Appeals Committee. Disputed situations in tournaments. — Tournament Committee

=Stinger=

10 years ago

Auto-translated

It’s my fault; I just expressed my opinion poorly. Dirty has nothing to do with it.

In reply to =Stinger=

злой_романтик

10 years ago

Auto-translated

The_

What are you talking about, well, well.
Maybe Dirty will come to his senses and correct the post before the trust in the AK falls below the plinth.

Timur, do you have any reason to doubt that the decision was made unanimously?

=Stinger=

It's my fault, I just poorly expressed my opinion, Dirty has nothing to do with it.

Hmm, I didn't see 2 meanings in your phrase either.

296524052
Весна 2012.

Dirty_Player

10 years ago

Auto-translated

zloy_romantik

The decision was indeed unanimous. Some members of the AC changed their initial opinion during the discussion.

Actually, when counting the votes, I counted Stinger's ambiguous post as "Yes," but it actually meant "No." In reality, the vote was 6:1 in favor of this decision.

In reply to Dirty_Player

злой_романтик

10 years ago

Auto-translated

Dirty_Player

Actually, when counting the votes, I counted Stinger's ambiguous post as "Yes," but it actually meant "No." In reality, the result was 6:1 in favor of this decision.

I would never have said that this phrase means "No" (especially its first part), but Artem knows best what he meant to say with it.

296524052
Весна 2012.

The_

10 years ago

Auto-translated

Sold-out performance on the Volga River (color).

241-568-808

In reply to The_

Dirty_Player

10 years ago

Auto-translated

The_

A full house on the Volga (color).

I'm almost certain that if the decision had been the opposite, "Anshlag" would have caused a Hellgate. That's just the way it is in AK: no matter the outcome, you'll be blamed.

=Stinger=

10 years ago

Auto-translated

Let him reach that cell, although my opinion hasn't changed, and I still think he's mostly to blame.

Here's what I wrote.
Considering that 6 members have already voted FOR, I wrote "Let him reach that cell," because my opinion no longer mattered.
But since this was already the second vote, and in the first one, I clearly expressed my OPPOSITION, I added that my opinion hadn't changed, meaning I remained AGAINST it.
I agree that it came out awkwardly and ambiguously. I was just in a hurry to write it, because, as it turned out, they were only waiting for me.

HellLighT

10 years ago

Auto-translated

It seems to me, or is it not AK that is putting on this clown show? Because nitpicking about the number of votes after a decision has been made is just empty sophistry, and Mr. Toganash is generally above all praise; he writes about not taking his words out of context, and then immediately takes the phrase:

p.p.s. I'm not asking to repeat anything, all I'm asking is to load the autosave (which is where we left off) and press the horse button (M)

And the copied phrase

"I'm not asking for anything, but I am"

Perhaps in Cheboksary, it is customary to operate in this way in texts that are not written with much thought, but please, don't amuse the people anymore.

In reply to HellLighT

Toganash

10 years ago

Auto-translated

"clownery", "empty trickery", "Mr. Toganash", "they write without thinking much", "don't make people laugh anymore" - how many epithets from a person who tries to accuse another of "trickery". Only a flawed personality can allow a statement hinting at racial, geographical, or other affiliation. Even as a joke or irony, such things are unacceptable.

ICQ: 564224919

HellLighT

10 years ago

Auto-translated

And for me, it is unacceptable that you entered a topic where you weren't expected and, acting as a victorious judge, started accusing me of all sorts of wrongdoings. Everyone has their own limits of what is acceptable, and in my opinion, you exceeded them. The first thing that came to mind was the location and the established norms there; I didn't make any hints, I stated it directly.

In reply to HellLighT

Toganash

10 years ago

Auto-translated

HellLighT

For me, it's unacceptable that you entered a thread where you weren't expected and, acting as a victorious judge, started accusing me of all sorts of wrongdoings. Everyone has their own limits, and in my opinion, you crossed them. The first thing that came to mind was the location and the established norms there; I didn't make any hints, I stated it directly.

I am one of the organizers and judges of the tournament, and the fact that you bypassed the regulations and appealed to the Arbitration Committee (AK) does not deprive me of the right to express my opinion. If this is not the case, let the AK correct me, but not you.

ICQ: 564224919

HellLighT

10 years ago

Auto-translated

Skd already provided you with a link to the rules for organizing tournaments, according to which this tournament is also held, but it seems you are really reading between the lines.