Posts from GO FOR IT, NEWBIE!!!

In the morning, there was a reasonable post from VLK777, but during the day, it disappeared.

The question is whether it makes sense to mention subparagraph "c" here. The idea is that if there is no tower building, then you need to completely build 2 of any towers. But this is subparagraph 5.2 "a". It is unclear why you can gain the right to use a scroll by taking Pandora with a completely different hero, playing as Stronghold/Swamp/Castle.

Here, Valentin and Pasha agree with me. And I also said that only magic specialists can do it. And in the case described above, they cannot. That is, as I understand it, Kirr or Tiaz cannot use the explosion scroll, for example, if they took Pandora with the entire map, but wisdom did not allow them to learn the spells. That is, if there is no wisdom in this case, then it's all over.

Pavel, you're once again beating around the bush. Tell me, why do you think the rules state "even if there is no corresponding wisdom"? Just for the sake of it? It's obvious that it can be used; this has been discussed for a long time. The problem is that if, when opening the Pandora's Box, the required magic isn't available, then a technical issue arises. As a judge, you don't have the right to prioritize your personal opinion over the current tournament rules. If you don't like the rules, change them, but for now, they are what they are.

Here, I thought that the key phrase is "THERE IS NO corresponding GM level." That is, it can be understood literally - if there isn't one, then there isn't, and whether it can be built in principle is a different question. That's why I edited that post myself.

Added 12 minutes later
Pasha is our well-known interpreter of the rules :) I remember how he insisted on breaking through from several guards of the respawn point, always the closest one. Well, even though the rules say "any one of your choice" - that doesn't matter, Pasha has his own opinion :D

Valentin, I would ask you to distinguish when I express my opinion as a Player, and when I interpret the Rules as a Judge and say how I would act as a Judge.

As a judge, you should follow the rules, and everything is written there. However, if you want, you can turn everything upside down and justify it by saying, "I'm the judge, and my decision is final." The argument about the connection between wisdom and the spellbook is very weak. Spellbooks can be used without wisdom and without any restrictions, and that's already clear. I'll repeat it again: if you don't like the rules, change them, but for now, they are what they are.

I have expressed my opinion as one of the Judges of the Seasonal Ranking; if you don't like it, I apologize. :)
In any case, if there is a dispute between players, and one of the disputing parties wants to appeal to the Arbitration Committee (AC), the dispute will be considered by the AC, not by a Judge of the Seasonal Ranking, so "it's not about me." :)

As another Judge of the Seasonal Ranking, I will say that both Pasha and Valentin are right...

But sometimes, the Pandora artifact is really empty, or was there really magic in it??))

But sometimes, Pandora's Box really is empty, or was there actually magic in it?

How can the game even ask such a question? :confused:

Regarding scrolls and Pandora's Boxes, it's nonsense. Kluka wrote everything correctly. Just delete one letter, v, and everything will be fine.

That is, without fulfilling the conditions in the Rules, none of the Heroes can use Scrolls higher than Tier 3 Magic (exceptions - Specialists with Tier 4 Magic, if the found Scroll matches the Magic they have "by birth," and only on "neutrals").

Although I'm too lazy to look for links, I remember that this question was raised in some topic about a year ago, and it seems that no one objected to what I wrote - in the sense that you can use scrolls after eating half of the Pandora's Box due to the lack of Wisdom.

If a hero does not have a sufficient level of Wisdom to learn spells from the Pandora's Box, then they can use them with the help of scrolls, but only after building the corresponding Guild. Because (let's take the principle of the library, if you have level 10, you get everything plus 2, otherwise, no way), increase your Wisdom...

But how do you know that all the magic was there? Maybe there were only 1-2 levels.

Still, I think like this:
If a hero does not have a sufficient level of Wisdom to learn spells from the Pandora box, then he can use them with the help of scrolls, but only after building the corresponding Guild. Because (let's take the library principle, there is level 10 - get everything plus 2, otherwise it's impossible), increase your Wisdom...

U]

Added 3 minutes later
[/U] Pavel and Roman's thinking is at the level of "I think it would be unfair." The fact that the rules say something different doesn't really bother them.