of the number of rights and powers, the authority on HeroesWorld belongs to the coordinator, right?

Who is the coordinator? Did you mean the creator?

In reply to Dima Surmay

злой_романтик

7/31/2015 3:34 PM UTC

Auto-translated

Dima Surmay

What do you mean by "coordinator"? Do you mean the creator?

The coordinator is the creator's representative; take a look under Dirty's avatar sometime.

296524052
Весна 2012.

In reply to Heroin_HP

Wicc

7/31/2015 3:39 PM UTC

Auto-translated

Heroin_HP

For as long as I've been playing on the forums, I've seen them resolve many controversial situations, and always fairly.

It's just that your tender feelings are clouding your judgment...

The latest example is the game between Darka and Gomunguls, which is being discussed in the neighboring thread. It's a complex case, I agree, but an experienced judge shouldn't have too much trouble figuring it out; the main thing is to pay attention to the details. However, Pit and Dirty disagreed, and, as I understand it, Dirty managed to convince Pit that his interpretation was incorrect.

If the question concerns judging, then definitely, they are not better, but more authoritative than others.

But in this formulation, it is absolutely correct.

In reply to Wicc

Dirty_Player

7/31/2015 4:02 PM UTC

Auto-translated

Wicc

However, Pete and Dirty had different opinions, and, as I understood, Dirty managed to convince Pete that his interpretation was incorrect.

Yura, I don't know how you read it, but if you don't know, why mislead? The situation was as follows: Gomunguls addressed Pete, and he made his decision. Vitaly disagreed with him and turned to me. I made my decision, and it turned out to coincide with Pete's decision. We didn't consult at all about this situation. I decided that there was no violation in that situation and that it was okay to play that way (I still think so). I also said that any controversial situation would definitely be interpreted in favor of the player, and there would be no reason to punish.

In reply to Juristis

scorp

7/31/2015 4:05 PM UTC

Auto-translated

Juristis

Yeah, I'd gladly leave Heroes of Might and Magic Online if I had somewhere else to go.

gameranger?

In reply to Juristis

Dirty_Player

7/31/2015 4:08 PM UTC

Auto-translated

Juristis

Yeah, I'd gladly leave HeroesWorld myself if I had somewhere to go)

But you've "left" HeroesWorld plenty of times yourself, let's be honest. And since we're having this conversation, tell me, what's so bad about HeroesWorld? What is it about it that makes you want to leave so badly?

In reply to Dirty_Player

Juristis

7/31/2015 7:35 PM UTC

Auto-translated

Dirty_Player

Yeah, you "quit" HeroesWorld a bunch of times too, so what's the point. And since we're having this conversation, tell me, what's so bad about HeroesWorld? What's in it that makes you want to quit so badly?

Let that stay with me. I don't want another ban. And I wouldn't be able to get through my statements without it.

heroes3.tv/juristis
ICQ - 488-784-621, skype - juristis18

Весна 2014.

In reply to Dirty_Player

Wicc

7/31/2015 8:50 PM UTC

Auto-translated

Dirty_Player

I believe that in that situation, there was no violation, and it's acceptable to play that way (and I still think so).

That's the problem – you still think that way. It's okay to miss the nuances of the wording when analyzing it yourself; it happens to everyone. But after it was pointed out directly...

I also said that in a controversial situation, it will always be interpreted in favor of the player, and there's nothing to punish for.

That reasoning is correct. But you were motivated by different reasoning. The fact that their answers coincided is just luck; they could have easily been different. Plus, your incorrect reasoning didn't allow you to convince Gomunguls of your rightness, and he brought the episode to the attention of everyone.

In reply to Wicc

Dirty_Player

7/31/2015 10:01 PM UTC

Auto-translated

Wicc

That's the problem – you still think like that.

If pedantry allows for such nonsense (where you can fly however you want if there are 2+ guards, but you have to crawl through the mountains if there's only one), then the rules just need to be adjusted. I don't manage the rules. Vitaly did a good job bringing the situation to light! The more controversial situations are studied, the easier it will be to judge in the future and make fewer mistakes.

Wicc

Plus, your incorrect reasoning didn't allow you to convince Gomunguls that you were right, and he brought the episode up for public discussion.

In no sport does a referee convince someone of their rightness. The referee makes a decision. If the referee's decision is not satisfactory, then they can be excluded from judging. This isn't soccer, where referees cling to their positions. By the way, would you like to judge a season? You'd be helping the forum! :smile20:

In reply to scorp

Lider1

7/31/2015 10:19 PM UTC

Auto-translated

scorp

GameRanger?Good perspective. Played via fast-click today, ran into a cheater :smile20:
I could see his innocent eyes through GameRanger. :eek:

Сейчас балуюсь этим https://vcmi.eu/download/
За то что нейтралы не бегают за единичкой, для меня это уже стоит того

In reply to Juristis

Dark

7/31/2015 10:29 PM UTC

Auto-translated

Juristis

How are these two better than other members of the AC or the forum in general?

because, unlike you, they uphold the rules and don't constantly want to leave and come back, and they also have experience:p

лето 2012.

In reply to Dirty_Player

Juristis

7/31/2015 10:38 PM UTC

Auto-translated

Dirty_Player

In no sport does a referee convince anyone of their correctness. A referee makes a decision. If the referee's decision is unsatisfactory, then they can simply not be invited to referee again. This isn't soccer, where referees cling to their positions. Would you like to referee a season, by the way? You'd be helping the forum! :smile20:

I can referee, it's not difficult for me.

heroes3.tv/juristis
ICQ - 488-784-621, skype - juristis18

Весна 2014.