Skip to content

Posts from Heroes 5 – “A masterpiece or an unfinished product?”

General Closed Topic
No ratings yet — be the first to rate!
Closed
What steps should the developers take regarding Heroes 5?
65 voters
Single choice
This poll is closed.
Make minor improvements and release it by the end of March
15.4% 10 votes
Refine bug fixes more carefully and postpone the release date.
29.2% 19 votes
Careful refinement, postponement of release, another test, further refinement, release
55.4% 36 votes
User Avatar
20 years ago
Auto-translated
I've been saying for a long time that this is how it should end. Now we can close the thread.
In reply to Alan
User Avatar
20 years ago
Auto-translated
Alan
"THE WRITERS ARE IDIOTS" were from Ubisoft, they are the ones who wrote the plot.
Ubi wrote the heroes (and biographies). Nival was responsible for the script.
2Uke-by_HoMM![Zavulon]
1. Three was never my favorite game in the series. Only 3rd place.
2. There was no random distribution of turns. If in 5, the hero gets the 1st turn and dragons get the 2nd, then victory is 100% probable. (Illusion on dragons and a simultaneous strike on weak stacks; as a result, an increase in morale and all subsequent effects)
In Three, all turns (the order) are known in advance.
3. Which series traditions were observed in 5?
4. Useless skills. The entire Ballistics branch, all abilities related to Logistics, the Curse and Blessing branches (completely), a number of frankly useless points in Luck, Leadership, Summoning.
5. An unclear magic system. For the Necromancer in the guild without raising dead, for the Academy not a single combat spell except Armageddon.
Which heroes were like that?
In reply to ТИГРЁНОК
User Avatar
20 years ago
Auto-translated
The fifth installment absorbed all the best features from the third game and added a lot of new content. The game is awesome!
In reply to Cornelius
User Avatar
20 years ago
Auto-translated
Cornelius
The fifth installment absorbed all the best features from the third game and added a lot of new things. The game is awesome!!!!!!!!!
I can forgive you for everything, *****, but I can't forgive you for saying that the fifth game is the best in the series and that it has more than 50% in common with the third game. People, are you completely crazy, or did you never really play the third game properly:mad:
In reply to ТИГРЁНОК
User Avatar
20 years ago
Auto-translated
TIGRYONOK
I can forgive you idiots for anything, but I can't forgive the fact that the 5th game is the best in the series and that it has more than 50% in common with the 3rd. People, are you completely stupid, or did you never really play the 3rd game:mad:

Tigryonok, to be honest, is completely out of line! Did you even play them?
Your statements make me want to find you in real life and...
By the way, we live not far from each other.
You don't seem to be reading the messages; most people aren't claiming that the 5th game is the best in the series. They'
User Avatar
20 years ago
Auto-translated
The game is certainly different, but if you look at its continuity, it was definitely made based on the third installment... (BASED on it, not a carbon copy...)
But it's a completely different game... (what do you expect from a company, from developers... everything is new, and you want the game to be old? (: )
20 years ago
Auto-translated
to Katrine, why did you assign so many excellent abilities to unnecessary skills? And you didn't skimp on the Necromancers' ability to raise the dead... at level 2, they can resurrect their units in a completely overpowered way, and it's almost always present in the magic guild.
In reply to Sergh
User Avatar
20 years ago
Auto-translated
Sergh
The game is certainly different, but if you look at the continuity, it was definitely made based on the third installment... (BASED on it, not a carbon copy...)
But it's a completely different game... (and what do you expect from the company, the developers... everything is new, and you want the game to be old? (: )

:) I agree with that.
In reply to Enot
User Avatar
20 years ago
Auto-translated
Enot
to Katrine aaaaa, why did you assign so many great abilities to unnecessary skills??? and they didn't skimp on raising the dead for the Necromancers... at level 2, they can resurrect their units in a completely overpowered way, it's almost always present in their magic guild.
Apparently, I'm just unlucky with my guild;)
Alan
Katrine at least tries to justify his claims, even though he's wrong. 8))
:p
Can someone tell me what I need to do in the final stage of the Elven campaign?
I've killed Nicholas 5 times.
I
In reply to Katrine
User Avatar
20 years ago
Auto-translated
Katrine

Which heroes had that?
The answer is obvious... in the 5th game....
And in general, why criticize Nival? In my opinion, they created quite decent heroes... remember, this is Nival's first experience...
I agree, there are flaws... but there are no perfect games... I doubt that Heroes 6 will appear... Nival and Ubisoft are already talking about it... So why criticize the 5th game so much? If you don't like it, don't play it...
In reply to Vlad
User Avatar
20 years ago
Auto-translated
Xaker
The answer is obvious... in the 5th installment....
And in general, why criticize Nival? In my opinion, they created quite decent heroes... don't forget, this is Nival's first experience...
I agree, there are flaws... but there are no perfect games... I doubt that Heroes 6 won't appear... Nival and Ubisoft are definitely already talking about it... So why criticize the 5th installment so harshly... if you don't like it, don't play it...
I don't like it and I won't.
But to see how they turn a legend into this... Excuse me...

To Nival - "If you can't do it, don't take it on!"
User Avatar
20 years ago
Auto-translated
Kathrin, could you write a script? Because everyone is quick to criticize (not always constructively), but when it comes to actually doing the work...
And create different ability trees (6 distinct ones!), and then I'll agree.
In reply to Tengro
User Avatar
20 years ago
Auto-translated
Tengro
Kathrin, could you write the script? Because everyone is good at writing criticism (not always constructive), but when it comes to actually doing the work...
And create different ability trees (6 distinct ones!), and then I'll agree.
We'll see what comes to mind... I think the other developers, except for Nival, would have made this game even worse.
20 years ago
Auto-translated
Boy... quite a bit of demagoguery going on here...
Who told you that Heroes 5 should be like other Heroes games? I love the 2nd one most of all, but I'm not screaming that the griffins aren't with the Warlock!
This is a completely different game, a different style, and it should be viewed as a project in need of support, not as "Heroes 3: Part Five"...
Xaker is right. Don't like it much? Then don't play. What's the point of saying "Stupid game!"? Explain your point of view: what, how, and why. Not everyone is as smart as you! Especially since there's no reason to criticize Nival and Ubi. There must have been some reasons why they specifically were the ones making the game. They were given an idea and a blueprint, and they brought it to life. In my opinion, quite well.

On subject: It's made competently, and it's interesting to play. Few downsides (such as: everything is very slow, models aren't fully detailed, etc.)
20 years ago
Auto-translated
Regarding Heroes, I wouldn't want to use certain words – it would make the game worse, I'd say – it's unlikely they would make it better.

Statistics

Welcome our newest member: recijeb