Auto-translated
Why all of a sudden? :confused:
Juristis
Posts from Appeals Committee. Disputed situations in tournaments.
Dirty_Player
Auto-translated
Turns out Dirty himself doesn't know the rules! :smile07: And who are the judges?
Added after 1 minute
Attention! The AK doesn't know its own rules.
Juristis
Auto-translated
Well, I'm not obligated to know them by heart. In any case, if there's a dispute in the game, I always refer to the rules.
Added 1 minute ago
I'm happy to step aside and let a more competent person take over.
злой_романтик
Auto-translated
Added 1 minute ago
[/U]
I allow you to replace me with a more competent specialist.
Oh, there's already one "rules expert" :D
Dirty_Player
Auto-translated
I'm happy to take on this responsibility.
злой_романтик
Auto-translated
If the tournament organizers don't mind, I'm happy to step aside and let you judge. If the other members of the Tournament Committee don't object, I'm happy to give up my spot (although there will soon be a vacancy in the Tournament Committee anyway).
Lider1
Auto-translated
Leaving isn't necessary. But you should definitely give it a try and see what this "mess" is all about. You need to sort through the saves and neutralize those annoying little monsters. It's not as easy as it seems. And it remains to be seen how much motivation the initiator will have :D
Pit for LM
Toganash
Auto-translated
I've been reading here about the insistence on replaying turns because of an alleged hit-run.
We're doing great... :smile13:
I am amazed how someone, having been in the same situation (Dragon Utopia) and feeling all the cretinism of the person insisting on a replay for Dragon Utopia, can repeat this against another opponent.
The tournament isn't for money, and it's not even certain that a title will be awarded, so why engage in this filth? Moreover, to do it consciously, knowing exactly how the opponent will feel.
On stream, togonash entered the mill without breaking through the guards, then worried about it, but didn't write гг and didn't tell the opponent. In other words, it's not a matter of principle, but simply dirty play. No fair play at all, tearing throats out for a victory in a fan tournament with no prize. :smile12:
I read a quote in someone's signature saying that the Heroes community is built on trust and understanding. True story... or not?
Auto-translated
It seems that the rules in general, and the section about "fair play" in particular, need to be revised...
PReDS
Auto-translated
...and the clause about "fair play" needs to be revised...
Auto-translated
At a minimum, it should be stated what constitutes fair play and what elements it includes. The current wording is somewhat vague...
fil0sof
Auto-translated
Firstly, such a case happened only once, if I remember correctly, and only in a fan-made game. And that turn was replayed. So, don't write as if it's the ultimate truth. That is, are you accusing me of playing dirty? I want to hear a clear and concise answer: "yes" or "no," and then we can talk about the specifics: who is who.
I apologize for answering a question addressed to someone else. If you're not interested in my answer, just ignore it.
My answer is yes :)
Well, more precisely, the question itself isn't entirely correct: I'm not authorized to accuse you in principle. But yes, I consider your action to be dirty play. And it looks even worse considering that you were on the other side and didn't like it. Nevertheless, even knowing firsthand what it's like, you decided to engage in this...
Added 2 minutes later
At the very least, define what constitutes fair play and what elements it includes. Because the current wording is somewhat vague...
Maybe also define what "game" is, what "elements" are, what "wording" is, and what "define" means? Don't take things to the extreme...
Toganash
Auto-translated
I apologize for answering a question addressed to someone else. If you're not interested in my answer, just ignore it.
...
fil0sof
Auto-translated
Let's start by saying that I didn't resort to personal attacks, and I hope you won't either in the future.
I don't know what you decided, I didn't observe your private conversations, I only saw the situation as described by Lizard and expressed my thoughts on the matter.
Regarding the mill situation, I apologize if I wasn't tactful enough in my statements. I didn't mean to say anything about that episode because, as you rightly pointed out, I have no information about it. When I talked about unfair play, I meant the principle of "they treated me in a way I didn't like, so I called for justice on the forum, didn't achieve justice, and decided to do the same thing myself, i.e., do what I just verbally condemned."
I don't even want to comment on the statements about "reputation." If you seriously believe that you can gain "reputation" in some forum discussion...
In short, if the conversation has turned into unproductive arguments and personal insults, I don't see any point in continuing it. You and Lizard have come to an agreement – great. If you believe you are right and will continue to do so, good for you, keep it up.
I don't have much more to say in this situation
Statistics
Welcome our newest member:
recijeb