Stay alive!!! Auto-translated

Magnus, dude, explain it in a way that everyone can understand!
And regarding the topic, Rep, good job creating the thread (I would have done it myself, but you were faster :D).
We could hold a rating for "dead" Clans twice a year and remove certain Clans.

I'll write a separate post.
About the forum and one-day users On the one hand, as LEY says, we could delete one-day users who haven't appeared after their first visit for N months. But then the forum statistics might suffer, because only a small percentage of users remain active on this forum, and then new users are unlikely to appear, because think about it, if we have, say, 1,000 users instead of 7-8,000, few people will be interested in the section, and the Admin is unlikely to receive offers to place ads on the portal and will not receive money, which is very important for the forum, for its development, or for the Admin's morale, who will look at the forum in difficult moments and think that he did not waste the best years of his life on it.
now about the Clans
we could do it this way: since the minimum number of members in a Clan (if I'm not mistaken) is 4, after a certain period of time, check the last activity time of the Clan leader and members. If the last visit to the forum by the 4 people in the Clan was later than a certain time, then a letter should be sent to the Clan leader, and if he does not take certain measures, his Clan will be disbanded after a certain number of days. Also, their Clan activity will be checked, and if one of the above conditions is not met, the Clan will be disbanded

It could be done this way: since the minimum number of members in a Clan (if I'm not mistaken) is 4, after a certain period, the system could check the last activity time of the Clan leader and the Clan members. If the last visit to the forum by all 4 members of the Clan was later than a certain time, then a message should be sent to the Clan leader. If he doesn't take certain measures, his Clan will be disbanded after a certain number of days. Also, their Clan activity will be checked. If one of the above conditions is not met, the Clan will be disbanded.

This is roughly what is being suggested here. Only the conditions are different. But there are many disputes about this, and they are not always relevant.

I agree with your conditions. This would be a good policy. If other users approve, I will specifically send a message to the Creator to approve the new rules.
After that, Clans will be checked for activity, say, 2 times a month.

Well, let's try to analyze the activity of Clans based on these rules. We open the page List of coordinators, newsmakers, and Clan leaders. What do we see: Maaelgrim 27.06.2007 Clan "Guardians of Illiar" Prorock 13.04.2007 Clan "League of Tournament Soldiers" These are Clan leaders who haven't been on the forum for a long time. Let's look at the Clan composition: "Guardians of Illiar" KRuGeR1991 Last activity: 30.08.2007 20:31 Dice Last activity: 21.06.2007 02:51 Bladson Last activity: 27.07.2007 18:42 iseM@N Last activity: 14.05.2007 13:31 Here are the first four members of the "Guardians of Illiar" Clan... Hmm... Next: Clan "League of Tournament Soldiers" natasha Last activity: 04.11.2006 01:08 PALADIN Last activity: 23.11.2006 02:48 nprf Last activity: 07.12.2006 07:44 Pred Last activity: 29.11.2006 04:23 It's a complete mess here.... Of course, these aren't all the Clans. There is also the possibility that the leader visits the forum regularly, but the members don't... But if the leader doesn't visit the forum, then the Clan definitely won't be active. These are the first Clans that should be disbanded. Or there is an option for someone to want to revive the Clan; in that case, they can become its leader and recruit new players. If anyone is interested in one of the listed Clans and is willing to become its leader and recruit a new team, please write to me in private message or in this topic. Sincerely, Hacker

you're giving the clans to good owners at a reasonable price:D

well, you can still do something with the Iliar, but it's pointless to recruit tournament fighters if the clan members haven't participated in any tournaments this year, so it's better to disband the clan.

Who even needs them? No one will take them. Unless the KL themselves reappear and take them back, or other clan members do, which is unlikely. It's better to create your own clan with a decent name and so on, rather than taking these. P.S. + Haku. All clans should be checked like this.

Yes... an old song with a new twist...!!!!! First, you can't participate in tournaments, then we're just looking at each other's saves, and now you can't join clans... come on, guys!!!!! What will happen next - will we be banned from being on the same portal??? Tell me, what does this have to do with relatives or not relatives... what difference does it make????

Relatives are irrelevant,
you said you don't care about the restrictions imposed on clans (which seems irresponsible),
I just showed a simple example:smile42:,
and now I see that it does matter:smile26:

But overall, good job for stirring up the topic,
and now things are moving forward.

I'll repeat my thought: I'm against restrictions:smile16:,
but I'm for cleaning up inactive clans.


2Xaker
This topic proves
that the truth is born in a dispute.

I think the decision is optimal:smile49:

Is that it? Has everything died down already?)))

Is that it? Has everything died down?)))

Is there any point in continuing the scandal? It's no longer relevant. The users decided to forget about this idea... Hmm, it's strange, but there was a very big debate, and now all the discussion has ended. Everyone is waiting for something. Maybe it wasn't worth even starting the topic if they couldn't bring it to a conclusion.

And I haven't forgotten! It's just that the creator isn't available right now, so there's no point in writing anything yet! As soon as he starts appearing regularly, I'll resume all of this.

kekekeke

By the way, a whole year has passed. As I thought, 80% of the clans simply died out, and the remaining 20% are trying to appear active...

Guys, ask yourselves: do you really need this?

I checked the inter-clan tournaments subforum – there are only 8 topics, about 1 per month. Do you even play against each other?

In general, I said everything I wanted to say a year ago. Now it's up to you.

P.S. I'm glad that more thoughtful people are appearing. Raper pleasantly surprised me.

2 Rean
Can you “predict” anything else interesting?:)
I’m serious.

The Clan Regulations need to be revised. And all these nuances should be specified there.

Who will take care of this? As I understand it, the clan leaders together with the Creator, or the Creator alone? If so, the clan leaders should, in my opinion, write to the Creator about this.

Added 3 minutes later
Or they could resolve this issue by a direct majority (2/3) vote of the clan members. This might take a while, as it will be more difficult to reach a consensus – there will definitely be those who disagree – and some may not have the time or desire for it.

I can offer my "Clan Regulations" (though a bit later) =)). Maybe someone else can too =)). I would advise all clan leaders, and no one else, because there will be too many =).

If you want someone to value something, make it difficult for them to obtain. I'm talking about clan leaders right now. A leader is a position of honor and responsibility. The requirements for candidates should be appropriate, both in terms of their tenure and their tournament experience. I propose allowing clan creation only for people who have been registered for at least 3 months and have participated in at least 3 official portal tournaments. A prize-winning place in a tournament could be rewarded with a reduction of the "trial" period to 1 month and 1 tournament. The clan is automatically disbanded if none of its members have shown "heroic" activity in the last 3 months. "Heroic" activity is considered to be participation in portal tournaments, hosting them, creating maps for them, writing manuals, etc. Moderation, RPGs, and various contests do not count. Adopting even these simple requirements (for active clans) will sharply reduce the amount of "dead weight." Further requirements can then be made stricter.