Appeals Committee. Disputed situations in tournaments. — Tournament Committee

=Lizard=

11 years ago

Auto-translated

I must admit, Toganaш is absolutely reasonable and fair. Perhaps in this whole story, there weren't any posts without claims to absolute truth. So, a replay is the right outcome. p.s. It would be cool to set up a cross-server connection with China again.

In reply to =Lizard=

Toganash

11 years ago

Auto-translated

=Lizard=

I must admit, Togannash is absolutely reasonable and fair. Perhaps in this whole story, there weren't any posts without claims to the truth. So, a replay is the right outcome.

p.s. It would be cool to set up a cross-portal with China again;).

I fully acknowledge the legitimate indignation on the part of my opponent and am even more grateful to him for his constructive approach to the discussion.

Сатир

11 years ago

Auto-translated

What was Валенка banned for?

zoog

11 years ago

Auto-translated

Toganash

It was after such incidents that I wrote to the judges on the forum, stating that I would act in the same way in the future.

This is understandable; it's a good way to point out the flaws in the rules (by the way, hackers who engage in similar searches for exploits for the benefit of society are often arrested – it's not worth emulating them). However, what will you say in response to the arguments repeatedly presented here in favor of adhering strictly to the letter of the rules?

In reply to Сатир

LeBron

11 years ago

Auto-translated

Satyr

Why was Валенка banned?

He was put in the corner for bad behavior and inappropriate pictures :D

In reply to LeBron

KobRa_RR

11 years ago

Auto-translated

LeBron

was put in time-out for bad behavior and inappropriate pictures :D

For an innocent bus?? Maybe Valenok himself asked to be banned?! :)

bubuch

11 years ago

Auto-translated

cast a spell on the bus)

Sloth_D

11 years ago

Auto-translated

I've been reading here about the "moshning" of a replay due to an alleged hit-run.
We're doing great... :smile13:
I am amazed how someone, having been in the same situation (Dragon Utopia) and feeling all the cretinism of the moshner playing as Dragon Utopia, can repeat this against another opponent.
The tournament isn't for money, and it's not certain that a title will be awarded, so why engage in this filth? Moreover, to do it consciously, knowing exactly how the opponent will feel.
On stream, togonash entered the mill without breaking through the guards, then worried about it, but didn't write гг or tell the opponent. In other words, it's not a matter of principle, but simply dirty play. No fair play at all, fighting tooth and nail for a victory in a fan tournament with no prize pool. :smile12:

I read a quote in someone's signature saying that the same-game community is built on trust and understanding. True story... or not?

Juristis

11 years ago

Auto-translated

You can enter windmills without breaking them.

In reply to Juristis

Dirty_Player

11 years ago

Auto-translated

Juristis

You can enter the windmills without breaking them.

Why all of a sudden? :confused:

In reply to Dirty_Player

Lider1

11 years ago

Auto-translated

Dirty_Player

Why suddenly? :confused:

:smile16:

2.7.2. It is allowed to obtain bonuses in Mystic Gardens, Watermills, and Windmills, Pavilions, and collect Chests, Campfires, and resources without destroying the guards, either by moving them aside or using the spells Flight, Spatial Gate, and the artifact Angel Wings.

.....

In reply to Sloth_D

fil0sof

11 years ago

Auto-translated

Sloth_D

I am amazed that someone who has been in the same situation (Dragon Utopia), and felt all the cretinism of Moshner's approach to Dragon Utopia, would repeat it against another opponent.

As was explained to me in response to a similar question, "What, should I turn the other cheek like in the Bible?!". Meaning, it doesn't even occur to people that there is a difference between the principle of "an eye for an eye" and "they shat on you - so shit on someone else, let's all live in filth". Just forget it, it's useless...
You're right, these aren't principles at all; it's simply a complete disregard for mutual respect and fair, open play...

In reply to fil0sof

KobRa_RR

11 years ago

Auto-translated

fil0sof

As I was explained in response to a similar question, "am I supposed to turn the other cheek like in the Bible?!". That is, people don't even consider the difference between the principles of "an eye for an eye" and "they messed with you - mess with them back, let's all live in the mud." Forget it, it's pointless...
You're right, these aren't principles at all, it's just a complete disregard for mutual respect and fair, open gameplay...

+1000 .