Posts from Mafia 112. Pirates of the HW Sea Auto-translated

What’s the point of doing it that way if you get punished for one role, but another role is responsible for the kill according to the newspaper?

I agree to vote for conviction if evidence emerges, but until then, I won't change my vote.

What's the point of doing that if you're going to be executed based on a single role, while someone else is killing based on information from the newspaper?

Are you referring to the role that Revan told you in the Mafia chat? I don't think it's worth executing Mirka-Nebka on the first day.

Based on the role Revan told you in the Mafia chat? I don't think it's a good idea to execute Mirka-Nebka on the first day.

No, it's something else.
Go ahead and investigate, what's stopping you... I didn't promise anything to anyone from the start, but you did.

Menti, I specifically reread the setting and don't see a peaceful role that Revan could reasonably insist on executing Nebk for.

Even Cotton, in a random game, can identify 1 or 2 items – no more. So, if Revan were Cotton, the only person he could identify with 100% certainty would be Clap, because no one else has the combination of a sword + bottle. But this scenario is pure fantasy. Are you basing your theory on this, or am I missing some other peaceful role from the setting?

This.

From the Quenta Koshi, he moved to the Quenta Fragmenta

Added 1 minute ago

No, it's something else.
Well, dig up the evidence, what's stopping you... I didn't promise anyone anything from the start, but you did.

So, I'm waiting for you to solve it, not for me to. It's not clear from the context of those messages, so don't play dumb).

I won't support this execution then.

If there are real arguments, let me know.

So I expect you to figure it out, not me. It's as if this isn't clear from the context of those messages; don't play dumb.

/topic/at/1257455/
Were those your words? And where did I promise that I would dig up evidence? That’s what I thought…

Then I won't support this execution.

If there are real arguments, let me know.

There are two options here, or rather three. Either an incredible event happened and Reva should be listened to, or he is lying and needs to be put on the block (and who can be sure of this, so what are you waiting for? Go ahead!), or he is joking (but frankly, that's just bad behavior).

In my opinion, Revan is currently executing Nebka based on information about the Night Watchman. He could be a Mafia member setting up Mirka, or simply someone who decided to execute randomly to avoid having no executions.
Why Ment joined this – that’s a big question. When he supported drug-fueled theories in the previous game, it turned out he was a Mafia member. It's disappointing if you allowed one of your former comrades to die. What next? Will you cut me down?
Ples is still under suspicion only because his block suspiciously coincided with the absence of investigations from two negative roles.
Neb actively tries to analyze the evidence – that’s good. He focuses on the Kraken clue and not on the Mafia members – that’s bad.
I don’t know what to say about the others yet. Kosha is joking around, Sif is cosplaying as Gur, Astral is trying to understand the specifics of Mafia and scumming in ХВ games, Heroist and Frag haven’t said anything substantial (or I missed it), and Arthur is completely silent.

Added 2 minutes ago

/topic/at/1257455/
Are those not your words? And where did I promise to investigate clues? That's why... There are two options here, or rather three. Either this incredible event happened, and Reva should be listened to, or he is lying and needs to be executed (and who can be sure of this, so what are you waiting for? Go ahead!), or he is just messing around (but frankly, that's a terrible thing to do).

Didn't Revan confidently hint that he was executing Nebka based on information about the Night Watchman, and not just for fun? Can you provide a link to the post(s)?

NNV? What is it?

No one should be hanged.

Is there a type where no one is executed between nights?

Yeah, if the majority votes for "No Night Vote" or, for example, no one gets the required minimum number of votes, then the day will end with everyone surviving the second night.

If everyone votes for NNV, the negative players will have more time to eliminate peaceful players.