Posts from "Newcomer-2009. Winter"

The situations of "rest due to a block" and "one road in ГО" are not like two peas in a pod. They are, excuse me, like heaven and earth... One road in ГО is a difficult situation, a strong block at the castle exit is an insurmountable one. So don't compare them. The fact that a strong block is not provided for in the rules is probably to prevent abuse.
I have nothing to add

Added after 4 minutes
So, here's the thing.
They agreed to ask me if this was a block. I answered that yes, it was a block. Will anyone else argue that this is a block? What does breaking on the third week have to do with it? You need to break on the third ГО, not break through the castle exit. Here again is an unequal comparison. A worse spawn is normal. A block at the exit is not a game, it's just: the spawn gave such a situation that you can't play no matter how much you want. And not giving a re in such a situation — that's nonsense.

Wow... I managed to get out of the castle on the third week!!! :smile52::smile52::smile52:

I fully agree with Gomunguls. I'll repeat myself - change the rules for the tournament. I'm sure there will be other dissatisfied players in similar situations.

I see you still don't understand... He has the right to grant a rest, and he has the right not to. And the fact that you're trying to pressure him with your authority to give a rest is not good!!! There are forum rules that everyone follows, and there's no need to change them!!! A block is when you can't leave the city, but here you can leave, and I exploited that... I'm telling you... and the fact that breaking the game on turn 3 is not standard... and not giving a rest, there's nothing shameful about it... it's a tournament!!! I'm not going to waste my time while he's there choosing his next move... he has 2 legal rests... I think that says it all!!!

There's no block there, it's just a map bug. Because there should be some kind of mine near the castle (wood, stone, whatever)...

We play according to the seasonal rules. If the seasonal rules change, the tournament rules will change accordingly.

Formally, you are right; if we follow the letter of the law, a restart shouldn't be given in this case. I was asked, and I advised giving one. I also said that it's an impassable block. In response, they started arguing that this block isn't that strong; now they say it can only be broken through on the third attempt...

In short:
If player A, who ultimately lost, feels it's right to submit a report claiming a victory on turn 112, that's their right. I think player B will confirm it and won't argue. I would also accept it.

Basically, it's like this: If player A, who ultimately lost, feels comfortable writing a report about winning on turn 112, that's his right. I think player B will confirm it and won't argue. I would accept it too.

To all participants: if your opponent doesn't allow a restart due to a block, don't give up, play to the end....And it's possible that you will be the first to find winning strategies....Read the season reports, because the game doesn't end just because someone breaks your Gate of the Month and captures your starting Castle; you can return after a week and give them a beating for such audacity))). Gather a large army, collect as many artifacts as possible, gain control of Dungeon, Tower, or Wings, and torment your opponent....
Good luck!!

I don't know who was playing, but allow me to remark.
Kash, do you remember what you answered to this post:
/topic/at/308115/
The situation is similar as two peas in a pod.
Your answer.

This is a tournament, not a market where you can bargain. If you came up with such rules, then let's follow them. I said that similar situations could occur, but you yourself said sorry, we won't change the rules. So this is reaping what you sowed, no offense meant.
And if the AC decides to replay the game, that will go against the rules. For example, in this game, what could have happened next?
Player B gives a restart to player A due to a block. After the restart, player A discovers on day 4 that he has only 1 road to the Griffin Conservatory. He asks for a restart. According to moral rules, player B should give it, hmm... but what if he doesn't??
What is this haggling? Rules are rules.

To prevent this in the playoffs - change the rules for the tournament.

Kash - what was it about the action that you didn't like? Because according to your rules a restart is forbidden, and a person played by the rules????

P.S. I don't want to offend anyone and I don't know who was playing, just an interesting situation.

and he starts to PROVE to ME that it's not a block (Victor)

I want Soroka white to be credited, he really wanted that!

and he also asked for an auto, but I gave him a break instead

After that, he acted like a real magpie

he said that he could really beat them on 121