Posts from Appeals Committee. Disputed situations in tournaments.

I remember, you once, during a live broadcast of your own tournament's draw, told the respected Dark to go to hell, and he forgave you then. Here, it's a similar story, you need to control yourself, this won't lead to anything good, sooner or later you'll be held accountable for your words, you'll remember what I said.
As for the game, this idiot was shouting all over Facebook that there was no chance, he even calculated on some turn that the opponent's next move would be almost his last, and in the end, he completely messed up, and then all you could hear was swearing and "BUG, BUG," and he ran to AK to complain.
For such a situation, the score should be 2-2, or even 3-2, those who watched Kobryno's video will understand.

SZOT. The, your opinions have nothing to do with the reality around you.
And on the topic: if you think this is unfair, that this is a bug, then you've got the wrong topic: write to the HoMM developers. No one from AK is among them, I think)))) And what you did is called whining. I saw it in the broadcast and I'm telling you about it right now.

Timur, due to the very fact of such a large amount of text in this topic, your brilliant victories in the mirror tournament fade on their own. And it doesn't matter at all who is right and who is wrong. If you had silently won the next match against Hell, most people would have said afterwards that it was actually 3-0, not 3-1. That would have been cool and manly. But as it is... it's not cool, and it's not brilliant. And in the end, these disputes will be remembered much more than the games and victories. No offense.

If such an episode happened in "Heroes of Might and Magic," I would recommend loading the autosave from turn 123 and continuing from there.

But since the players mutually agreed to change the rules of the game, they are responsible for the consequences.

P.S. Reaching turn 123 in Heroes of Might and Magic is quite a feat.

P.P.S. From a technical implementation perspective, I think it would be better to show the blue player the red player's turn after synchronization and offer to stop the "Heroes of Might and Magic" with a replay of the last turn.

This is a rollback of exactly 1 turn – blue moves 123, and red moves 124. The reason is to maintain the game's logic. For a tournament that is positioned as a test of Online Heroes, this solution is, in my opinion, the most correct.

In those distant times, when they didn't yet know how to cure split turns, it sometimes took 2-3 turns to complete a move.

P.P.S. Regarding the technical implementation - I think that after synchronization, the blue player should be shown the red player's move and offered to stop the OH with a replay of the last day.

A simple option for mirror match templates: make the Overkill Halt (OH) trigger after one of the players breaks through to the opponent's plane.

A simple solution for mirror match templates: make the Overlord Hour (OH) end after one of the players breaks through to the opponent's plane.

Regarding the topic: I believe that the current Overlord Hour logic required a replay of the blue player's last turn, but Zee should have demanded this immediately (from the stream, it seems that he immediately understood what happened and could have not waited for the results of all the battles). But after the red player had already retreated and won 3 battles against the blue player, the opportunity was lost. You formally agreed with what was happening as soon as you started moving in the first combat encounter.