Posts from Mafia: general discussions. Auto-translated

No, I'm talking about a game with heart and soul. When we completely blocked half the city in 3 turns and ran out of mana, and still won decisively.

It's all simple. Sesama outlined the plans in the last game. And in the case of a hanging world and mafia, the plans differed.

Well, it's all quite simple; these plans arose from the complete exposure of the roles and players in the newspapers, plus the "peaceful" semaphore signals and roles.

Well, almost all our Mage Guilds write newspapers like that; Revnya just has a more ornate description of ND and the roles of corpses, but the principle of writing the newspaper is no different. You could experiment with newspapers where absolutely nothing is clear to anyone, but it's unlikely that idea would be in demand.
I'm not against experiments, but I don't like things that are too desperate, and I frankly like a number of features of our mafia more than the proposed alternatives.
After all, we aren't rushing over to your MF to impose democracy friendship-magic our rules.

I don't want to be rude, but please don't speak for the ENTIRE forum. Please write to ME; these rules don't suit ME, and I am used to different rules.

in the end, no one is forcing you to play those maps that you don't want to play.

Instead of trying to force a peaceful outcome against the Mafia, I did it only because there was no other option.

No, my dear.:p The existing rules (and the "silence" at night in particular) were created to suit the current balance. If something is to be done with this "silence" that you dislike so much, then something must definitely be done with the balance as well. I would really not want the balance to be adjusted in the direction of blindness in the game. Making the game more complex is fine, but not by making it a blind game. Because I love blind games just as much as you love silent nights.;)
No problem. I'm just worried that all the GMs will start creating blind games, and I'll be left with nothing.:(

The current question is: who will host the next game and when?

I'm sure if the Warlock hadn't skipped a turn, things would have been different. ;) And Alex's bluffs in the newspaper were a bit much. This is probably the only thing they shouldn't have done... However, the set was lying around for quite a while, and we didn't pay attention - no one is to blame.

I will not be analyzing blind games! I enjoy vividly describing who had what role. Especially if a bloody mess involving half the players happens at night, yum.

All GMs will only start creating such games if everyone likes it, but even if that happens, it's not a given that you yourself will like it that much.

the unhanged GM (with his -1 vote)