Dialogues with Moderators — Suggestions and improvements.

wolf64

17 years ago

Auto-translated

Kyle

....I think that first, we need to create a proper hall of fame for players.

Vitaly-Kamikaze already does a lot in this area. He came up with a very good rating system for Tournaments (awarding points)... plus, he quickly summarizes the results of each tournament for all versions and awards rating points. At my request, he increased the number of players who make it into the final table for the year (both the top 40 and for each one separately)... because before, it was only the top ten.
The results of all tournaments are in tables and are very clearly presented. Therefore, everyone can see themselves in the table if they played in tournaments... well, and the winners already have medals under their avatars.

Kyle

And if a person has done a lot for the forum, they will be known and remembered anyway. There is no need to highlight this in any special way.

Newcomers who appear on the portal are unlikely to immediately (if they even find out, and probably only about those who organized the tournaments) learn about the past achievements of the old-timers... if there is no information in a prominent place.

Kyle

Although there are already awards for developing the portal: example. And to highlight them in any other way - IMHO: this is unnecessary.

Marking our female members with flowers under their avatars every year is a very interesting idea!!! But this applies to all women, without exception, regardless of their contribution to the development of the portal...
And each one is interesting in her own way... and they also please us - men - with their presence on the site.
Like Katya-Luchik... she just works hard for the benefit of the portal... and visible gratitude - several bouquets in her avatar (as with other women who have been on the portal for more than one year, but their merits to the site are, to put it mildly, a little less)

In reply to wolf64

Kyle

17 years ago

Auto-translated

wolf64

Marking our ladies with flowers under their avatars every year is a very interesting move!!! But this applies to all ladies, without exception, regardless of their contribution to the development of the portal...
And each of them is interesting in her own way...and they also please us - men - with their presence on the site.
Like Katya-Luchik...she just works hard for the benefit of the portal...and the visible gratitude is a few bouquets in her avatar (as with other ladies who have been on the portal for more than one year, but their merits to the site are, to put it mildly, a little less).

Hmm, why don't you ever fully understand what I'm writing to you.
I gave a link not to the bouquets for March 8, but to unique awards.
Award #1: Reason for awarding: For assistance in the design work of the portal
Date of awarding: 10.08.2006 12:01

Award #2: Reason for awarding: Organizing an international tournament, and just as a good person.
Date of awarding: 31.01.2008 04:10

wolf64

Newcomers who appear on the portal are unlikely to immediately (if they even find out, and probably only about those who organized tournaments) learn about the past merits of the old-timers...if there is no information in a prominent place.

I just don't want those in power to start glorifying themselves. IMHO: this may not end very well.
But maybe I'm wrong.

Good luck.

In reply to Dirty_Player

Kyle

17 years ago

Auto-translated

Dirty_Player

It's high time to somehow highlight such figures as: vbn, VDV, Nagan-4, Catch, Lu41k, and many others!

If Sir Catch is on your list, then it won't be a Hall of Fame for HW anymore. It will be more like a Hall of Fame for the entire "Heroes World." Because Sir Catch's contribution to the HW portal is very small, but his contribution to Heroes as a whole is simply enormous, and it's hard to overestimate it.

IMHO: Therefore, if you're going to create a Hall of Fame, you should include people (including those from other portals, such as Horn, Catch, etc.) who have made a huge contribution to the development of the "Heroes World," rather than just HW moderators.

Good luck.

Qwerty

17 years ago

Auto-translated

2 wolf64
Okay, here's a shortlist of people whose contributions deserve recognition regarding Heroes 2 on our forum:
Katrine
VDV_forever
Qwerty
Alan
vbn
Kyle
Dust
Catch
Brennan
AlexSpl
Monza.

Qwerty

17 years ago

Auto-translated

As I feared, questions arose regarding the justification for including humans in the list published above.
Firstly, this list was compiled based on a combination of merits.
Secondly, I will try to list some of the reasons:
Katrine - for establishing moderation standards;
VDV_forever - for Dragon Slayer and the initial development of the section, as well as for being one of the top players;
Qwerty - for starting and developing offline tournaments;
Alan - for organizing Van Kanegem memorial tournaments for the second game;
vbn - for inventing the hero skill calculator (which doesn't work for me!!!), as well as for the stunning results in the 2007 season, which led to an overall improvement in the level of play among forum members;
Kyle - for preparing, organizing, and conducting offline tournaments;
Dust - for organizing and conducting the first and all subsequent joint offline tournaments;
Catch - for organizing and conducting joint offline tournaments in 2008;
Brennan - for boosting the online aspect of our forum;
AlexSpl, Monza - for their programming activities in the second game, in particular for creating a program that allows calculating the hero skill tree (morality and luck in the second game are strictly determined BEFORE the battle and cannot be generated).

In reply to Qwerty

Dirty_Player

17 years ago

Auto-translated

2Kyle:
I just suggested it on the fly, but I think I conveyed the meaning. Although you're right, we should really only reward residents of our portal. And the Hall of Fame is a great idea.
I also suggest that the nicknames of the honored residents be displayed in a color different from other users (for example, Gold).
Yes, and by the way, to make the Hall of Fame truly honorable, there should be no more than 10 people on it, not 30-40.

In reply to Dirty_Player

Alex_R

17 years ago

Auto-translated

(Regarding Controversial Issues and Their Resolution)
What's going on?
Insults, arguments, off-topic discussions, spam, and other things.
Attracting people from other resources... why?
Is it just provocation, or a lack of experience in... well, you know?

Due to the absence of a judge or a responsible person in Heroes 3 online, all issues are resolved by moderators and coordinators, and it MUST be understood that the coordinator has a more authoritative say than the moderator (even if they are not as knowledgeable or involved in a specific issue).
Reminder! When discussing any topic, don't forget...
1) ... that there are ICQ/QIP; private messages; special threads on the forum, etc.
2) Forum rules - which everyone usually "skims through" during registration, and they include, for example:
- guidelines and restrictions on message formatting (for those who, for example, are unhappy with the font color);
- definitions of basic terms (spam, off-topic, etc.);
- hierarchical structure of the administration (for those who think that a Moderator is more competent than a Coordinator). Moreover, if you cannot do a better job than the coordinator, or if you don't support someone who could actually do it better, then such criticism and accusations of incompetence are equivalent to mere chatter or discussing the actions of the administration.

In reply to Alex_R

Kyle

17 years ago

Auto-translated

Alex_R

Reminder! When discussing any topic, don't forget...

I completely agree with what has been said above. :smile20:

I hope that all players involved in the dispute are reading this thread. :rolleyes:

Дубровин Павел

17 years ago

Auto-translated

What I would like to say:
I ask that Valera (Loi) be unbanned, because even if he made certain statements that led to his ban, he was motivated by noble intentions of justice.
And it is not his fault that the saves were uploaded incorrectly, which confused everyone.
Valera is a true devotee of Heroes, standing up for the principles of "fair play"!
I ask that you listen to me...:)

In reply to Дубровин Павел

Javdet

17 years ago

Auto-translated

Dubrovin Pavel

What I want to say:
I ask you to unban Valera (Loi), because if he did make some statements that led to his ban, then he was motivated by high ideals of justice.
And it's not his fault that the saves were uploaded incorrectly, which confused everyone.
Valera is a true fan of Heroes, standing up for the principles of "fair play"!
I ask you to listen to me...:)

Oh my god... I support Valera.

In reply to Дубровин Павел

numOne

17 years ago

Auto-translated

I agree with Pavel! The ban on Valera is a real absurdity. They could at least say what he did to deserve it. Was it because he didn't fawn over Djede's avatar like everyone else?

In reply to numOne

Dirty_Player

17 years ago

Auto-translated

Gentlemen, what are you writing here? Write directly to the Creator in a private message!

In reply to Дубровин Павел

SEM_56

17 years ago

Auto-translated

I also support lifting the ban on the highly respected Loi....
It's unlikely you'll find another Heroes player as active as him on the forum!
In my opinion, the ban was too harsh; a warning would have been sufficient.
And when did expressing personal opinions and views become grounds for such severe action? Explain yourselves!!!

In reply to Дубровин Павел

Ta Kotoraya...

17 years ago

Auto-translated

Dubrovin Pavel

What I want to say:
I ask you to unban Valera (Loi), because even if he made some statements that led to his ban, he was motivated by high ideals of justice.
And it's not his fault that the saves were uploaded incorrectly, which confused everyone.
Valera is a true fan of Heroes, standing up for the principles of "fair play"!
I ask you to listen to me...:)

I DEFINITELY SUPPORT THIS!!! Unban him - what, now you can ban someone just for having an opinion that doesn't match the coordinator's?
Loi is a wonderful person!! Unban him!!!

Lider1

17 years ago

Auto-translated

Definitely, unban Loi. They drove the person to the point where they started deleting players from their ICQ contact list.

And some people really need to read the posts of the people writing here and stop acting like they're all that!:smile51: :smile51: :smile51:

Reading content in

Interface language

Posts from Dialogues with Moderators

Statistics

Library

Users Online 10 users 1317 guests

Today's Visitors 32