Skip to content

Mafia: general discussions.

User Avatar
#1085
Auto-translated
I suggest we deal with these points right now:
Leang
Thank you all for the game. I liked everything except for a few moments.
First - Arandor broke the rules, plain and simple. We are not playing psychological Mafia where such moves are permitted.
Second - Hostor leaking my role. It seems to me that only a foolish person, or someone who wasn't following the game, would fail to guess my role after his post. I also believe that this should not be repeated in future games (by the way, after this, I saw skipping my turn as the only way out for myself, so as to possibly make someone a suspect for the mask).
Third - I am against replacing players with those who have already been eliminated.To avoid further violations, such as revealing one's status, the rules should be supplemented immediately.
Also, I would like to reach a decision regarding the second point. For example, I consider this a gross violation, while Hostor completely disagrees that it is any kind of rule violation at all.
The situation: a recruiter who recruited a player, while on the verge of execution, writes a sentence in their post that names the recruit in direct "veiled" text. In this case, the recruit was the maniac (all players are aware of this from the newspaper). In other words, the recruiter simply reveals someone else's role during the game day, as if just "hinting." Furthermore, the revealed maniac has no chance for victory, firstly, and for a normal game, secondly. It is as if the entire Mafia lineup had been published in the newspaper.
The third point should be at the GM's discretion, but in my opinion, it is still undesirable.

Стартовый пост - Квенты - Разное - Список НПС - Турнир -
Резара - Аксель - Орвальд - ЭмилияСтэфания - Амвросий - ЛестерАльсираАлария