Criteria for participating in the АК elections. — Tournament History

No ratings yet — be the first to rate!

Single choice Public votes

This poll is closed.

Registered for at least 3 months

11.4% 4 votes

Registered for at least 6 months

14.3% 5 votes

Played 10 online games in Heroes 3 across all Seasons on Volde

5.7% 2 votes

Played 15 online games in Heroes 3 across all Seasons on Volde

2.9% 1 vote

Played 20 online games of Heroes 3 across all Seasons on Volde

0% 0 votes

Posted at least 50 times on the Volde forums

0% 0 votes

Posted at least 100 times on the Volde forums

0% 0 votes

Organized at least one online (offline) tournament for Heroes of Might and Magic III on Volde

0% 0 votes

Organized at least one online (offline) tournament for Heroes III on any of the Resources

0% 0 votes

Must have played for at least 3 months and completed at least one official Heroes 3 tournament on Volde

31.4% 11 votes

Must have played for at least 3 months and participated in 15 online Heroes 3 matches on Volde across all Seasons

5.7% 2 votes

Salary is guaranteed for at least 3 months, and organizing at least one online (offline) Heroes 3 tournament on Volde is required

2.9% 1 vote

Salary no later than next year, and at least one official tour to G3 on any Republic between 2009-2010.

11.4% 4 votes

Salary: at least 3 months (or completed 100 posts on Volde) and played 15 online games in Hero 3 for all Seasons on Volde

0% 0 votes

Must have played for at least 2.5 months and participated in at least 20 online matches in Heroes 3 on Volde across all Seasons

5.7% 2 votes

A player who has completed at least 2 online Tournaments in Heroes 3 on Volde over the past year

2.9% 1 vote

Salary no less than 6 months, experience no less than 2 years, at least 3 trips to G during the last year on V, and at least 50 successful missions on V.

5.7% 2 votes

1
2
3
4
Next
Last

Statistics

Registered: 6/12/2007 8:51 AM UTC

Posts: 1,832

4/17/2010 10:51 AM UTC #1

Auto-translated

We ask players to submit suggestions for defining the criteria for participation in the AK elections. Based on the discussion, the final criteria will be determined by a poll from the proposed options. For example: - Played 20 games on the World of Xeen, regardless of the season; - Registered on the World of Xeen for at least six months.

С истиной где-то рядом...

Лето 2010.

Statistics

Registered: 10/12/2009 5:34 PM UTC

Posts: 526

4/17/2010 11:01 AM UTC #2

Auto-translated

my IMHO: 1. unwavering love for the game 2. a certain level of skill (including not only online experience but also some offline experience: analyzing save files specifically in this mode) 3. human qualities, i.e., an innate ability to avoid conflict, combined with a desire and ability to defend one's position privately and publicly, but also to listen to the opponent, understanding and taking into account all the constructive points in their arguments 4. the candidate must have free online time, of course, but if necessary, they can recuse themselves

"...the personal strengths and weaknesses of a leader are no true indication of the merits of his cause"

(с) Roger Zelazny

In reply to wowa

Statistics

Registered: 6/12/2007 8:51 AM UTC

Posts: 1,832

4/17/2010 11:07 AM UTC #3

Auto-translated

wowa

my IMHO:

1. unwavering love for the game
2. a certain level of skill (including not only online experience but also some offline experience: analyzing save files specifically in this mode)
3. human qualities, i.e., an innate ability to avoid conflict, combined with a desire and ability to defend one's position privately and publicly, but also to listen to the opponent, understanding and taking into account all the constructive points in their arguments
4. the candidate must have free online time – but if necessary, they can recuse themselves.

This refers to the criteria for a Voting Participant (not a potential Arbitration Committee Participant), as it has been decided that there will be no requirements for the Candidate, except for Registration on the Volde forum, Selection, and the Trust of the Voters.

С истиной где-то рядом...

Лето 2010.

Statistics

Registered: 12/30/2007 9:49 AM UTC

Posts: 1,084

4/17/2010 11:22 AM UTC #4

Auto-translated

15 games online regardless of season AND registration on HeroesWorld for at least 3 months.

Стратегия - искусство возможного.

Первое правило форума :
"Хвалу и клевету приемли равнодушно
И не оспаривай глупца" (с)

Новичкам: ВНИМАТЕЛЬНО перечитайте ВЕСЬ первый пост по нижеприведенной ссылке и 90% ваших вопросов отпадут( на остальные 10% с удовольствием отвечу):
Правила онлайн игр

Statistics

Registered: 10/12/2009 5:34 PM UTC

Posts: 526

4/17/2010 11:32 AM UTC #5

Auto-translated

Here, the criterion is, in my opinion, flexible – many don't play and haven't played online, even though they are experts in the game. Therefore, participation in forum life should also be taken into account: 10 confirmed match reports, or 100 posts on the online version 3 forum. (Option: 5 matches + 50 posts, 8 matches + 20 posts))) So, if you registered recently but are actively participating in the community, you will be rewarded accordingly and gain the right to vote. For the rest, it will accumulate over time. The idea isn't very good because it seems to count the total number of posts across all threads, but there are probably ways to address this.

"...the personal strengths and weaknesses of a leader are no true indication of the merits of his cause"

(с) Roger Zelazny

In reply to Loi

Statistics

Registered: 10/13/2008 12:10 AM UTC

Posts: 1,147

4/17/2010 11:34 AM UTC #6

Auto-translated

I was thinking of writing something along those lines too: so many games and so much time since registration, but then I thought and realized — what nonsense :). It’s some kind of stupid discrimination, protecting against who knows what. Do you think some evil HeroesWorld users will mass-produce clones (formally ask a bunch of acquaintances to register, etc.) just to spite you and vote against the current AK members?:eek: Or what? I don’t understand the motive. In my opinion, all HeroesWorld users should have the right to vote, and there’s nothing scary about that. Let’s start with the fact that if “random” people (including those who don’t play Heroes 3) come to the elections :), they’ll clearly be a minority and won’t make a difference. And seriously, who’s going to count games across all tournaments for each individual person:D?? And if there’s a trend of massive voting by complete newcomers, there’s nothing bad about that either, because they’ll most likely vote first and foremost for those who brought them in/helped them get started — and aren’t those the kind of activists we should be voting for?;)

Ибу ибуди - хуйдао муди - Шаг за шагом можно достигнуть цели (китайская мудрость)

Кто к нам с пером придёт, тот от пера и погибнет!:smile51:

In reply to wowa

Statistics

Registered: 3/16/2009 4:08 PM UTC

Posts: 517

4/17/2010 11:45 AM UTC #7

Auto-translated

wowa

my IMHO:

1. unwavering love for the game
2. a certain level of skill (including not only online experience but also some offline experience: analyzing save files specifically in this mode)
3. human qualities, aka an innate ability to avoid conflict, combined with a desire and ability to defend one's position privately and publicly, but also to listen to the opponent, understanding and considering all the constructive points in their arguments
4. the candidate must have free online time - but if necessary, they can recuse themselves))))))

Attention, where do such people live??? :D :D :D

In reply to КостяN

Statistics

Registered: 11/27/2007 1:22 PM UTC

Posts: 5,092

4/17/2010 11:52 AM UTC #8

Auto-translated

I don't think it's nonsense. Universal suffrage is a tricky thing — inefficient, not always predictable, and subject to all sorts of flash mobs, vote rigging, fleeting trends, etc.

So defining the concept of a "HeroesWorld citizen" would be useful, not just for these elections but also for future ones. The main criterion is that a person should not be here for just a day or two, but should be aware of how things work around here, what's customary, and what's generally going on.

A possible option — registration date no later than six months before the vote, at least 50 posts on the forum, and at least 2 online Heroes 3 tournaments played over the past year. These thresholds can be adjusted as needed, guided by the principle outlined in the previous paragraph.

In reply to Van

Statistics

Registered: 10/12/2009 5:34 PM UTC

Posts: 526

4/17/2010 11:53 AM UTC #9

Auto-translated

Haven

Attention, where do such people live??? :D :D :D

and what about Vic – doesn't he work too?)))))))))))))
at the same time, one shouldn't confuse the desire to avoid conflicts with the ability and willingness to engage in debate, even a heated one, where it is necessary ;)

P.S.: here – he appeared as confirmation of my words! :D :D :D

"...the personal strengths and weaknesses of a leader are no true indication of the merits of his cause"

(с) Roger Zelazny

Statistics

Registered: 9/8/2008 5:16 PM UTC

Posts: 1,957

4/17/2010 12:00 PM UTC #10

Auto-translated

20 online games and registration for at least 2.5 months.

Всё не так плохо как Вы думаете. Всё намного хуже!

In reply to Loi

Statistics

Registered: 8/31/2008 12:32 PM UTC

Posts: 2,198

4/17/2010 12:09 PM UTC #11

Auto-translated

Loi

15 online games regardless of the season and registration on HW for at least 3 months.

+1
I'll continue to say that the Arbitration Committee is not a governing body.
The Arbitration Committee is an organization that helps online players resolve disputes in their matches.
Therefore, those who need it should choose the members.

Statistics

Registered: 12/30/2007 9:49 AM UTC

Posts: 1,084

4/17/2010 12:11 PM UTC #12

Auto-translated

The main criterion is that the person should not be new here, but rather someone who has been around for a while, understands what's happening, and knows the rules and customs.

Yes. Based on this principle, you, Pasha, can make a specific decision instead of conducting a general poll, to avoid unnecessary discussion and maintain efficiency (10-15-22.6 games are not that crucial, and the same applies to other principles like being active on the forum...).

In reply to Hermit

Statistics

Registered: 11/14/2007 8:15 AM UTC

Posts: 1,493

4/17/2010 12:19 PM UTC #13

Auto-translated

Loi

15 online games regardless of the season and registration on HW for at least 3 months.

Hermit

20 online games and registration for at least 2.5 months.

I searched through the archives of HW tournaments, but I couldn't find 20 or 15 reports from Tatiana - if she doesn't deserve the right to participate in the elections, then who does?! :confused: (maybe I didn't search well enough).

Statistics

Registered: 9/8/2008 5:16 PM UTC

Posts: 1,957

4/17/2010 12:27 PM UTC #14

Auto-translated

AK is certainly not a governing body. No governance is needed; there is nothing to govern. When organizing each tournament, the organizer determines the course of its conduct, and after that, everything is governed by the rules. AK is a judicial body that helps online players resolve controversial situations and resolves them if participants cannot reach an agreement (requiring not just consultation, but intervention). Changes to the rules of online games are made by AK only based on the results of a vote by all players. It does not govern anything.

Added after 2 minutes

PReDS

I searched through the archives of the ХВ tournaments but still couldn't find either 20 or 15 reports from Tatyana in them — if she doesn't deserve the right to participate in the elections, then who does?!:confused: (maybe I didn't search well enough).

Regarding games — not necessarily on HW. It could probably be on other well-known resources: Бае, HP, at dreamcatcher's.

Всё не так плохо как Вы думаете. Всё намного хуже!