Posts from Mafia 90. The Tale of Oldforest.

Forum users, those who have been playing here for a long time, tell me, in which Mafia game was a Heroes player the peacemaker and not killed on the first night?

Saret

Who is this?

Who is this?

Alright, I've read through the first day, and Master is leaning towards a peaceful outcome. So, Alex, don't completely eliminate him; I gave you bad advice, forget it.
Ugh, I can't keep up with you all. Hmm, I'll think about it some more. Does anyone want to execute Snowman? )

The situation is this: the Mafia has nothing on me because they haven't used any Night Actions on me that would be reported in the newspaper. It's very beneficial for them to eliminate me and, moreover, to find out my role so they can cross it off their list and be sure about the roles of other players. But it's very disadvantageous to eliminate the Hero. First, he might be their guy; second, according to Snowman, there are only two peaceful roles on him. So, what's the point of eliminating him? None! But eliminating me is very advantageous.

I want to... but not today! I completely refuse to choose between a potentially peaceful Olahm and a potentially peaceful (with an important role) hero.

Mika, you see, the whole thing here is about constraints. It's like Sudoku: if you put a "3" in this square, then only a "2" can go in this one, and if you put a "2" in this one, then a "4" must go in that one. If the Hero is Mafia, then he's not a Werewolf, but a Fire Mage or a Bard. Then the Cop is a Warrior, a Priest, or a Knight. And if the Hero is innocent, then he's a Knight or a Warrior, so the Cop is definitely a Werewolf. The Snowman is a Fire Mage or a Bard, and the second Mafia member is among those who are targeting the Hero for the second time. We need to weigh this, but no one wants to argue; everyone is just shouting, "Let's hang him!" They're hoping to guess correctly, like with the Flower? No, it's more likely that this is the work of the Mafia lobby.

Mika, you see, it's all about the constraints. It's like Sudoku: if you put a "3" in this square, then only a "2" can go in this one, and if you put a "2" in this one, then a "4" must go in that one. If the Hero is Mafia, then he's not a Werewolf, but a Fire Mage or a Bard; then the Cop is a Knight, a Paladin, a Priest, or a Crusader. But if the Hero is Innocent, then he's a Knight or a Paladin. Then the Cop is definitely a Werewolf. The Snowman is a Fire Mage or a Bard. And the second Mafia is among those who are accusing the Hero for the second time; you need to weigh it, but no one wants to argue; everyone is just shouting, "Let's hang him!" hoping to guess correctly, like with the Flower? No, it's more likely that this is the work of the Mafia lobby.

but no one wants to argue

So, the probability that there was a killer in the group, and the sorcerer didn't kill, but instead used healing or redirection, is quite high.

Well, it seems like the sky is burning with some kind of peaceful role, which could be a Hero. I think I have two alternative mafia scenarios.
First: Saret is mafia. Then we exclude Heroist and Ovn, and Snowman and Sky become mafia. Or Sesam (but maybe Sesam is still a villager? He seems like one ;)).
Second: Ovn and Heroist are mafia. The third one should be chosen from the above, excluding Saret. And Sesam is definitely a villager.

Then we exclude Heroista and Oven.