Posts from your questions regarding the game rules (improving the interpretation). Auto-translated

I didn't even remember your nickname :D, I just happened to find out on the CIS server that it was you :D

And the situation is memorable only because I stopped playing games after that, maybe you think I'm biased towards you now - I don't know, I think I've always been fair.

For those with limited mental capacity and similar individuals, let me remind you that the main moderators and judges of almost all tournaments (Pit and Dirty) stated that everything was within the rules when reviewing this situation...

For the skd and other similarly gifted individuals, I will remind you that the head moderators and judges of almost all tournaments (Pit and Dirty), when analyzing this situation, stated that everything was within the rules...

Typical quibbling... and yes, I'll join Vic, it's good that you're not judging... Dark took an absolutely logical action by using wings, and the stories about him incidentally seeing 5 cells of the treasure zone - that's already reaching and a desire to latch onto something to snatch victory where you lost... If it comes to that, wings themselves are wildly imbalanced on Jebus Cross, especially if they are on the respawn, let's ban them:smile04:

How is aerial control related to passing through? This restriction applies specifically to other overland passages. The rules are clear on this:
- Transitioning between zones using the Angel Wings artifact and the Flight and Dimension Door spells is allowed:
a) between any of zones 1-4 and central zone 5, if a path has been cleared through any passage between the corresponding zones;

I think that if you're unsure whether something is allowed or not, you should save at that point and continue after clarifying, rather than having the result interpreted in favor of the player, as the rules are written with inaccuracies. And since you didn't save before such a situation and took action, you get a loss.

In this case, the first action isn't breaking the path but visiting the treasure hoard. Whether by flight or on foot doesn't matter anymore.

There's an analysis of such a situation in the comments to the rules
Goblins can be taken from the external dwelling without clearing the path.

I drew: purple - cells where you can use Dimension Door. Red - possible trajectory options when using Flight/Wings. Brown - walking route. Blue - trajectory that violates the rules.

In my understanding

I disagree with Gomunguls that such a violation should result in a technical defeat.

There is an analysis of such a situation in the comments to the rules...

What if there are no doubts? Dark clearly had no doubts. That is, even if this rule is introduced, it will be difficult to apply.

By "action" here, we mean interaction with any objects - visiting, collecting, breaking through.

And what if a player stayed the night on the cell to the right of the external dwelling? On the sand. The opponent formally has the right to attack, thinking that the player has already broken the ГО.

And how does the right red trajectory differ from the blue one? From the perspective of the rules, not from the perspective of your IMHO.

Disputed situations are resolved by the letter of the law, not by anyone's understanding. They are disputed precisely because understandings diverge.

Gomunguls:smile40: :smile54: , if there are any other controversial situations, let me know, and we'll look into them.

...
He also revealed the stats and mana of my army by attacking the hero. That is, if you replay, he will already have additional information.

He wasn't sure, but that doesn't mean he's right.

What is meant by "action" is not specified in the rules; for you, it's visiting, collecting, or probing, but for me, it might be reconnaissance. Also, stepping on a certain cell or flying over it is also an action for me.

When there's nothing to say in response, silence or inappropriate laughter ensues.

Don't you even know that? When you replay, everything repeats exactly, how do you even play without knowing the rules? And he knows that, for example, if you have Armageddon, you'll just repeat your Armageddon, but he can't change the equipped artifacts or the army, etc.

In the game, the logistician's map was different.

In the case you proposed — a player who stayed overnight did not break through the Guard Obligations, but is camping in a treasure zone. If the opponent broke through their Guard Obligations and entered the treasure zone — they are not prohibited from attacking another player in the treasure zone on Jebus Cross.

As another option: a player who did not break through the Guard Obligations — camps on a passage through which they can exit without breaking through the Guard Obligations. In that case, upon seeing the opponent, they can warn that they did not break through their own Guard Obligations, then the opponent first needs to kill the gold dragons or efreets and then the hero.