Auto-translated
But most old players, I'm sure, switched for a completely different reason.
IMHO they switched for the same reason they play Jebus Cross - lots of troops, sprinkled with goodies, you feel like a god, crushing everything in the first few days. PvP-like templates, on the other hand, are just geared towards results/sportsmanship; 2nd level, 9 stacks at the start objectively reduce randomness, auto-bans everywhere like in Europe.
Many anti-SoD-ites are like Hitler, the same negativity from bad roads in this your sectarian outdated Soviet-Rash.
Iamsamstan
Firstly, I'd start by saying that the top players in SoD and Hota are practically the same people, or thereabouts; this suggests that at the very least, the same people understand the gameplay of both versions better than others.
Secondly, regarding SoD's non-linearity, the vast majority plays on 6lm10a
Thirdly, (firstly) the Hota generator completely outperforms the SoD generator. Many people on streams don't even understand what a "block" on the road is and mistake any level 1-2 neutrals standing on the road for one, while in SoD there are blocks of strong monsters everywhere that are impossible to break through without losses.
Fourthly, I don't really understand why not make it 100% 3 stacks in SoD; after all, it makes the start easier for any Castle.
Sixthly, it's stupid to criticize one version or another, because everyone has already decided what to play, and those who say, I'm fundamentally for Hota and against SoD, are far fewer than those who are true SoD-ers.
It really does resemble a sect - the lack of optionality and the ability to disable Hota's innovations (as was implemented in WT - the ability to play WT under SoD).
The common principle everywhere was the same - the truest version is not the canon from 1999, but the version that is accepted in competitive tournaments.
No matter how many times I tried to force myself to switch to Hota, it only made me want to delete the game
So essentially an "improved SoD" had already been "created" multiple times - it's just that for various reasons the created versions don't satisfy everyone.
it's just old age
the ability to step out of your comfort zone and learn new things decreases every year