Posts from Мафия 86. Vallée des Roses

Well, judging by the newspaper and the fact that we don't have any other candidates, we should execute Ment.
There's also a possibility that Feral is the Countess, and he's just trying to deflect suspicion with this "investigation." But in that case, we would have someone else here loudly proclaiming that Feral is a scoundrel, a liar, and a villain.

It seems like Alexiglus and Heroist didn't like something.
Well, who knows. There's a theory that the real guardian doesn't want to reveal himself, so he's staying silent, but is there any point in doing that?
No, a wait-and-see tactic also exists, but I don't think that's the case here.
Although... Remembering some games, I can assume that Alexiglus would do exactly that. But that's just a thought.
For now, the obvious option is Ment-Countess. Let's see what happens with the disrupted execution.

And there will be a disruption either way. If Ment is indeed the Countess, then the Mafia has no choice. If the Countess (or another Mafia member, but that's unlikely) is Feral, and Ment is executed, and his role becomes clear, then an assassin will come for Feral at night. In both cases, the Countess, whether it's Ment or Feral, will live for the same amount of time. If Ment is a decoy, then if the execution is disrupted, Feral will gain an extra day of life.

In general, if Feral is the Mafia, that's a pretty good move. Because in that case, we'll spend two days lynching Ment and one day executing him, while in three days the Mafia can cause a lot of trouble.

Execute Feral.

Morni, is there something we don't know?

I think you know more than you let on.

The funny thing is that if we execute Feral, and he turns out to be a Guardian, then the Cop will live for another 2 nights and 2 days, which is basically the same amount of time that Feral would live if he were a Countess who is framing the Cop. Well, Ney has already explained this.
But personally, I won't change my vote. The Cop is stirring up trouble all day, Feral is a newbie, and I don't believe that in his first game on the portal, he would risk so much and so openly reveal himself as a Town role, being Mafia.

Feral is a newbie; I don't believe that in his first game on the portal, he would risk so much and openly reveal himself as a town role, especially while being Mafia.

Maybe he's not a newbie at all and is acting according to his cunning plan. In that case, Morny figured him out.

Execute Feral.

Is the day still ongoing? Well, I want to say that Tox's logic about a newbie not making any impressive moves on their first day isn't very sound. Firstly, because we essentially know nothing about how Feral plays. Secondly, because we don't know who's on the Mafia team, and any strong player could easily pull something like that off. Moreover, it would be the only reasonable move in that situation, although it should be noted that in that case, the town role needs to pretend to be specifically the burned Countess, and not just anyone, then the outcome would be the best. That's the situation.

Is searching for a clue the same as stirring up trouble? Oh yes, we have an anonymous murder with two hints about the culprit.

Well, let’s execute you, Menti, and find out if you’re a good player or not.

Morni, do you seriously think that teeth-grinding is a clue or a hint about a role?

Morni, do you really think that teeth grinding is a clue or a hint about a role?...

Why teeth grinding? If there is a clue, it's more likely a case.

Yes, Morni, elaborate. What do you think, who killed with or without a clue?