Rehabilitation of cheaters. — Tournament Committee

No ratings yet — be the first to rate!

Multiple choice Public votes Closed 2012-04-26

This poll is closed.

Yes, I wouldn’t mind playing with Katherine

25.3% 21 votes

Yes, but I won’t play with Katherine

20.5% 17 votes

No, ignore reports

14.5% 12 votes

We need to develop a system for rehabilitating cheaters

19.3% 16 votes

Cheaters should be banned

27.7% 23 votes

I don’t really care, but I like taking part in polls

16.9% 14 votes

In reply to numOne

Pit for LM

5/23/2014 7:36 AM UTC

Auto-translated

numOne

I have nothing against a physical unban on the forum; in principle, this is a matter for the Creator, who can theoretically do it manually.
We are talking about an unban from official Tournaments. This character has no interest in being unbanned, and it is unlikely that he will develop any, given his personality.

Let's analyze this. There are two areas of work on the forum: administrative and tournament-related.

The player is banned on the forum (his nickname is in black). This is an administrative penalty. Why was he banned? He has 160 penalty points. If you know the forum rules, you can understand that he has been banned repeatedly. Points were mainly given for rude insults towards users. No, you cannot insult or swear on the forum.
In addition, this user registered several clones on the forum, which should have been penalized with 50 points each, but we no longer give points for this.

He was added to the Blacklist for cheating. This is a completely different story. This penalty was imposed by the AC (Anti-Cheat) and prevents him from participating in Tournaments.

There is no basis to "unban" him, as you put it, in either of these areas. Moreover, we already have a sad experience with similar measures.

Подарок от Gomunguls на ДР :)

Осень-Зима 2013-14.

In reply to Pit for LM

Dark

6/6/2015 8:05 AM UTC

Auto-translated

I wonder if Indra will ever have his ban lifted. He's a great player, and I don't see the point of a lifetime ban.

лето 2012.

In reply to Dark

=Lizard=

6/6/2015 8:09 AM UTC

Auto-translated

Dark

I wonder if Indra will ever have his ban lifted? He's a great player, and I don't see the point of a lifetime ban?!

+1

As a person, he may not be liked by many, as his communication style is quite similar to that of another player from St. Petersburg. But this has no direct relation to the game. Personally, I believe that the tournaments lost some of their overall quality when ATG left the resource. The same goes for Indra. To a slightly lesser extent, but he was still a brilliant player.

http://ru.twitch.tv/lizard_wt

Juristis

6/6/2015 8:36 AM UTC

Auto-translated

As I understand it, Pavel doesn't just have a ban from tournaments, but a ban from the entire site, and it wasn't even issued by our moderators. Therefore, first, he needs to be unbanned on Heroes of Might and Magic Online, and it's not certain that Dirty can do that. If he can, then of course, we would like to see Indra on the resource.

heroes3.tv/juristis
ICQ - 488-784-621, skype - juristis18

Весна 2014.

In reply to Juristis

Dirty_Player

6/6/2015 12:07 PM UTC

Auto-translated

I can unban Indra on the website, no problem. We can also raise the question of his rehabilitation. But is it necessary? During his farewell, he said a lot of offensive things, the essence of which was that he "has seen this HW before." The main question is, does he even want this?

In the near future, the issue of reorganizing the AK will be raised: a complete change of personnel, etc. This may be the first matter to be considered.

In reply to Dirty_Player

KobRa_RR

6/6/2015 1:47 PM UTC

Auto-translated

Dirty_Player

I can unban Indra on the site, no problem. We can also raise the question of his rehabilitation. But does he even need it? During his farewell, he said a lot of offensive things, the gist of which was that he "has seen enough of HW." The main question is, does he even want this himself?

In the near future, the issue of reorganizing the AC will be raised: a complete change of the team, etc. This may be the first matter to be considered.

LOL, +1, you should first ask Pavel if he needs this.

In reply to KobRa_RR

Nick_Maniac

6/6/2015 4:40 PM UTC

Auto-translated

KobRa_RR

LOL, +1, you should first ask Pavel if he even needs this.

Ahah, so now the policy is that moderators have to beg:smile41: to unban a cheater or rule-breaker, profusely apologizing, because without him, there's no point, and there's no one to play with.

Недоигранные партии:
Mikem от 01.06.15 В общем он спецом не доигрывает проигранные игры!

In reply to Nick_Maniac

Sanin

6/6/2015 4:50 PM UTC

Auto-translated

Nick_Maniac

Haha, so now the policy is that moderators have to beg:smile41: to unban a cheater or rule-breaker, profusely apologizing, because without him, there's no point, and there's no one to play with.

Not the moderators, but those who advocate for the unban.

ICQ 423164784

In reply to KobRa_RR

bubuch

11/21/2015 2:50 PM UTC

Auto-translated

KobRa_RR

LOL, +1, you should first ask Pavel if he needs this.

I asked, and some others are interested too, so ask yourselves.

Grando

1/22/2017 11:56 PM UTC

Auto-translated

Here's another person who's interested in learning about Indra. That's me. I couldn't find a more suitable topic to ask my question.

Indra is on the blacklist for maphacking. Is there anywhere I can read about how this happened? Ideally, it would be great if there were also save files of the game/games that led to the decision to ban him for maphacking.

I asked Indra himself, but he's being rather evasive. Either this topic annoys him (and he doesn't trust anyone), or he really is a cheater. I want to understand for myself.

https://www.twitch.tv/grando__

In reply to Grando

Noom

1/23/2017 2:48 AM UTC

Auto-translated

Al Feyn

Here's another person who is interested in learning about Indra. It's me. I couldn't find a more suitable topic to ask my question.

Indra is on the blacklist for maphacking. Is there anywhere I can read about how this happened? Ideally, if there was also a pack of saves from the game(s) that were used to make the decision about the maphack.

I asked Indra himself, but he gives vague answers. Either he's annoyed by this topic (and doesn't trust anyone), or he really is cheating. I want to understand it myself.

You can read the history of questions and discussions here:
/topic/6122/

Стримы HMM5 на полных картах мод TE:
ru.twitch.tv/noom11

Alex_nv - draw - Vovan112013 летос 236

alex_nv wrote: Наконец то нормальная игра с открытием половины карты.

Grando

1/23/2017 9:50 AM UTC

Auto-translated

Excellent. "Another person" calmed down. I am completely on the side of AK. And then Indru asked in the Twitch chat what exactly happened there? So, instead of direct answers, he spent half an hour struggling through jumping from topic to topic and substituting concepts. Now the "moral image" of this (for me, undoubtedly top-tier) player and (undoubtedly very intellectually strong) person is clear. As, indeed, is the case with everyone who inserted something in his defense. :D The community is what it is. Facepalm. Added 1 minute later. While I'm at it, I'll ask another question. Have there already been any initial ideas somewhere that they have learned how to crack password-protected saves?

https://www.twitch.tv/grando__

bubuch

1/23/2017 6:13 PM UTC

Auto-translated

but...
Re: [TOURNAMENT] One for all and all for one 5
Quote:
Message from silenthill
After looking at the save with 100%, it seems that he won. He has a large army, but at the end of the battle, after 2 rounds of Dismal Rays, Angels, and Ducks, everything looks bleak. God is your judge. It's a pity I didn't record the game or stream it. Regarding the 2nd game, where I surrendered on turn 111, there was a promise from my side to lose the match, for balance in the tournament. In essence, it wasn't really played. And demanding money from a tournament game is complete nonsense. I didn't want to play at all.
Where did you get the passwords to view the save? a) That's the first question...

Added after 45 seconds
while there is no answer, it is possible that silenthill misspoke.