Posts from Mafia 112. Pirates of the HW Sea

I control the game. I also sacrifice my heroes to have time for gaining experience. Just kidding.

Okay. But all my questions remain after replacing the word "Cop" with the word "<whoever has the sparrow role>..."

I agree with you that there's no point in blocking the Cop if they've already been checked. But blocking someone else, whom they considered a Kraken, for example, is a perfectly valid move. But they ended up targeting Jack, who then redirected them to the Cop. My theory is that's exactly what happened.

I stopped understanding anything.
Why did the Mafia block Ment? And why shouldn't they?

I'm reading, but

I'll leave the voice as is.

I'm reading, but

I'll leave the voice as is.

Based.

Perhaps we didn't know the true face of Ment. Perhaps he was incredibly cool. But the tentacles deprived us of the opportunity to unravel his mysteries.

Added after 42 seconds

I'm reading it, but

I'll leave the voice as is.

I'm reading the expansion.

I agree with you that there's no point in blocking Mental if they've already checked him. But blocking someone else, whom they considered a "kraken" for example, is a perfectly valid move. However, they ended up hitting Jack, who then targeted Mental. My theory is that this is exactly what happened.

Such a move is possible, in principle... But then who did they kill? Did they go to reduce the "Kraken's" defense with Clap and also hit Mental?
This is possible, but it seems unlikely. It would have been easier to simply kill Kraken with Beckett, since the chance that Kraken would hit Beckett is minimal.

They could have also targeted the natural defense.

They couldn't, Beckett breaks through everything. But, as correctly noted, Jack could have redirected the attack back to Heroist, to Mental, to the monkey. They could have also just shot at the monkey. So, the complaint is withdrawn.

Why did the Mafia block Ment? And why shouldn't they?

Answers like "randomly," "for laughs," etc., will not be accepted...

But I don't understand why they couldn't have blocked it.

Actually, I also don't understand why the Mafia didn't block Mental. But I don't want a No Night Vote.

But if he were a Heroes player instead of a Heroist, they wouldn't have executed him so easily.

I claim it.
Monkey theft on Revan.
Mafia block on Mente.
James' protection on Neyra.
Will's protection on Ples.
Kraken kill on Mente.

Do you agree that on the first night, the monkey stole a bottle from Heroist?

Neyra, I'm still waiting for your answer.

Let's be honest, there isn't a single person here who is 100% sure of anything, except perhaps about the character Yaschur. This game is essentially about guessing and figuring out what will occur. Even now, the picture could be completely wrong due to a misinterpretation of some small detail. The probability of error here is at least 50% for almost any action, except for very straightforward ones like Jack's.

It's impossible to interpret anything here with certainty! I realized this on the very first day of the game, after reading the first newspaper.

Yes, a roulette wheel has a better chance of correctly determining who did what than these speculations, lol.

Therefore, between two probabilities, I choose the one where the potential gain is greater. In the event of failure, the difference is still small.