Ment
Auto-translated
The first one is better than the second.
But in general, I would rather go for the Shabeth/Sylvester version. The stats seem to work a little better there, in my opinion. Although, some combination of the first option with the Shabeth version would probably work well (in particular, I think it would be reasonable to introduce restrictions on certain builds depending on the stats).
And ideally... Koshe has already mentioned that there was an idea to abandon independently upgradeable stats altogether and tie everything to skills and abilities. Such a system could theoretically be made very flexible, but it requires a full skill tree and a huge amount of time to think it all through.
But in general, I would rather go for the Shabeth/Sylvester version. The stats seem to work a little better there, in my opinion. Although, some combination of the first option with the Shabeth version would probably work well (in particular, I think it would be reasonable to introduce restrictions on certain builds depending on the stats).
And ideally... Koshe has already mentioned that there was an idea to abandon independently upgradeable stats altogether and tie everything to skills and abilities. Such a system could theoretically be made very flexible, but it requires a full skill tree and a huge amount of time to think it all through.