Auto-translated
I'll be doing this for the third time, just for kicks. =)
New here? I'm Roha — want a quick tour?
I'll be doing this for the third time, just for kicks. =)
Zubr, let's remove the notes, hints, and fuel; let's keep only the clues, investigators, protectors, and doctors (which is also very important, as it provides guaranteed non-mafia roles, a fact that players often overlook!). Let him be a blocker, if necessary!
How does this arrangement sound to you? I think it's perfect.
You're missing such a simple point that any GM has the right to run a game in the manner they deem necessary, and no one can forbid them from doing so; they are only dependent on the players' desire.
removing hints and baiting
But, oh my god, why does the Investigator call himself by name in a note and get nothing? Why?!
And now, gentlemen, I suggest banning those who are playing Mafia for the first or second time from hosting.
I think that’s too much. Maybe you should run classic games instead? Half of the players will drop out, and you’ll be playing as a team of 10 skilled players.
How can you convey information if hints are also not allowed?
Notes almost never affect anything; they are just a small addition.
This is complete nonsense. Yes, because I only did it once :(.
Yeah, Tox really went too far this time, don't pay attention to him. What matters most is not skill, but interest in the game.
Through their behavior. There's nothing complicated about it.
The notes have a very strong influence. It's only thanks to them, or rather, the manipulation in them, that the city is doing well. But it's doing well undeservedly. When, on the second day, there simply aren't enough players to execute a player, and it's difficult to gather the minimum required, that's not normal. And that's the main problem.
I wasn't talking about reducing the number of players for the settings, but about removing key roles and interesting features.
On the second day, I hinted. On the third day, if there hadn't been notes, I would have been executed as a negative player.
Yes, there is a lack of city activity. But please, give another example of when a city won thanks to notes.