Posts from Оценка HoMM V Tribes of the East

Perhaps the topic is a bit strange, but still, how do you rate this game, considering not only the expansions and the new storyline, but also the game as a whole?

I don't know who's developing the game's storyline, but they deserve special recognition! The plot and the world of Ashan are worthy of Tolkien himself!

The game is awesome!!! It's the best game I've ever played!!! I think everyone on this forum agrees... ;)

Knight of the Temple, I doubt the plot is worthy of Tolkien; it's far from perfect, although the idea isn't bad. Perhaps if the developers had created more cutscenes not using the game engine (like the ones we saw at the beginning and end of the original), it would have been more impressive. As it is, the plot is mediocre and doesn't aspire to anything more. Including the plot, I'm giving it 9 points instead of 10. The game isn't perfect, but I really liked the introduction of alternate upgrades, the Orc race, and the fact that the wheel has been improved; I definitely respect the developers for that. But still, not 10 points. By the way, the ratings from gaming magazines and websites are somewhat different. If I remember correctly, they range from 7.5 to 8.5, which is also not bad, but not 9. And I don't quite agree with the explanations for the ratings. 10 is usually a perfect game, or at least as close to perfect as possible, surprising with its plot, gameplay, and graphics. In short, a revolution. A description of the author's maximum rating would be quite suitable for 9 points, and so on. If it weren't for the explanations, I would confidently give it an 8, but I don't think the game is what is written in the rating description. Never mind, don't pay attention to me; these are just my nitpicks

What’s there to think about? 10 out of 10! This add-on brought only positive emotions and a lot of delight.

My rating on MY scale is 9/10. And according to the scale presented here, it's 10.

Excellent, but not perfect! There are some minor drawbacks!

In my opinion, the plot of Tribes of the East is a bit rushed. And so what if the title is appropriate in Dark Messiah, but there was no need to borrow characters from there. As a critic, I'd give it an 8.5-9, but as a fan, it's a 10!

The game is great; the campaigns are well-voiced (although a bit too quiet), the plot is decent, and it features the long-awaited orcs, alt-gates, Hottabych, and new abilities. 10! Respect to the developers!

The game is good, but I don't think it deserves a 10. In my opinion, the first part is the best, and it definitely deserves a 10.

Excellent game! Wonderful expansions, wonderful storyline! Keep it up!!!!

The game deserves a full 10 out of 10. There are minor flaws everywhere, but they are insignificant and can be ignored. In my opinion, the plot isn't the most important aspect; the main draw is the online gameplay, although you can also play against the computer. Moreover, the game seems to be bug-free; it hasn't crashed or frozen even once for me. So, 10 out of 10.

the game is great
the orcs' raw strength and their sentimentality towards children are awesome.

The game deserves a solid 10 out of 10. Minor flaws exist everywhere, so they can be overlooked. In my opinion, the plot isn't the most important aspect; the main draw is the online gameplay, and it's also enjoyable to play against the computer. Moreover, the game seems to be bug-free; it hasn't crashed or frozen even once for me. So, 10 out of 10.

What about the terribly quiet localization? The problematic game through Hamu and Ubisoft? The plot is actually a very important thing. Nowadays, it's hard to impress with graphics, but a game with an excellent plot is a rare gem. Even in Heroes, the campaign is very important, in my opinion. And there haven't been any truly good and intriguing ones, in my opinion. Maybe this is just a characteristic of the Heroes series itself?

The most important thing is the gameplay;) If we don't take into account the problems with localization, then IMHO, the game deserves 9 out of 10 points.