The Tudors

Therefore, only negative arguments can be used to criticize Tox's writings and develop his ideas.

Great. Let's not listen to Tox; we have our own heads on our shoulders, after all. Do you think he voted against Calypso for no reason? He probably had his own logic, didn't he?

Because, for the most part, peaceful players execute other peaceful players – this is a well-known fact.

It's not just peaceful players who execute peaceful players on the first day; everyone does. It's beneficial for the Mafia to cast votes in different directions, including on the first victim. And you're trying to shift the blame onto the players who didn't believe Tox was Mafia or didn't vote for him for other reasons.

Added after 44 seconds

If you're a peaceful player, and you reveal yourself to the Sheriff as a Mafia member, there's a high chance the Mafia will target you. They probably know you're peaceful and, in effect, have been "checked," so they don't need you. Thus, you ruin the check.

This is actually a reasonable point.