Auto-translated
Currently, the following element of the main topic is being discussed: "
"A comparative analysis of pikemen and halberdiers with units of a similar level in other Castles."
Since units are one of the essential parameters of a Castle, this discussion is generally not considered irrelevant.
Now, let's move on to the topic.
There is no hero-specialist for pikemen in this Castle. By the way, I don't remember any specialists for the first level in the Elven, Elemental, or Titan Castle either.
The main parameters of a unit are its speed, HP, damage, attack-defense, special abilities, and quantity.
Regarding quantity, all Castles have approximately the same number of units, except for the Castle and the Rampart.
Special abilities... In general, only two units have them: master gremlins and upgraded fairies. Immunity to blindness in troglodytes and blocking cavalry bonus in halberdiers are less relevant.
Speed. Well, upgraded fairies and centaur captains are the fastest!
Now, let's talk about firepower.
My personal belief is that upgraded fairies are unmatched in this parameter. Retaliation strike + speed + flight.
However, there is an opinion that the Black Dragon Castle has the greatest firepower - troglodytes under the leadership of the specialist hero Shakti (often called the "Miner") perform wonders, especially on their own territory.
In this context, it is also impossible not to mention the phenomenon called "gremlin rush." The essence is quite simple: if there are two or three free gremlin recruits, they are upgraded in the Castle, and off they go. However, master gremlins should not be overestimated either - only 8 shots, low damage, and a modest amount of HP severely limit their application.
The firepower of pikemen and halberdiers depends primarily on the troops they are fighting against. If these are not ranged troops, their firepower is high, primarily due to their very high HP. It becomes much more difficult for them to deal with powerful ranged troops - a lot depends on the relative speed of the troops (which, in turn, depends on "their own territory"). By the way, the firepower of these units increases significantly under the leadership of Sir Mullich (in the opinion of many, this legendary hero from the Angel Castle is one of the best in the game).
Firepower of first-level troops.