Skip to content

Which came first: matter or spirit?

User Avatar
#42
Auto-translated
Berserk;81237
Let matter appear first. Billions of years pass. Matter remains as it was... dead, gloomy, chaotic...
(.....here is the atheist's tale about the possibility of life appearing from dead matter) - Gentlemen! You believe that life can emerge from the dead, and at the same time, you say that the Spirit cannot exist before matter??? Your religion is even less plausible than ours!!!

I will give my old example. Let matter be a two-dimensional space. We live here and cannot (in any way) imagine anything outside of it. Suppose the Spirit lives in a three-dimensional space; do you think it can be outside our plane? Of course, it can! And yet, with no experience living in a two-dimensional space, it is impossible to prove that a three-dimensional space exists! Remove your two-dimensional plane; the one who lives in a three-dimensional space will still remain! This is the most illustrative example I can give.

Added 8 minutes later
So, something or someone can easily be outside of something, and that's it!
Quote:
"Everything we see is what we know. The rest are various manifestations of private experience, multiplied, interpreted, and accepted on faith by some part of humanity."

Mr. Ganymede is wrong again, and terribly so!!!

1) Do you know that vision is 90% a purely psychological process?
2) Do you know that what our eye receives is not the whole image; there is a black spot that we do not receive, but the brain completes the image based on experience and its algorithms?
3) Do you know about millions of visual illusions, tests, which line is longer, what is further away, where vision deceives us?
Now, answer: how can you make such a critical statement, relying on such a terribly imperfect device for obtaining information, and even more so, the Truth??? I prefer to use logic rather than believe my eyes.
Logic, then logic. Let's consider the situation. A soul flies around the Earth. Since it is not in our plane, it cannot change anything here. Where did matter come from then? Situation 2. There was matter on Earth. It did not think, but it reacted to certain events. What prevents a spirit from inhabiting such matter (for non-atheists), or why can't this organism become more complex and react differently to stimuli, with variations, and eventually become a human (for atheists)?
Умирает не тот, кто устал, а тот, кто остановился.

Statistics

Welcome our newest member: artem