Skip to content

Posts from Calculating the rating for clans!

5.0 (1 rating)
In reply to AlexeyPank
User Avatar
19 years ago
Auto-translated
IronAxe;68675
Kyle, what will you do with the clan rating when people start joining and leaving clans all over the place?
First of all, please don't go off-topic in other threads! There are dedicated threads for that!

Secondly, regarding the matter at hand:
In my opinion, it's very simple... the rating is calculated based on tournaments, so let's say: player X was in clan A and played n tournaments, therefore the rating for these n tournaments is attributed to clan A. Then, the player moved to clan B, so this clan will only be credited with the rating for new tournaments. That is, the old rating will remain with clan A. I think this is the fairest system. Or
In reply to Kyle
User Avatar
19 years ago
Auto-translated
Kyle;68786
First of all, don't go off-topic in other threads! There are dedicated threads for that!
Oh, come on, it wasn't that off-topic :) It's actually quite relevant. I saw an example of people switching from one Clan to another, or even leaving Clans altogether, so this post naturally fit into your thread.
Kyle;68786

Secondly, to the point:
In my opinion, it's very simple... the rating is calculated based on tournament results, so let's say: player X was in Clan A and played n tournaments, so the rating for these n tournaments is attributed to Clan A, then the player switched to Clan B, and this Clan will only be credited with the rating for new tournaments. i.e., the old rating will remain in Clan A. I think this is the fairest system. Or do you disagree?
I almost agree :) Because, hypothetically, if over time some people leave Clans, and others switch from one Clan to another, what will this Clan rating reflect when people leave their results in one Clan and then earn a rating for another? In my opinion, there's no way to avoid having Clan ratings that age over time :)
In reply to IronAxe
User Avatar
19 years ago
Auto-translated
IronAxe;68904
Oh come on, you're really going off topic here.
Off-topic is off-topic! :D
IronAxe;68904
I almost agree :) Because if we assume hypothetically that over time some people will leave Clans, others will move around by leaving some Clans and joining others, then what will this Clan rating reflect when people leave their results in one Clan and then earn a rating for another. In my opinion, it is impossible to do without aging of Clan ratings :)
Well, everything is simple here... You just didn't keep up with the developments... The Clan rating is limited in time! i.e., it is a cyclic rating (this was written about earlier here). Therefore, there will be no such problems! And I don't want to introduce aging... well, you know that anyway... :D

Sincerely.
In reply to Kyle
User Avatar
19 years ago
Auto-translated
Kyle;68905
Well, it's simple here… You just didn’t keep up with the developments… The Clan rating is time-limited! i.e., this is a cyclical rating (this was mentioned earlier here). Therefore, there will be no such problems! And I don’t want to introduce aging… well, you already know that… :D
I understand, so each New Year, each clan starts with a clean slate :) That is, with all zeros? Well, if that’s the case, then it works.
User Avatar
19 years ago
Auto-translated
Kyle, I looked at the rankings you calculated. First, thank you very much for the work you did! And second, I still have a comment. Is that okay? Knight is listed in your ranking and has been added to our clan's list. However, he was only accepted into the clan on March 1st, and as I understand it, the tournament ended on February 28th. So, I would appreciate it if you could look into this and, if possible, take this fact into account!
In reply to Ta Kotoraya...
User Avatar
19 years ago
Auto-translated
Ta Kotoraya...;71274
Kyle, I looked at the rankings you calculated.
First, thank you very much for the work you did!!!!!
Second, I still have a comment. Is that okay? Knight is listed in your ranking and has been added to our clan's list. However, he was only accepted into the clan on March 1st, and the tournament ended on February 28th, as I understand it. So, I would appreciate it if you could look into this and, if possible, take this fact into account!
And I don't understand where you found out about Night's result - why don't I see it anywhere? Kyle, tell me where you got Night's result.
In reply to IronAxe
User Avatar
19 years ago
Auto-translated
IronAxe;71349
And I can't figure out where you found out about Night's result - why don't I see it anywhere? Kyle - spill it, where did you get Night's result :)
a little bird told me... :D
But seriously, thanks to VDV_forever for providing the information... :)

Respectfully.

Added after 9 hours 42 minutes
Ta Kotoraya...;71274
And secondly, I do have a comment. Ok? It's just that Night is calculated in your rating and included in our clan list. However, he was only accepted into the clan on March 1 - while the tournament ended on February 28, as I understand it. So accordingly... please look into this, and if not too difficult, take this fact into account!
Already taken into account... updated everything.... :smile33:
User Avatar
18 years ago
Auto-translated
Dear Clan Representatives,

The Clan Ranking on our portal has been updated; I invite everyone to review it and consider the current situation (I especially ask clan leaders to think about it).

Sincerely.
User Avatar
18 years ago
Auto-translated
Dear Clan Representatives,

The Clan Ranking on our portal has been updated; I invite everyone to take a look.

Congratulations to the clan "Alliance of the Undead" – for moving out of the zero position in Heroes 4. Keep up the good work! :smile20:

Sincerely.
User Avatar
18 years ago
Auto-translated
Dear Clan Representatives,

The Clan Ranking on our portal has been updated; I invite everyone to take a look.

Congratulations to the clan "Knights of the Apocalypse" – for moving out of zero place in Heroes 5. Keep it up! :smile20:

Also, in the Heroes 2 nomination, the clan "From Many, One" overtook the clan "Haven" and took third place.

Sincerely.
User Avatar
18 years ago
Auto-translated
I would like to express my sincere gratitude to Kamikaze for his help in finding errors and typos in the ranking.
:smile12: Thank you very much! :smile12:
User Avatar
18 years ago
Auto-translated
Dear Clan Representatives,

The Clan Ranking on our portal has been updated; I invite everyone to review it. The update affected the Heroes 1 nomination due to the completion of: Tournament No. 7 for Heroes 1 "Companionship" (Stage 3)

The clan "From Many, One" overtook the clan "Order of the Phoenix" and took second place. :smile12: Congratulations! :smile12:

Sincerely.
User Avatar
18 years ago
Auto-translated
I wanted to ask about the "New World" tournament. Is it a rated tournament? Meaning, does it also contribute to the clan ranking, right?
In reply to Kamikaze
User Avatar
18 years ago
Auto-translated
Kamikaze;139157
I wanted to ask about the "New World" tournament. Is it a ranked tournament? Meaning, does it also contribute to the clan ranking, right?
Yes, it is a ranked tournament; I will add it in the near future. ;)

Statistics

Welcome our newest member: recijeb

Users Online 2 users 1305 guests