Posts from Logical duel, aka bugs in Magnus's RPG.

Nothing complicated.
Just arguments for and against the current game mechanics and plot.
Arguments Against
1. It is not specified how damage is calculated.
2. The trading system is not specified.
3. Imbalance with the spell system.
4. Difficulty in calculating skills and imbalance of some abilities (especially those of the Gnomes).
5. Artificial increase in the difficulty for the Rebels (and meanwhile, Magnus gained 5 levels and an army of 1,000,000 warriors just by running around. And while I, for example, am disguised and haven't given any reason to reveal myself, I am exposed by 25 Archangels. And... a cloak for 40 silver? Is it gold-plated?)
6. General primitiveness of the plot (and again, imbalance - 5 against 3, is that normal?) and its inconsistency in at least one aspect - the Light Elf and the Dark Elf can only COOPERATE if it is bad for both of them. But in a relatively peaceful time, they will immediately try to tear each other apart.
Arguments For
1. Familiarity for those who have played Heroes.
2. Ease of starting with the Empire.
3. Convenience of playing as the Empire.
4. Familiar system of spells and transformations (and it is unclear why I should become a vampire if I only become weaker).
5. Familiar atmosphere of chat battles.
6. There is something for those playing RPG-1 to do while RPG-2 is being developed.

Purely subjective conclusions.
Please also share YOUR conclusions after playing.

Cons:
-1 Complete imbalance
-2 Poor activity of GMs. To be honest, I don't know who the GMs are here.
-3 No damage or magic systems. And a bunch of numbers will disappear again.
-4 Some ideas are not used at all (alchemy, for example)
-5 The Rebels are in a bad state. I understand that it is quite realistic, but suppressing any attempts at active action by the Rebels...
Pros:
-6 Super ability: Want to gain respect and be a super guy - say "Glory to the Emperor"
-7 You can write a couple of posts and write one or two sentences.

(Jack fires from cannons... WHAT CANNONS? Magnus gains 5 levels for running. I didn't get even a single experience point for the cut monster cave...)
.

6. ME
And this is exactly what "otherwise, it will be bad for both of us" means.
5. I was disguised – well, I wasn't walking around with my fangs bared! And then this guy catches me with 25 Archangels (WHERE DID THEY COME FROM??? EVERYONE WENT TO THE FRONT!!!)
5 Knight
I don't know about Knight, but I, SUPR, we behave normally.
Regarding the storyline quest – did we get it IN THE GAME? You gave it to yourself. And we, HONEST ROLEPLAYERS, can't read assignments from other players. And what, is joining the Brotherhood mandatory? Then what about freedom? And again... Here, all players IN THE GAME know about the Dark Brotherhood and how to join it... Am I the only stupid one, or are they geniuses?
And Knight is right about point 6. The mechanism is simple – play as the Empire, and NOTHING will interfere with you. Play as the rebels – and a peasant will see a vampire in disguise, and if he doesn't, 25 archangels will crawl out of the AIR and put the scoundrel who doesn't want to die in jail.

Hence, another argument AGAINST

The lack of logical (or is it inhuman logic?) justification for almost EVERYTHING (Jack shoots from cannons... WHAT CANNONS? Magnus gains 5 levels for running. I didn't get even a single experience point for the cut monster cave...).
And... allow me to express my dissatisfaction with your work.
Because the role of the GM (even if it's called GRAND MASTER OF THE TEMPLARS, the essence is the same) is to MAINTAIN BALANCE BETWEEN PLAYERS OF DIFFERENT FACTIONS.
So, either give us a second Grand Master – for the Darkness. Or step out of the conflict.

I understand... BUT WHAT ARE THEY DOING IN A WORLD WHERE GUNPOWDER DOESN'T EXIST YET?

What's so bad about my application?...