Posts from Mafia 101. Disputed Island Auto-translated

Is it really that straightforward?

Well, there might also be a non-damage ability, like (U) ("kill someone"). At least, that's what I initially thought. For the first one, it seems more about belonging to a city, and for the third, I only thought of a non-damage ability of type (-).

Well, there’s not much information. No new clues. I think we should execute Alex or Hekasan.

The moderator doesn't seem to have made any mistakes.
If the second question is about Necropolis (or Necromancer), then the third question is even less clear.

Is it really that straightforward?

Oh, Dag, I'm not sure. Judging by my calculations, this combination (urban, mental health, ND type -) conveys a fairly good amount of information, even in a general sense. I can say that I'm open to alternative options and will try to come up with something else myself.
For now, I see an alternative as a series: city + ND type U + location, but the latter seems somewhat doubtful.
Or maybe it's a question about a character, but I don't think such questions should be asked at all. The question itself might provide a lot of information, but any such question almost guarantees that no one will be able to decipher it.

Either it's some kind of question about a character, but I think such questions shouldn't be asked at all.

Maybe something like, "Does the character annoy those around them?"

He annoys everyone except Granny Nyura.

He is constantly criticized by other members of the group.

He constantly grumbles about everything, which greatly irritates those around him.

But I agree that this is very vague, and such questions shouldn't be asked, while the previous surveys from Granny seemed to be very well-composed and logical.

Based on the survey, I like the Mentha option with the question about mental status. But since Doug denies it, then...

Here's another survey option:
Are you negative? No
Do you have a melee weapon? Yes
Do you have a negative trait like (-)? Yes

Lie on the first question: Jen Li, Hunter
Lie on the second question: Ricchi
Lie on the third question: Hoffman

Even without the mental status, Doug strongly resembles a negative character.

Yeah, there isn't much information.
It seems Nancy has been recruited?
Poll.
Okay, let's assume the first question is "Are you from the city?" - Yes
Then, about the ND, something like "U?" - the answer is Yes.
So, either the first or the second answer is a lie. Out of the mountain archers, only the old woman remains.
In this case, Dag, as always, answered in the most absurd way.
The third question - we need to think about it.

The Fragment also has a very interesting option.
Or maybe the second question is about psychic status, and the third is about melee weapons? Although the mention of "I'll cut him down" is specifically in the second...

Yes, I also thought that Nancy was recruited.

I think either Sezam and Snowman, or Doug and Alex are the mafia. By the way, I had a guess about Sezam, and yesterday, based on her posts, I would have thought she was mafia.
Execute Sezam, for now.
If anything, I can switch to any of the above.

Added 2 minutes later
More precisely, in the second option, Alex is mafia, and Doug is a town member.

As a twisted option – "You won't last long" – this is a question about a character, falling into the category of "Can you recruit them?" or "Can you kill them on the first try?". It's quite absurd. The old woman hasn't been recruited yet, so why would she need to know if the candidates have such an ability? Although, on the other hand, both bosses and the main characters cannot be recruited. And both bosses and two town characters have protection against being killed.

I suggest that everyone share their opinion again. I still trust my intuition more than anything else. And in the case of Vish and in the case of Shaman, my intuition didn't let me down.

And besides Ment, does no one think that the fact of successful treatment is evident at the end?

Actually, I haven't liked Sesam from the very beginning, and on the second day, I specifically checked to see if any clues were connected to her.

Fragment, what do you think about Alex's poem?

Fragment, what do you think about Alex’s behavior?

What do you think? Who among those I mentioned would you execute today?
Of course, not myself, although if you’re the Mafia, everyone would only thank you :)

Added 1 minute ago
Taking this opportunity, thank you, Shaman, for such a great New Year's gift!

Hmm... you know, Fragment, answering a question with a question is kind of...