Posts from Mafia 31. Twilight Dances. Auto-translated

Lol, Locky, you didn't even realize that Gill is suggesting a rational assessment of the situation, not just saying "Oh, Nereus was unfairly buffed, oh, heresy!" and continuing to grate on everyone's nerves.

Any thoughts on the topic?

Yes, but it contains offensive language directed at someone else, so I'll keep it to myself.

That’s right. No one here needs it.

But why would I risk so much to protect an innocent? The point is, I wouldn't care who I executed, as long as it wasn't one of my own.

What a giveaway!!1 He admitted that he's Mafia and is protecting Slonysh!11 Yes, I know how to read between the lines and I know everything!111 :smile04:

In general, the idea of silence and the Mafia protecting someone seems beautiful to me, but, no offense, it's stupid. Why? If I'm "not a good guy," I could easily frame: an angel, a golem, or an abbot. Why would I so obviously draw attention to myself? I might be bad at Mafia, but I would never let my team make such a mistake (and if they did it while I was away, I would reveal myself, because I would be ashamed to work with such noobs).
But it's very convenient for the Mafia to frame me like that. And then they can suddenly pretend to be innocent and start saying that the cunning Mafia decided to "protect" me in this way. It won't work, the Mafia are stupid if they think that there are only idiots in this town who will fall for any nonsense. And yes, since I don't see any point in it, I won't accuse those who fell for it of being Mafia.
Yes, by the way, if I'm an evil Mafia, why would I want Whispering to block me, while no one is paying attention to me? I'm not stupid, I don't want that kind of attention.

I'm for executing Slonysh. First, if she's an advisor, nothing will happen to her, and we'll be sure of her innocence. Second, if she's actually a golem, which is unlikely, it's not a big deal. A golem is a suicide anyway, since she protects everyone, and if anything, we'll figure it out from the newspaper whether she's a golem or not. So we have a good chance of eliminating the Mafia or exposing an innocent. The only downside is that we might waste a day on her, but we don't have any other candidates anyway.

My advice: forget all these "probabilities." Stop turning the game "Mafia" into a "Guessing Game."

P.S.: Blockers, go bang your heads against a wall! =/ (I've always wanted to write this, I'm tired of my favorite night-time role being used on me, especially when the person using it doesn't know what they're doing)
P.P.S.: Gil's intuition sucks, mine is better! I predict roles and always know all the Mafia, and I always stay silent for one reason: I give the Mafia a chance so that they don't lose completely! :cool: (I couldn't resist, I wanted to remember my past successes, when I knew my role before the role reveal, and after the first newspaper, I identified the Mafia, and then I stayed silent until the end of the game and actively eliminated the bad guys at the end)

Added 3 minutes ago
In general, I like the idea of the following group: Gil, Slonysh, Rimp/Lizard (both), Hostor (sorry, bro) - but since it's a bit too obvious and stupid, I won't suggest it.

Added 7 minutes ago
I could subtly hint at who I am right now (what? it works for me, I won't be modkilled for it), but I won't. Because if I do this stupid thing, the Mafia will definitely want to kill me. On the other hand, if you want, kill me, if it pleases you, but since you're not particularly smart, as I think, you're unlikely to figure out my role, so you're in for a surprise, lol. Although, if a crazy knight comes along, it won't end well, but I'll save other players from his stupidity. Okay, all the killers, come to me, let's dance! :cool:

Passions, passions! Execute Slonysh - 7 votes (Arandor, Morning, Xostor, WhiteLizard, WishmasteR, TaKo, Neyra) Execute Rimpel - 3 votes (Amko, Slonysh, Luis) Execute Neyra - 1 vote (Gil4) Execute Lizard - 1 vote (Rimpel) 8 votes are needed for execution.

Execute Rimpel - 3 votes (Amko, Slonysh, Luis)
Execute Neyra - 1 vote (Gil4)
Execute Lizard - 1 vote (Rimpel)

Mafia detected.

I think I've already explained why Rimpel should be executed, both yesterday and today. And you, first, write that Slonysh should be executed, and then

forget all these "probabilities"

That's how you should execute the one to whom only two pieces of evidence point, and not waste time executing someone unknown. If Slonysh is Mafia, she will reveal herself later anyway, or her accomplices will.

Gil, do you think they were protecting or testing Slonysha on the second night?
This is not a hint.

Kill Heaven - 13 votes (Slonysh, Gil, Ar, Amko, Vish, Luis, Hos, Morni, Ney, Liz, Kitz, Zedzi, Vervolka).
NNV - 1 vote (Gur).

Vote count for the second night, as requested by some.

Surprisingly, I currently trust Gil the most. The Mafia wouldn't act like that. And he's genuinely trying to logically and discreetly resolve the situation, rather than simply throwing someone under the bus. Hos also writes well, but he seems more suspicious.
Regarding the candidates for execution: Rimple is absolutely against it. Not only is he poisoned, but the clue is also – the key here isn't its simplicity, but the fact that it's a bit off, and I agree with Hos on that. We can assume that the fang is a planted clue, but it's also too simple (it's practically next to the main clue in the profile), and there was no reason for the Mafia to expose the archer so blatantly. I'm leaning towards the idea that the fang and the four elements are a single clue pointing to one detail in the profile.
Slonysh – I voted because there were no other candidates, but I think eliminating her is a big risk, and I'm not sure she isn't being set up by the Mafia.
Neira – I initially wanted to join Gil, but I realized that it's no less risky than with Slonysh.
However, Lizard seems like a pretty good candidate to me; the clue against him turned out to be quite complex, but right now, it's the best interpretation. Although he still won't be executed. By the way, where's Rimple with the proof of the white lizard?

Actually, I have my own suspicions about the Mafia, based on the notes from the second night, their behavior, and other things, but revealing them would either lead to a modkill or a knife/arrow in the back at night.

Learn to read between the lines.

Although I can't do it myself :(

Actually, I have my own theories about the Mafia, based on the notes from the second night, their behavior, and other things, but revealing them would either lead to a modkill or a knife/arrow in the back at night.

You're not revealing important information to the town because you're afraid for your life, which could be ended on any given night?

Are you withholding important information from the town because you fear for your life, which could be cut short at any moment?

Yes, I am afraid because I can bring more benefit while alive than by leaking dubious information that won't lead to anyone being punished, but tomorrow the mafia will use "Silver Crescent" and goodbye, town.

Another question: can the advisor see the Night Defense (ND) applied to their target if that ND is not displayed in the newspaper?

The Advisor receives an additional hint regarding the role.

in the profile, practically right next to the main one

The Mafia doesn't know what the main clue will be when they give out the additional clue; at least, they shouldn't know.
And in general, the profile is small. The clues will be close together. And Visi clearly doesn't like to spend a lot of time on clues and gives out easy ones.