Pit for LM
Auto-translated
Following up on the topic of a **permanent rating**.
It is clear that creating an absolute skill measurement is impossible; you can read discussions on this in the relevant threads:
/topic/3352/
/topic/5625/
/topic/5822/
**The history of the issue on HW in the third game.**
Initially, StickyFingaz proposed a new formula, and it was also suggested not to reset the rating every 3 months but to calculate it over a longer period. Under the new system, Sticky himself manually calculated the results for six months, and Vitaly vbn calculated them simultaneously using two formulas during the spring of 2009, taking into account the results from the previous winter in the permanent rating. In the summer of 2009, the new system was adopted by forum vote, and we fully switched to it.
Based on general considerations, Sticky's system provides a more or less objective result over a large time frame and with a large number of games played by each player. Therefore, the idea arose to calculate how many games were included in the permanent rating calculation over the past nine seasons.
There may be some errors because I used the results posted on the forum by Vitaly, and unfortunately, much of that information has been lost because it was placed on another resource. I have corrected some obvious errors in nicknames. There are also players who change their nicknames, as well as clones that appeared in different seasons under different nicknames.
It turned out that the minimum number of games among the players who made it into the top 15 is 32 wins in 32 games for Alex_R - a permanent rating of 1793, 5th place.
Based on this, players who have played more than 30 games will be included in the permanent rating table. This will also exclude "ghost accounts" and at least some clones that periodically start a new life with 1500 points.
**Permanent rating of HOMM3 players who have played more than 30 counted games during the period from Winter 08-09 to February 28, 2011:**
Rank. Nick (wins, losses, games) permanent rating
1. Pit for LM (56, 9, 67) 1883
2. Gomunguls (162, 53, 223) 1855
3. AliaSmehova (34, 2, 36) 1848
4. bRitvo4kA (165, 46, 212) 1796
5. Alex_R (32, 0, 32) 1793
6. AYMAN (224, 84, 319) 1776
7. SEM_56 (307, 210, 532) 1772
8. Vigo (84, 24, 112) 1764
9. numOne (157, 85, 246) 1755
10. Сатир (40, 17, 58) 1738
11. FireToSky (68, 38, 108) 1733
12. Erdem (56, 34, 93) 1728
13. GoD (70, 36, 111) 1725
14. Piterius (47, 20, 70) 1723
15. Forrest (32, 7, 41) 1720
16. тенью бездомной (30, 8, 38) 1685
17. Javdet (104, 88, 199) 1675
18. Sevensan (65, 44, 109) 1675
19. Герой Меча и Магии 3 (42, 22, 69) 1671
20. Oelm (46, 32, 80) 1669
21. TERI (40, 15, 55) 1655
22. Дубровин Павел (251, 145, 401) 1654
23. Lider1 (72, 42, 117) 1645
24. Wlk777 (287, 231, 521) 1643
25. scorp (38, 34, 72) 1638
26. LeBron (51, 23, 77) 1637
27. Medium_HP (17, 13, 31) 1637
28. Kluka (61, 46, 109) 1630
29. PReDS (24, 15, 39) 1629
30. OUTLAW (141, 75, 220) 1616
31. Keba (23, 14, 37) 1616
32. Loi (163, 112, 292) 1616
33. Vmn2009 (23, 20, 48) 1615
34. Captain (59, 37, 97) 1612
35. Aldegir (35, 17, 55) 1611
36. Mizrael (52, 39, 91) 1608
37. Psyche_7 (40, 37, 77) 1607
38. R55Max (50, 36, 86) 1601
39. Tovariщ (28, 17, 45) 1596
40. SuperGrandMaster (24, 24, 48) 1586
41. ~no1_knows_me~ (51, 36, 89) 1586
42. theShevanesian (35, 33, 69) 1570
43. 13v (31, 33, 65) 1557
44. SpiriTT (86, 60, 153) 1552
45. Hermit (82, 135, 223) 1549
46. RomarioGrom (83, 92, 183) 1547
47. KillerVampire (30, 30, 62) 1546
48. temofey (24, 25, 49) 1546
49. soulist80114522293 (37, 48, 85) 1544
50. Redwhait HP (25, 38, 66) 1542
51. Volland (34, 57, 91) 1540
52. XL (17, 17, 34) 1529
53. Shamys (29, 34, 63) 1525
54. Neverminder (29, 41, 71) 1516
55. StickyFingaz (15, 31, 49) 1516
56. Smoke_mk (36, 41, 77) 1511
57. mals (27, 46, 76) 1500
58. злой_романтик (61, 86, 151) 1498
59. Деконтаминатор (13, 26, 42) 1487
60. vbn (14, 17, 31) 1486
61. Legionerdv (17, 26, 43) 1485
62. Looser (23, 18, 42) 148363. Heavy Case (17, 31, 48) 1478 64. Vasutka (14, 21, 35) 1470 65. Monstro_aka_h3 (12, 22, 34) 1465 66. Slav4eG (14, 20, 35) 1464 67. Pradromalo (23, 53, 76) 1459 68. Mar (15, 29, 44) 1457 69. Deriel_Linch (18, 28, 50) 1447 70. Van (82, 126, 209) 1440 71. Kash (77, 146, 227) 1435 72. Lanser (26, 42, 68) 1417 73. Logisti k (8, 25, 33) 1414 74. Soroka (13, 43, 57) 1398 75. Dima Surmay (19, 45, 64) 1387 76. wariator (20, 70, 90) 1375 77. RiMpel2 (22, 57, 79) 1369 78. Blackpoint (24, 66, 90) 1367 79. Alessandro (16, 43, 59) 1361 80. КостяN (24, 58, 85) 1360 81. P.Alexei (2, 38, 40) 1317 82. Ivanhoj (7, 30, 37) 1315 83. Sevan_80 (16, 82, 98) 1309 84. Avern (16, 61, 78) 1295 The attached text file contains complete information about all players, including the number of games played and their permanent rating for the period from Winter 08-09 to the end of Winter 2011.
It is clear that creating an absolute skill measurement is impossible; you can read discussions on this in the relevant threads:
/topic/3352/
/topic/5625/
/topic/5822/
**The history of the issue on HW in the third game.**
Initially, StickyFingaz proposed a new formula, and it was also suggested not to reset the rating every 3 months but to calculate it over a longer period. Under the new system, Sticky himself manually calculated the results for six months, and Vitaly vbn calculated them simultaneously using two formulas during the spring of 2009, taking into account the results from the previous winter in the permanent rating. In the summer of 2009, the new system was adopted by forum vote, and we fully switched to it.
Based on general considerations, Sticky's system provides a more or less objective result over a large time frame and with a large number of games played by each player. Therefore, the idea arose to calculate how many games were included in the permanent rating calculation over the past nine seasons.
There may be some errors because I used the results posted on the forum by Vitaly, and unfortunately, much of that information has been lost because it was placed on another resource. I have corrected some obvious errors in nicknames. There are also players who change their nicknames, as well as clones that appeared in different seasons under different nicknames.
It turned out that the minimum number of games among the players who made it into the top 15 is 32 wins in 32 games for Alex_R - a permanent rating of 1793, 5th place.
Based on this, players who have played more than 30 games will be included in the permanent rating table. This will also exclude "ghost accounts" and at least some clones that periodically start a new life with 1500 points.
**Permanent rating of HOMM3 players who have played more than 30 counted games during the period from Winter 08-09 to February 28, 2011:**
Rank. Nick (wins, losses, games) permanent rating
1. Pit for LM (56, 9, 67) 1883
2. Gomunguls (162, 53, 223) 1855
3. AliaSmehova (34, 2, 36) 1848
4. bRitvo4kA (165, 46, 212) 1796
5. Alex_R (32, 0, 32) 1793
6. AYMAN (224, 84, 319) 1776
7. SEM_56 (307, 210, 532) 1772
8. Vigo (84, 24, 112) 1764
9. numOne (157, 85, 246) 1755
10. Сатир (40, 17, 58) 1738
11. FireToSky (68, 38, 108) 1733
12. Erdem (56, 34, 93) 1728
13. GoD (70, 36, 111) 1725
14. Piterius (47, 20, 70) 1723
15. Forrest (32, 7, 41) 1720
16. тенью бездомной (30, 8, 38) 1685
17. Javdet (104, 88, 199) 1675
18. Sevensan (65, 44, 109) 1675
19. Герой Меча и Магии 3 (42, 22, 69) 1671
20. Oelm (46, 32, 80) 1669
21. TERI (40, 15, 55) 1655
22. Дубровин Павел (251, 145, 401) 1654
23. Lider1 (72, 42, 117) 1645
24. Wlk777 (287, 231, 521) 1643
25. scorp (38, 34, 72) 1638
26. LeBron (51, 23, 77) 1637
27. Medium_HP (17, 13, 31) 1637
28. Kluka (61, 46, 109) 1630
29. PReDS (24, 15, 39) 1629
30. OUTLAW (141, 75, 220) 1616
31. Keba (23, 14, 37) 1616
32. Loi (163, 112, 292) 1616
33. Vmn2009 (23, 20, 48) 1615
34. Captain (59, 37, 97) 1612
35. Aldegir (35, 17, 55) 1611
36. Mizrael (52, 39, 91) 1608
37. Psyche_7 (40, 37, 77) 1607
38. R55Max (50, 36, 86) 1601
39. Tovariщ (28, 17, 45) 1596
40. SuperGrandMaster (24, 24, 48) 1586
41. ~no1_knows_me~ (51, 36, 89) 1586
42. theShevanesian (35, 33, 69) 1570
43. 13v (31, 33, 65) 1557
44. SpiriTT (86, 60, 153) 1552
45. Hermit (82, 135, 223) 1549
46. RomarioGrom (83, 92, 183) 1547
47. KillerVampire (30, 30, 62) 1546
48. temofey (24, 25, 49) 1546
49. soulist80114522293 (37, 48, 85) 1544
50. Redwhait HP (25, 38, 66) 1542
51. Volland (34, 57, 91) 1540
52. XL (17, 17, 34) 1529
53. Shamys (29, 34, 63) 1525
54. Neverminder (29, 41, 71) 1516
55. StickyFingaz (15, 31, 49) 1516
56. Smoke_mk (36, 41, 77) 1511
57. mals (27, 46, 76) 1500
58. злой_романтик (61, 86, 151) 1498
59. Деконтаминатор (13, 26, 42) 1487
60. vbn (14, 17, 31) 1486
61. Legionerdv (17, 26, 43) 1485
62. Looser (23, 18, 42) 148363. Heavy Case (17, 31, 48) 1478 64. Vasutka (14, 21, 35) 1470 65. Monstro_aka_h3 (12, 22, 34) 1465 66. Slav4eG (14, 20, 35) 1464 67. Pradromalo (23, 53, 76) 1459 68. Mar (15, 29, 44) 1457 69. Deriel_Linch (18, 28, 50) 1447 70. Van (82, 126, 209) 1440 71. Kash (77, 146, 227) 1435 72. Lanser (26, 42, 68) 1417 73. Logisti k (8, 25, 33) 1414 74. Soroka (13, 43, 57) 1398 75. Dima Surmay (19, 45, 64) 1387 76. wariator (20, 70, 90) 1375 77. RiMpel2 (22, 57, 79) 1369 78. Blackpoint (24, 66, 90) 1367 79. Alessandro (16, 43, 59) 1361 80. КостяN (24, 58, 85) 1360 81. P.Alexei (2, 38, 40) 1317 82. Ivanhoj (7, 30, 37) 1315 83. Sevan_80 (16, 82, 98) 1309 84. Avern (16, 61, 78) 1295 The attached text file contains complete information about all players, including the number of games played and their permanent rating for the period from Winter 08-09 to the end of Winter 2011.