Skip to content

Posts from Unconfirmed reports.

No ratings yet — be the first to rate!
Closed
Should unconfirmed, yet also unverifiable, reports be taken into account?
23 voters
Single choice Closed 2009-03-31
This poll is closed.
YES!
43.5% 10 votes
NO!
52.2% 12 votes
WHO CARES!
4.3% 1 vote
In reply to Oelm
User Avatar
17 years ago
Auto-translated
Oelm

It's great, I'll lose a couple of games, close my eyes, and everything will be fine. After all, only when I don't confirm a few games will people stop playing with me!
And that will be fair. If you intentionally don't confirm your losses.
User Avatar
17 years ago
Auto-translated
Yes, it’s frustrating when you put in effort, struggle, and win a match, only for your opponent to disappear or make false promises to confirm the result. However, such occurrences are common in the world of Heroes, and there’s no need to make a big deal out of it. This shouldn’t be a reason to refuse to play with newcomers; each of us was once a beginner, and people played with us. Before the game, you can immediately agree on a report; many newcomers have no idea about this system for recording games and don’t pay any attention to it. Even during the negotiation stage, it becomes clear who we are dealing with – a responsible player who intends to become a member of the community, or someone who just happened to visit the forum. And, as I said, all experienced players have gone through games with players who don’t confirm the results; this is a common occurrence.
In reply to Oelm
User Avatar
17 years ago
Auto-translated
Oelm
Xaker -1.

How great, I'll play a couple of losing games, close my eyes, and everything will be fine. After all, only when I don't confirm a few games will people stop playing with me!
Exactly. Even just one is enough ;)
In reply to invisible
User Avatar
17 years ago
Auto-translated
I also don't understand what "a few games" means. Why is ONE game, which remains unconfirmed for a month, two months, or three months, not being addressed, even though the player continues to play without any consequences or sanctions against them??? Let's also allow cheating a couple of times:D - and only punish them on the fourth or fifth offense:rolleyes:. I don't understand how the parliament hasn't passed laws on legal theft and a limit on murders yet: let's say you can steal three times a year and kill once:D :D :D ...
In reply to КостяN
User Avatar
17 years ago
Auto-translated
KoStyaN
I don't understand either, what does "a few games" mean?
Please, let's not exaggerate. It all depends on the reasons for the report not being confirmed. Each case is different and usually requires an individual approach. Therefore, you only need to report the unconfirmed report, and then the reasons will be investigated.
In reply to Vlad
User Avatar
17 years ago
Auto-translated
Xaker

Please, let's not exaggerate.

Everything depends on the reasons for the report not being confirmed.

Each case is different and usually requires an individual approach.

Therefore, you only need to report the unconfirmed report, and then the reasons will be investigated.

So, what happened? Did you find out the reasons for the most significant unconfirmed report this winter (I mean the game between Valentin Wlc777 and Viktor Vigo)? :) And I'm not even mentioning the other 20+ unconfirmed reports...
User Avatar
17 years ago
Auto-translated
I fully support Drem completely!!!

I just want to suggest an addition, if you'll allow me...

I propose introducing a panel of judges, to whom the last save of the game day is sent along with the "non-confirming" player — they will decide what the situation is at that game moment and personally inform the Tournament Host that yes, the game took place, they saw the save, the "person who filed the report" is the winner in this situation. (Or something similar)
The judges should be competent players (who know what they're talking about) and who have both in-game and moral authority among beginner, developing players, and just residents of HeroesWorld.
In reply to Vigo
User Avatar
17 years ago
Auto-translated
Vigo
I fully support Drim!!!

I just want to suggest an addition, if I may...

I propose introducing a panel of judges, to whom the last save of the game day is sent from the "non-confirming" player — they decide what the situation is at that game moment and personally inform the Tournament Host that yes, the game took place, saves have been seen, and the "person who filed the report" in this situation is the winner. (Or something like that)
Only judges must be skilled players (who know what they're talking about) and who have game-related and moral authority among beginner, developing players, and just HeroesWorld residents.
Right, smart thoughts, respect. But what about a situation when a seemingly well-respected player (Vigo), clearly losing in the game, uses the slightest excuse in the form of a game crash on his own turn (well, my game crashed, but not on my turn, so at least you can't suspect that I quit somewhere and decided to cheat) to end the match, writes to me in ICQ something like "okay, you can file a report", and then when all saves have already been deleted, it turns out he had no intention of confirming anything, but the report has already been filed and there's no reason to delete it. This casts a shadow on the honesty of the player (me), which is doubly insulting after already forgiving this person for one lost match. So before discussing a panel of judges, some people simply need to learn how to behave like human beings, and then these judges might not even be needed. If he had told me in ICQ right away that he wouldn't confirm, I probably wouldn't have bothered with the report at all and would have forgotten about it soon, but this turned out, to put it mildly, unsightly. That match is already forgotten, the season is over, but I still haven't understood the reason for Mr. Vigo's behavior. Maybe he can explain something to me now? :smile27:
User Avatar
16 years ago
Auto-translated
I don't understand what kind of reports you're talking about?????????=((((((((

Statistics

Welcome our newest member: recijeb

Users Online 3 users 1310 guests