Posts from TOURNEY "Sea Battle" - rules and discussion

The team should come up with the names themselves; the captain decides and chooses from the suggestions made by the participants, or comes up with something on their own. Regarding templates, Jebus shouldn't be used. Moz himself said that this template is not suitable for tournament games (or for a tournament exclusively using it). Those interested in why I think so can watch Moz's stream with Kontra. In general, regarding the choice of template, I'm all for a free choice.

In my opinion, Bedah is quite good.

- the number of points awarded for defeating a player with fewer ship decks = (n1+n2)/2,
where n1 is the number of ship decks of player 1
n2 is the number of ship decks of player 2

according to this formula, it is more advantageous and, naturally, easier for a 4-deck ship to win against a 3-deck ship than against a 1-deck ship:
(4+3)/2=3.5
(4+1)/2=2.5

I suggest:
formula for victories over players with fewer decks: 1+0.25*(n1-n2)
where n1 is the number of decks of the ship with more decks
n2 is the number of decks of the ship with fewer decks

4-deck ship defeated 3-deck ship = 1+0.25*(4-3)=1.25
4-deck ship defeated 2-deck ship = 1+0.25*(4-2)=1.5
4-deck ship defeated 1-deck ship = 1+0.25*(4-1)=1.75

3-deck ship defeated 2-deck ship = 1+0.25*(3-2)=1.25
3-deck ship defeated 1-deck ship = 1+0.25*(3-1)=1.5

2-deck ship defeated 1-deck ship = 1+0.25*(2-1)=1.25

4-deck vs. 4-deck, 3-deck vs. 3-deck, 2-deck vs. 2-deck, 1-deck vs. 1-deck victory = 1

formula for victories over players with more decks: 1-0.25*(n1-n2)

1-deck ship defeated 2-deck ship = 1-0.25*(2-1)=0.75
1-deck ship defeated 3-deck ship = 1-0.25*(3-1)=0.5
1-deck ship defeated 4-deck ship = 1-0.25*(4-1)=0.25

2-deck ship defeated 3-deck ship = 1-0.25*(3-2)=0.75
2-deck ship defeated 4-deck ship = 1-0.25*(4-2)=0.5

3-deck ship defeated 4-deck ship = 1-0.25*(4-3)=0.75

No need for a list.
Players in the list are ranked from strongest to weakest. If a player is already chosen by another captain during a draft, Will "takes" the next player on his list according to his ranking...

We're playing on version 6.6:
"FOR" - KillAndAction, Adv, DanielM, G_L, Noom, Yaughen, alex_nv, Leolopus, JonnyP.
"AGAINST" - Vip.rus, alijvit (responded to me in ICQ).
"ABSTAINED" - BOLIVAR.
Will abstained from voting (responded to me in ICQ).

Did not express their opinion: Элементаль Бога, Boez., ekzekut, Bradiaga, Stefandmy, Y11, dmitrik, ElfElite.

Please, don't forget to register me. As for the version - since I don't understand the difference yet - I'll abstain, but I'm sure that 6.6 is better - Leha's mod changes are only for the better.

Playing on version 6.6:
"FOR" - KillAndAction, Adv, DanielM, G_L, Noom, Yaughen, alex_nv, Leolopus, JonnyP, Элементаль Бога, Boez., sir_moz.
"AGAINST" - Vip.rus, alijvit (responded to me in ICQ).
"ABSTAINED" - BOLIVAR, Kolobokk.
Will abstained from voting (responded to me in ICQ).

Did not express their opinion: ekzekut, Bradiaga, Stefandmy, Y11, dmitrik, ElfElite, kontr.

Total:
"FOR" - 12 participants
"AGAINST" - 2 participants
"ABSTAINED" - 3 participants

So, we're playing on 6.6.

There are 25 participants, apparently: so, 5 teams or something?

for teams of 5 ships (1-deck, 2-deck, 3-deck, 4-deck, 5-deck)

formula for victories over players with a smaller number of decks: 1+0.2*(n1-n2)
where n1 is the number of decks of the ship with a larger number of decks
n2 is the number of decks of the ship with a smaller number of decks

5-deck defeated 4-deck = 1+0.2*(5-4)=1.2
5-deck defeated 3-deck = 1+0.2*(5-3)=1.4
5-deck defeated 2-deck = 1+0.2*(5-2)=1.6
5-deck defeated 1-deck = 1+0.2*(5-1)=1.8

4-deck defeated 3-deck = 1+0.2*(4-3)=1.2
4-deck defeated 2-deck = 1+0.2*(4-2)=1.4
4-deck defeated 1-deck = 1+0.2*(4-1)=1.6

3-deck defeated 2-deck = 1+0.2*(3-2)=1.2
3-deck defeated 1-deck = 1+0.2*(3-1)=1.4

2-deck defeated 1-deck = 1+0.2*(2-1)=1.2

formula for victories over players with a larger number of decks: 1-0.2*(n1-n2)

1-deck defeated 2-deck = 1-0.2*(2-1)=0.8
1-deck defeated 3-deck = 1-0.2*(3-1)=0.6
1-deck defeated 4-deck = 1-0.2*(4-1)=0.4
1-deck defeated 5-deck = 1-0.2*(5-1)=0.2

2-deck defeated 3-deck = 1-0.2*(3-2)=0.8
2-deck defeated 4-deck = 1-0.2*(4-2)=0.6
2-deck defeated 5-deck = 1-0.2*(5-2)=0.4

3-deck defeated 4-deck = 1-0.2*(4-3)=0.8
3-deck defeated 5-deck = 1-0.2*(5-3)=0.6

4-deck defeated 5-deck = 1-0.2*(5-4)=0.8

5-deck vs 5-deck, 4-deck vs 4-deck, 3-deck vs 3-deck, 2-deck vs 2-deck, 1-deck vs 1-deck – victory 1

Isn't it time to assemble your teams, esteemed captains? ;)

And what can captains recruit now? Who is the captain?

What's the harm in waiting a week? It might make the game more interesting.

I'm all for waiting...

It's already been 2 weeks, looks like we'll have to wait another 2!

When will the tournament start? And what are we waiting for?

There are 25 participants, which means 5 teams of 5 participants each. I understand there are 4 team captains: dmitrik, ekzekut, will, sir_moz. The fifth spot is open. Let's decide on the 5th captain, conduct recruitment, the captains decide on team names, the judges determine the order of games between the teams, and the captains provide the order of players for pairing and lists by faction. And that's basically it...

As many as you want – North, AD, Danil, Yura...
I think ADV is the best.
And, in my opinion, the best captains are Will, Dmitrik, Exz, ADV, and North.

As many as you want - North, AD, Danil, Yura...
I think ADV.

That's the problem. No one wants to be the captain.
The deadline for team recruitment is Monday.

AD should be the fifth captain, in my opinion. Based on skill, he is the strongest among all the candidates mentioned by Stefan. If he isn't a captain, the team he joins will immediately gain a significant advantage, just like in the previous team competition, IMHO.

I think ADW should be the fifth captain. Based on skill, he's the strongest of all the candidates Stefan mentioned. If he's not the captain, the team he joins will immediately gain a significant advantage, just like in the last team competition, IMO.

+

Randomly generate the teams, IMO.
Just divide the strong players equally among the teams.