HOMM3 Ratings and Stats — Online Tournaments

KobRa_RR

10 years ago

Auto-translated

Dirty_Player

There are some negative aspects. Incorrect reports will be counted, like when the wrong opponent is indicated, and they didn't even know. Or one person writes a report for the winner, and another for the loser. It's better if everyone confirms it; it's not that difficult. IMHO.

I think a stricter approach is needed here.

Dark30

10 years ago

Auto-translated

Perhaps it's not a popular method, but you can send a message to the debtor on the forum. If there's no confirmation of the report within a week, the game is canceled. Players simply won't want to play with such individuals again. After all, the report is something conditional, a reason for playing, in addition to the enjoyment you get from the game.

In reply to Dirty_Player

злой_романтик

10 years ago

Auto-translated

Dirty_Player

There are some negative aspects. Incorrect reports will be counted, like when the wrong opponent is indicated, and they didn't even know. Or one person writes a report for the winner, and another for the loser. It's better if everyone confirms it; it's not that difficult. IMHO.

IMHO, but it's better to agree before the game who will write the report – the winner or the loser. As for incorrect reports and indicating the wrong opponent, if it works once, it's fine, but the second time, they could get a warning for falsification, right?

In reply to Dirty_Player

Wicc

10 years ago

Auto-translated

Dirty_Player

There are some negative aspects. Incorrect reports will be counted, such as indicating the wrong opponent, and they didn't even know. Or one person wrote a report for the winner, and the other for the loser.

Incorrect reports... blessed soul :D

The main abuse is to generate reports against "dead accounts" and, in a month, grab 1st place in the ranking for free.

In reply to Dirty_Player

Nitro

10 years ago

Auto-translated

Dirty_Player

There are some negative aspects. Incorrect reports will be counted, such as when the wrong opponent is indicated, and they didn't even know. Or one person wrote a report as the winner, and the other as the loser. It's better if everyone confirms them; it's not that difficult. IMHO.

This happens rarely, but there are dozens of unconfirmed reports older than six months.

Wicc

Incorrect reports... blessed person :D

The main abuse is generating reports against "dead accounts" and, after a month, getting 1st place in the ranking for free.

This will be immediately visible.
In general, for now, in test mode, unconfirmed reports older than 30 days are being counted.
But they are still displayed in the list of unconfirmed reports. So, check this list for incorrect or "abusive" reports :D

Added 3 hours 28 minutes ago
Removed those absent for more than 500 days from the permanent ranking.

Added 1 hour 4 minutes ago
Added the ranking position in parentheses.
I invite those who want to help with the banner graphics to collaborate (the current one needs to be reworked a bit + I want to make a new banner (bigger)).

=Lizard=

10 years ago

Auto-translated

I suggest moving this thread to the top – to the main section, replacing the outdated thread by Pita.

My only suggestion: add a column for achievements and medals to the right of the rating (as it was, by the way, in WOT).

cost

10 years ago

Auto-translated

I agree about "pinning" the topic.

Marcus Aurelius

10 years ago

Auto-translated

Are there any plans to integrate with the HD-mod (or HW-rules)? Personally, I dream of being able to write reports, view player ratings, and access information about current tournaments directly within the game. (And if there's a chat feature too, I'd be ecstatic.)

In reply to Nitro

Nitro

10 years ago

Auto-translated

Nitro

Basically, for now, in test mode, unconfirmed reports older than 30 days are being counted.

Unconfirmed reports are not being counted again. There have been complaints about abuse.

=Lizard=

10 years ago

Auto-translated

I think that in tournaments (besides the seasonal ones), unconfirmed matches should also be counted, as there is evidence in the form of a player advancing to the next round, etc.

Antiplayer

10 years ago

Auto-translated

Some games that were previously included are no longer considered in the ranking. Why is that?

In reply to Antiplayer

KobRa_RR

10 years ago

Auto-translated

Antiplayer

Some games that used to be counted in the ranking are no longer being considered. Why is that?

Some tournaments that were moved have been removed. Nitro is aware of the issue.

In reply to Antiplayer

Nitro

10 years ago

Auto-translated

Antiplayer

Some games that used to be counted in the ranking are no longer being considered. Why is that?

We've looked into it. One of the moderators moved a topic from the previous season to a different location.

In reply to Nitro

KobRa_RR

10 years ago

Auto-translated

currently, the table at http://heroes3stat.tk/rating/ shows the following milestones:
Gomungulza has played 700 games, Sevensan has played 500, and I have played 300 )))