One for all and all for one - 3 — Tournament History online

R55Max

11 years ago

Auto-translated

Dima Surmay

Actually, he's a captain.

Oh yes, yes, yes))) I didn't watch the voting; I was answering the question.

The 2nd and 3rd tiers will be announced.

МУДРЫЙ - не обязательно старый, ОПЫТНЫЙ - не обязательно мудрый... обладатель и того и другого всегда должен помнить слова НАПОЛЕОНА БОНАПАРТА: Война состоит из непредусмотренных событий; В каждом большом деле всегда приходится какую-то часть оставить на долю :smile33: СЛУЧАЯ...

In reply to R55Max

Dirty_Player

11 years ago

Auto-translated

R55Max

The community has chosen, so we have to make it work :D

I mentioned this after the second tournament. If a player who, according to their rating, should be in the 3rd tier is suddenly chosen as captain, the team ends up with a 3+2+3 tier composition. It's clear that such a team won't be able to compete effectively. Therefore, I suggest adding a small amendment: in teams where the captain has a lower rating than the other team members, the player placement should be based on rating. Perhaps the captain will receive a strong player from the second tier who can compete with the players from the first tier. Or the captain themselves can compete with the players from the second tier.

In reply to Dirty_Player

StickyFingaz

11 years ago

Auto-translated

I agree with the previous speaker.

In reply to StickyFingaz

R55Max

11 years ago

Auto-translated

No changes will be made. Any player chosen as a captain will play with the captains; I hope this is clear without further explanation. Secondly, if a weak player from the 2nd tier ends up on a team (because stronger captains will pick the strong players), then in the 3rd round, he will be able to choose a strong player because the selection will go in reverse order.

The voting will follow this analogy:

Round 1:

Captains, in the order shown in the table, choose players from the 2nd tier. The last of the 20 captains will get the remaining player from the 2nd tier.

Round 2:

Captains, in reverse order (starting with captain No. 20) choose players from the 3rd tier. The last player from the 3rd tier goes to captain No. 1 in the table.

Tiers 2 and 3 are arranged by rating from top to bottom (higher rating at the top).

Reserve: wowa - Tier 1
Fill-ua - does not participate in the draw because he did not confirm his participation in the tournament. If he wants to, we'll take him as a reserve.

Attachments 1

1 file attached • Total size: 8.6 KB

МУДРЫЙ - не обязательно старый, ОПЫТНЫЙ - не обязательно мудрый... обладатель и того и другого всегда должен помнить слова НАПОЛЕОНА БОНАПАРТА: Война состоит из непредусмотренных событий; В каждом большом деле всегда приходится какую-то часть оставить на долю :smile33: СЛУЧАЯ...

In reply to R55Max

The_

11 years ago

Auto-translated

Maybe it's not too late to move marajan to the second tier? Although, in my opinion, his skill level definitely deserves the first tier. And the last tournament, where Marat either didn't lose a single match or lost very few, and that was probably out of boredom, isn't really representative, is it?
And in this case, wouldn't it be better to use an interpretation of the rules that takes into account not the rating, but an individual approach?

241-568-808

In reply to R55Max

злой_романтик

11 years ago

Auto-translated

So, Bishop, who is already strong, has the right to get the strongest player from the 2nd tier? It seems a bit unfair, in my opinion, although, of course, the host has the final say.

296524052
Весна 2012.

In reply to The_

Redwhait

11 years ago

Auto-translated

The_

Maybe it's not too late to move marajan to the second tier? Although, in my opinion, his skill level definitely deserves the first tier. And the last tournament, where Marat either didn't lose a single match or lost very few, and that was probably out of boredom, isn't really representative, is it?
And in this case, wouldn't it be better to use an interpretation of the rules that takes into account not the rating, but an individual approach?

Then many could be moved.
In general, I think it would be better to let them choose from the second tier from the bottom, and the third from the top.

In reply to злой_романтик

Dima Surmay

11 years ago

Auto-translated

evil_romantic

So, Bishop, who is already strong, is entitled to get the strongest player from the 2nd tier? It seems a bit unfair, in my opinion, although, of course, the host can do as he pleases.

and the weakest from the 3rd tier, so everything is fine.

In reply to Dima Surmay

злой_романтик

11 years ago

Auto-translated

Dima Surmay

and the weakest of the 3, so it's all good

Having the first pick from 2 and the last pick from 3 – these are, in my opinion, completely different things.

296524052
Весна 2012.

In reply to R55Max

cuc9ctblu

11 years ago

Auto-translated

Please register me for the tournament
if it's still possible, veto 6lm10a.

In reply to злой_романтик

Roger-ua

11 years ago

Auto-translated

zloy_romantik

Consequently, Bishop, who is already strong, has the right to get the strongest player from the 2nd tier? It seems a bit unfair to me, although, of course, the owner is the boss.

The imbalances in the 3rd tier are worse because the draw is correct. In my opinion, the rating for choosing captains is fairer and has fewer flaws (I would remove Iamsamstan from the 2nd tier) than the regular rating (there are many flaws here, at least Zloy, who is in the 3rd tier, could have been a captain!!!).

Весна 2013.

In reply to Roger-ua

Dirty_Player

11 years ago

Auto-translated

Why did the discussions start now? And when I brought up the topic, everyone was silent? :confused:

In reply to cuc9ctblu

R55Max

11 years ago

Auto-translated

cuc9ctblu

Please register me for the tournament if there are still spots available, veto 6lm10a.

If only as a reserve, would you agree?

Guys, stop coming up with all sorts of hypotheses. Let's read the regulations, form teams, and play. Voting and determining the tiers based on the rating is the fundamental part of forming the teams for this tournament!
Is this still not clear to anyone?

P.S. The top-ranked captain will choose from which tier, and this should also be based on the voting. However, the rules already state: 5. Based on the order of the list, the captains will choose one player from the 2nd tier to join their team. When choosing from the 3rd tier, the order of selection changes to the opposite..

МУДРЫЙ - не обязательно старый, ОПЫТНЫЙ - не обязательно мудрый... обладатель и того и другого всегда должен помнить слова НАПОЛЕОНА БОНАПАРТА: Война состоит из непредусмотренных событий; В каждом большом деле всегда приходится какую-то часть оставить на долю :smile33: СЛУЧАЯ...